The Path To Citizenship: Immigrants' Legal Challenges

Immigration is a complex and highly regulated process, and for many undocumented immigrants, there is no clear path to citizenship. While there are several routes to legal immigration, including employment, family reunification, or humanitarian protection, each avenue has strict eligibility criteria and numerical limitations. For instance, employment-based immigration requires a job offer from a US employer, and only certain highly skilled professions qualify. Similarly, family-based immigration is restricted to specific close relationships, and sponsors must demonstrate an income above the poverty line. Obtaining asylum is also challenging, as individuals must prove they have a credible fear of persecution based on specific criteria. Furthermore, undocumented immigrants who entered the US without inspection or overstayed their visas face significant barriers to obtaining legal status. If they leave the country to apply for a visa, they may be barred from re-entry for up to ten years. The absence of a clear pathway to citizenship for undocumented immigrants highlights the need for comprehensive immigration reform that addresses the complexities of the issue.

Immigration laws are restrictive and make obtaining legal status impossible for many undocumented immigrants

Immigration laws in the United States are restrictive and make obtaining legal status difficult for many undocumented immigrants. The US immigration system is highly regulated and subject to numerical limitations and eligibility requirements. Most undocumented immigrants do not have the necessary family or employment relationships to qualify for legal status. Even those who pay taxes, work hard, and contribute to their communities often have no way to adjust their status unless Congress creates a new pathway to legal status.

There are three main routes to immigrate to the US temporarily or permanently: employment, family reunification, or humanitarian protection. For employment-based immigration, foreign workers typically need a job offer from an eligible US employer, and the qualifying professions for permanent immigration usually require high levels of education and professional experience. For family-based immigration, US citizens and lawful permanent residents can petition for their spouses, parents, children, or siblings to join them, but there are annual numerical limits for most categories outside of immediate relatives. For humanitarian protection, individuals must demonstrate a well-founded fear of persecution based on specific criteria, and there is an annual cap on the number of refugee admissions.

Undocumented immigrants who entered the US without inspection are generally not eligible to obtain green cards while still in the country. Even if they are eligible for a visa, they usually need to leave the country and may face significant bars to re-entry, such as being barred from re-entry for three to ten years. The process of obtaining legal status can be complicated, costly, and uncertain, often keeping families apart for lengthy periods.

Furthermore, restrictive state-level immigration policies can directly restrict access to social safety-net programs, health care services, and other resources. They can also generate stress and anxiety among immigrant communities due to increased surveillance and the risk of deportation. Restrictive legislation may require health care workers to report patients suspected of being undocumented, creating a barrier to care for undocumented immigrants. Overall, the restrictive nature of US immigration laws and policies makes obtaining legal status challenging for many undocumented immigrants.

There is no line for undocumented immigrants to become citizens

Immigration to the United States is generally restricted to three routes: employment, family reunification, or humanitarian protection. Each of these avenues is highly regulated and subject to eligibility requirements and numerical limitations.

There is no "line" for the majority of undocumented immigrants to achieve legal status. Most do not have the necessary family or employment relationships to qualify for a visa, nor can they access humanitarian protection. Even those who pay taxes, work hard, and contribute to their communities have no way to "get in line" unless Congress creates a new pathway to legal status.

Undocumented immigrants who entered the US without being legally admitted are generally ineligible to obtain green cards while remaining in the country. Leaving the country to obtain a visa can result in significant negative consequences, including being barred from re-entering the US for three to ten years.

While there are some paths to legal status for undocumented immigrants, such as marriage to a US citizen or lawful permanent resident, asylum, or the U Visa for victims of crime, these options are limited and often complex.

The lack of a clear pathway to citizenship for undocumented immigrants has led to calls for legislative reform to address this issue.

The process of becoming a citizen is long and costly

The process of becoming a citizen can be long and costly. In the US, there are an estimated 11.1 million unauthorized immigrants, 60% of whom are from Mexico, and 20% from other Latin American countries. Many of these immigrants would prefer to live and work in the country legally, but the current immigration legal framework restricts lawful immigration to only a few narrow categories of people.

There are three main paths to becoming a "legal" immigrant in the US: work sponsorship, family sponsorship, or asylum. Each of these categories is hard to qualify for, and there are long waiting periods to obtain visas. For example, only 5,000 of the 140,000 reserved green cards given out annually for immigrant workers are for immigrants working in a job that does not require a college degree. Similarly, there are fewer than 500,000 visas available for family sponsorship each year, which can result in waiting periods of decades. Obtaining asylum in the US can also be difficult, as applicants must prove they have a "credible fear" of their home country, and the majority of asylum applicants are rejected.

