Understanding The Challenges Of Bills Becoming Laws

The legislative process is long and complicated, with many steps, and lawmakers' bills are often introduced with the knowledge that they have no chance of becoming law. For a bill to become a law, it must be introduced, moved to committee, have witnesses called, undergo committee action, floor action, a vote, and be presented to the President for approval. This process can be killed, delayed, or changed at any step.

The process is long and complicated

The process of turning a bill into a law is long and complicated. It involves multiple stages and can be terminated at any step. The process begins with the introduction of a proposal in one of four forms: the bill, the joint resolution, the concurrent resolution, and the simple resolution. The bill is the most commonly used form. Bills may be introduced by any member of the House of Representatives or the Senate, except for money bills, which can only be introduced by the House. The proposal is then referred to the appropriate committee or committees, where it is intensively considered and the public is given a chance to be heard. The committees may seek input from relevant departments, agencies, and the Government Accountability Office. They may also hold public hearings, during which witnesses testify either voluntarily or by subpoena. After hearings are completed, the subcommittee considers the bill and votes on whether to report it favorably to the full committee. If the full committee also votes to report the bill favorably, it is sent back to the House or Senate, where it can be amended and then voted on. If the bill passes, it is sent to the other chamber to be approved. If it is amended, it is returned to the first chamber for approval of the amendments. Once a bill has been approved by both chambers, it is sent to the President for approval. The President can sign the bill, veto it, or take no action for ten days, in which case the bill becomes law unless Congress is adjourned. The process of turning a bill into a law involves multiple steps and can be derailed at any point, making it long and complicated.

It has many steps

The process of turning a bill into a law is long and complicated, with many steps that can kill, delay, or change the bill. The process begins with the introduction of a bill, which can be done by any member of Congress. The bill is then moved to a committee, where witnesses are called and action is taken. Following this, the bill goes through floor action, a vote, and possibly a conference committee before being presented.

The first reading of a bill involves getting its title and number. The bill is then sent to the relevant committees, which provide intensive consideration and a forum for public input. The committees may also call for reports from relevant government departments and agencies. After this, the bill is considered by the full committee, which may involve further referral to subcommittees. The committee will then vote on whether to report the bill to the House, with or without amendments.

If the committee votes to report the bill to the House, a committee report is written, describing the purpose and scope of the bill and any amendments. The report is then filed and sent to the Government Printing Office for printing and distribution.

The bill is then placed on the House Calendar or the Union Calendar, depending on its nature. It can then be called up for consideration by a member of the committee that reported it. The bill is then considered and debated in the House, possibly involving referral to the Committee of the Whole House. Amendments may be offered, and a vote is taken.

If the bill is amended and passed by the House, it is then sent to the Senate for consideration. The Senate gives the bill the same detailed consideration, possibly referring it to its own committees. The Senate may agree to the House's amendments, request a conference, or further amend the bill.

If the Senate amends the bill, it is returned to the House for action on the Senate's amendments. The House may agree to the amendments, request a conference, or further amend the bill.

If a conference is requested, conferees are appointed by both Houses to resolve the disagreeing votes. The conferees meet and negotiate, possibly holding open meetings. They then make recommendations in a report, which is sent to both Houses for a vote.

If the conference report is agreed to by both Houses, the bill is enrolled for presentation to the President. The Enrolling Clerk meticulously prepares the final form of the bill, reflecting all amendments agreed to by both Houses. The enrolled bill is then sent to the President for approval.

The President may approve the bill, in which case it becomes law. If the President does not approve, they may veto it, returning it to the House in which it originated with their objections. The bill can then be reconsidered, and if two-thirds of both Houses agree to pass it, it becomes law.

If the President does not return the bill with objections within 10 days (excluding Sundays) and Congress does not adjourn, the bill becomes law as if the President had signed it. This is known as a "pocket veto."

As this overview demonstrates, the process of turning a bill into a law involves numerous steps, providing ample opportunity for the bill to be killed, delayed, or changed.

Lawmakers introduce bills they know have no chance of becoming law

The introduction of a bill is just the first step in a lengthy legislative process. For a bill to become a law, it must pass through multiple committees, undergo revisions, and be approved by both houses of Congress. This process can be time-consuming and complex, and it provides ample opportunity for a bill to be killed, delayed, or changed. Introducing a bill does not guarantee its success, and lawmakers may be aware of this from the outset.

Additionally, the introduction of a bill can serve as a political statement or a way to gain support from constituents. Lawmakers may introduce bills that align with their campaign promises or address specific concerns raised by their constituents. By introducing these bills, lawmakers can demonstrate their commitment to certain issues, even if the bills have little chance of becoming law.

In some cases, lawmakers may introduce bills to gain political leverage or to make a point. These bills may be used as bargaining chips in negotiations or to draw attention to a particular issue. Introducing a bill can be a way for lawmakers to exert influence and shape the legislative agenda, even if the bill itself is unlikely to pass.

Furthermore, the introduction of a bill can be a starting point for discussion and debate. By bringing a bill to the floor, lawmakers can initiate conversations and spark dialogue on important topics. This can lead to amendments to existing laws or the development of new legislation that has a better chance of success.

It is important to note that the introduction of a bill is just the beginning of the legislative process, and there are many factors that can influence its outcome. Lawmakers may introduce bills with the understanding that they may not become laws, but they can still serve a purpose in the political landscape.

Bills are killed, delayed, or changed

A bill can be killed by not acting on it during the last 10 days that Congress is in session, known as a "pocket veto". Bills can also be delayed or changed by being sent to multiple committees for consideration, or by being amended. Amendments can be proposed by either the House of Representatives or the Senate, and can be substantive or procedural in nature.

The legislative process is designed to give all sides a chance to be heard and to make their views known. This can result in the notable improvement of a bill by amendment before it becomes law or in the eventual defeat of an unadvisable proposal.

Sponsors must be willing to bargain and compromise

The legislative process is long and complicated, with many steps, and at any stage, a bill can be killed, delayed, or changed. To successfully navigate this process, sponsors must be willing to bargain and compromise. This is because the process is designed to allow all sides to be heard and make their views known. The fact that a proposal cannot become a law without consideration and approval by both Houses of Congress is an outstanding virtue of the bicameral legislative system.

The open and full discussion provided under the Constitution often results in the notable improvement of a bill by amendment before it becomes law or in the eventual defeat of an inadvisable proposal. Sponsors must be willing to engage in this back-and-forth, to listen to the views of other members of Congress, and to make changes to their bill if they want it to pass.

The process also requires sponsors to be persistent. They must be willing to see the process through to the end, which can take a long time. It is not enough to simply introduce a bill; sponsors must be prepared to defend and promote it at every stage of the process. This includes being open to making changes to the bill along the way.

In addition, sponsors must be strategic. They must be able to read the room and understand when it is necessary to stand firm and when it is necessary to compromise. They must also be able to build coalitions and gain support for their bill. This may involve bargaining and making concessions to gain the support of key members or groups.

Overall, the legislative process requires sponsors to be willing to bargain and compromise if they want their bill to become a law. This is an important part of the democratic process, ensuring that all sides are heard and that laws are carefully considered before being enacted.

Frequently asked questions