Undocumented Immigrants: Breaking Us Laws?

Undocumented immigrants in the US are a highly debated topic, with some arguing that they are breaking the law and should be deported, while others advocate for their rights and path to citizenship. According to US law, undocumented immigrants are those who enter the country unlawfully or stay beyond the expiration of their visas. While they do have certain rights, such as due process, protection from unreasonable searches, and the right to a safe work environment, they also face significant restrictions and challenges. The debate around undocumented immigration centres on issues of national security, economic impact, and the rule of law.

The strain on public funds and services

Undocumented immigrants are a drain on public funds and services, according to some sources. Accommodating the needs of endless numbers of poor, unskilled illegal entrants undermines the quality of education, healthcare, and other services for Americans. They crowd classrooms, consume already limited affordable housing, and increase the strain on precious natural resources.

Undocumented immigrants are not eligible for most federally funded safety net programs. They are barred from receiving benefits from Medicare, non-emergency Medicaid, or the Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP). They also cannot participate in health insurance marketplaces and are not eligible to receive insurance subsidies under the Affordable Care Act. They contribute up to $12 billion annually to the Social Security Trust Fund but are ineligible to receive any Social Security benefits.

Unauthorized immigrants are generally ineligible for federally funded public benefits, including programs such as Medicaid, food stamps (Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program), and cash assistance programs such as Supplemental Security Income (SSI) and Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF). They are, however, eligible for some programs, including emergency Medicaid, primary and preventive health care at federally qualified health centers, free or reduced school lunches, and short-term access to shelters and soup kitchens in emergency situations.

Mixed-status families, where at least one member is unauthorized, can be adversely affected by restrictions on noncitizens' access to certain public benefit programs, even when the US-citizen child is fully eligible. For example, while SNAP allows eligible individuals to apply for food stamps even if their household includes someone with an ineligible immigration status, the benefit amounts are adjusted to match the number of eligible household members. This means that US-citizen children in mixed-status households receive a lower amount per person.

Unauthorized immigrants are estimated to pay around $11.6 billion a year in taxes. They contribute more in tax revenue than they take in government benefits. A 2017 report from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine found that immigration "has an overall positive impact on the long-run economic growth in the US".

The impact on communities

Unauthorized immigration has a significant impact on communities in the US, with an estimated 11 million individuals living in the country without legal status as of 2022. This figure represents a slight increase from 10.5 million in 2021 but remains below the peak of 12.2 million in 2007.

Unauthorized immigrants are often working, paying taxes, and contributing to their communities in various ways. They are more likely to be of working age, ranging from 25 to 64, and fill jobs that Americans are less interested in pursuing. For example, they account for 50% of all hired field and crop workers, making them essential to American farms. They also contribute to other key industries such as construction, hospitality, and agriculture.

The presence of unauthorized immigrants can have both positive and negative effects on communities. On the one hand, they contribute to the local economy, pay taxes, and fill labor shortages. They are also less likely to commit crimes than native-born citizens. On the other hand, unauthorized immigration can place a strain on public resources, including education, healthcare, and housing. It can also lead to increased competition for jobs and potentially drive down wages, particularly in low-skilled sectors.

The impact of unauthorized immigration varies across states, with Nevada, Texas, Florida, and New Jersey having the highest shares of unauthorized immigrants in their workforce. At the same time, in states like Maine, Mississippi, Montana, and West Virginia, less than 1% of households include an unauthorized immigrant.

The debate around unauthorized immigration continues, with opponents expressing concerns about crime, social burdens, and the importance of following the formal immigration process. Proponents, on the other hand, highlight the economic contributions of unauthorized immigrants and the fact that they commit less crime than natives.

The security risks

Unauthorized immigration to the United States is a highly debated topic, with opponents citing concerns about crime, national security, and potential social and economic burdens. However, the notion that unauthorized immigration poses a security threat is largely subjective and constructed, rather than an objective danger. Here are some perspectives on the security risks associated with unauthorized immigration:

Impact on Societal Security

Unauthorized immigration is often perceived as a threat to societal security, particularly when immigrants are seen as challenging the cultural, linguistic, or religious identity of the receiving country. This perception varies depending on how a state defines itself and its values. Some states may view multiculturalism as undesirable, while others embrace cultural diversity. The securitization of immigration as a threat to societal security can lead to racism, xenophobia, and social disintegration by excluding and "othering" immigrants.

Economic Security Concerns

Unauthorized immigration is sometimes argued to pose a threat to a country's economic security. The "brain drain" theory suggests that developing countries lose highly skilled workers to developed nations, resulting in undesirable economic consequences. However, this ignores the concept of "brain gain," where developing countries benefit from the return of skilled migrants with enhanced knowledge and experience. Additionally, remittances sent by immigrants to their home countries contribute significantly to economic growth and poverty reduction.

Immigration is also perceived to strain the receiving country's labor market, taking away jobs from native-born workers and depressing wages. However, this perception is not supported by empirical evidence. Immigration often increases job opportunities and enhances the host country's economy by creating jobs and providing a workforce for sectors with labor shortages.