The process of becoming a citizen is made even more challenging by the fact that undocumented immigrants cannot apply for a green card within US borders. If they leave the country and apply at a US consulate, they will be ineligible to return. If an immigrant has lived in the US without authorization for more than six months, they are barred from re-entry for three years, and if they have lived in the US without authorization for more than a year, they are barred for ten years. These bans apply even if the immigrant is married to a US citizen or has US citizen children. While it is possible to ask the government to waive these bars, doing so is difficult and requires meeting specific conditions.

Even for those who are able to obtain a green card, the path to citizenship is not straightforward. To become a US citizen, an individual must be a green card holder, or lawful permanent resident, for at least five years. If there has been a violation of status at any point, such as entering the country illegally or staying on an expired visa, it could derail the process. In most cases, if an undocumented individual wants to obtain a green card, they must return to their country of origin, which can mean leaving their spouse or children behind.

The process of becoming a citizen in the US is complex and costly, both financially and emotionally. It involves navigating a web of legal requirements and restrictions, and can take many years to complete. For many immigrants, the prospect of becoming a citizen may seem out of reach.

Undocumented immigrants are often ineligible to obtain green cards while inside the country

Immigration to the United States is generally limited to three routes: employment, family reunification, or humanitarian protection. Each of these avenues is highly regulated and subject to eligibility requirements. As a result, most undocumented immigrants do not have the necessary family or employment relationships and often cannot access humanitarian protection.

Unauthorized immigrants who entered the United States without being legally admitted and inspected are generally not eligible to obtain green cards while still inside the country. Even if there is a visa available, they are barred from "adjusting status" and getting a green card without first leaving the country because of how they entered.

However, leaving the country to obtain a visa can have significant negative consequences. Any person who has been out of status for more than 180 days but less than a year is barred from re-entering the United States for three years. Those out of status for more than a year are barred for 10 years. Although waivers to these bars exist, they are difficult to obtain. This means that even when a visa is available, undocumented immigrants must risk spending up to 10 years away from their families in the United States before being allowed to re-enter.

One option for undocumented immigrants who have lived in the United States for at least 10 years is "cancellation of removal". This remedy allows non-citizens who are already in immigration court proceedings, fighting against removal from the United States, to request relief if they have been in the country for 10 years or longer. If approved, the immigration judge will grant the person the right to a green card. However, the applicant must also show that their removal from the United States would cause "exceptional and extremely unusual hardship" to their U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident spouse, parent, or child. They must also demonstrate "good moral character" and that they have not been convicted of certain crimes or violated certain laws.

Another option for undocumented immigrants to obtain a green card is through marriage to a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident. If the immigrant's entry was not lawful, the process becomes more complicated. By law, if the foreign spouse and children entered the U.S. without inspection and remained in the country, they must leave and conclude their immigration process through U.S. consulates abroad to obtain an immigrant visa (green card). If they resided in the U.S. unlawfully for at least 180 days, they could be barred from re-entry to the U.S. for 3 to 10 years once they leave. However, they may be able to qualify for a waiver of the 3- and 10-year bars if they can demonstrate that their absence from the U.S. would cause an "extreme and unusual hardship" to their U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident spouse or parent.

In conclusion, while there are some options for undocumented immigrants to obtain green cards while inside the United States, these paths are often complex and challenging to navigate. Most undocumented immigrants do not have access to the necessary family or employment relationships, and leaving the country to obtain a visa can result in significant negative consequences.

Leaving the country to obtain a visa can result in significant negative consequences

Moreover, overstaying a visa or being unlawfully present in a country can significantly affect an individual's ability to remain or apply for legal status in the future. For example, in the US, overstaying a visa for more than 180 days but less than a year can result in a three-year ban on re-entry, while overstaying for a year or more can lead to a ten-year ban. Such unlawful presence can also negatively impact future visa applications, as consular officers may view it unfavourably.

In addition to the risk of being barred from re-entry and the negative impact on future visa applications, leaving the country to obtain a visa can also result in other consequences. For instance, individuals who have overstayed their visas or have been unlawfully present may become ineligible for certain visas or immigration benefits. They may also face deportation and removal proceedings if apprehended by immigration authorities.

Overall, leaving the country to obtain a visa can have significant negative consequences, including the risk of being barred from re-entry, negative impacts on future visa applications, ineligibility for certain visas or benefits, and the possibility of deportation.

Frequently asked questions