The influx of immigrants is also portrayed as a burden on social services, such as housing, education, and welfare systems. However, this perception is influenced by discourse that uses metaphors of "floods" and "invasions" to create a sense of fear and insecurity. While immigration poses fiscal challenges, the long-term economic benefits, such as the positive impact on the host country's economy and the development of the immigrants' home countries, should not be overlooked.

Internal Security and Terrorism

Unauthorized immigration has been linked to terrorism and heightened as a national security concern, especially after the September 11 attacks. Immigration policies and border control have become instruments in the "War on Terror," with increased scrutiny of foreign nationals and stricter immigration laws. However, this connection between immigration and terrorism is largely exaggerated and based on the failure to distinguish between immigrants and temporary visa holders, who constitute a small fraction of the foreign population. The perception of immigrants as a threat to internal security has led to racial profiling and the exclusion of immigrant groups, particularly those associated with Muslim or Arab identities.

Public Security and Criminality

Unauthorized immigration is often associated with increased criminality and is perceived as a threat to public security. While some studies show a correlation between high immigration rates and crime rates in certain areas, these links are often influenced by demographic factors rather than immigration status alone. Most research suggests that immigration does not lead to higher crime rates and that the correlation between immigration and criminality is weak or non-existent.

The legal rights of undocumented immigrants

Undocumented immigrants in the US are entitled to certain fundamental protections under the law, despite not having the same comprehensive liberties as US citizens. These rights are shaped by a combination of constitutional protections, federal laws, and court rulings.

Right to Due Process of Law

Undocumented immigrants in the US have the right to due process of law, as outlined in the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments of the US Constitution. This means they are guaranteed fair legal proceedings and protection against arbitrary denial of life, liberty, or property, regardless of legal status. This right has been reinforced by various legal precedents, such as Zadvydas v. Davis (2001), ensuring that undocumented immigrants receive the same judicial considerations as citizens in deportation or other legal matters.

Protection from Unreasonable Searches and Seizures

The Fourth Amendment, which protects individuals from unreasonable searches and seizures, also extends to undocumented immigrants. However, this protection isn't absolute, especially regarding immigration enforcement. Courts have balanced individual privacy rights with the government's interest in border security and immigration control.

The Right to Legal Counsel

The Sixth Amendment guarantees the right to counsel in criminal prosecutions, which also applies to immigration proceedings. However, the government isn't obligated to provide free legal counsel to undocumented immigrants in deportation proceedings. They must either retain an attorney or represent themselves, which can be a significant barrier for those unfamiliar with the legal system and lacking financial resources.

The Right to Be Paid Fairly

The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) prohibits employers from discriminating against workers based on their immigration status. Therefore, undocumented immigrants have the right to be paid the same wages for the same work as US citizens and legal residents, including overtime pay, minimum wage, and the same safety and health protections.

The Right to a Safe Work Environment

The Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA) requires employers to provide a safe and healthy work environment for all employees, regardless of legal status. Consequently, undocumented immigrants have the right to report workplace hazards and discrimination without fear of retaliation, and employers are prohibited from retaliating against them if they file OSHA complaints. Additionally, Title VII of the Civil Rights Act protects undocumented immigrants against employment discrimination based on race, colour, religion, sex, or national origin.

The Right to Be with Family

The right to family unity is articulated in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) and is particularly relevant in deportation cases that could result in the separation of children from their parents. However, this right is often weighed against the government's interest in enforcing immigration laws, potentially leading to family separations and emotional hardship.

The Right to Education

Under the landmark decision Plyler v. Doe (1982), undocumented children have the right to access public education from kindergarten through 12th grade, based on the Fourteenth Amendment's Equal Protection Clause. States cannot deny free public education based on immigration status, although undocumented students may face language challenges or fear deportation.

The consequences of deportation

Deportation is the forced removal of an immigrant from a foreign country, and it can have far-reaching consequences for the individual, their family, and the wider community.

Financial hardship

Deportation can lead to sudden and severe financial hardship for families. The loss of an income earner can result in families struggling to pay bills, put food on the table, and keep a roof over their heads. In some cases, adults go hungry so that their children can eat.

Disruption to children's lives

Children of deported individuals may experience a range of negative consequences, including anxiety, anger, aggression, withdrawal, fear, eating and sleeping disturbances, isolation, trauma, and depression. They may also have to take on jobs or increased responsibilities at home, disrupting their routines and relationships.

Emotional and physical health

The stress and trauma of being separated from a loved one can lead to extreme sadness, desperation, and even suicidal thoughts. Physical health may also be impacted, with deportation causing problems with eating and sleeping, as well as exacerbating chronic conditions like diabetes and hypertension.

Educational attainment

Deportation can disrupt a child's education, making it difficult for them to pay attention in school and perform academically. This can have long-term effects on their future success as adults.

Fear and mistrust

Communities affected by deportation may experience fear and mistrust, becoming less likely to participate in churches, schools, health clinics, cultural activities, and social services. This can have a ripple effect on the wider community and lead to further isolation and disengagement.

Legal and social consequences

Deportation can also result in legal and social consequences, including the loss of legal status or citizenship, and the risk of being targeted by immigration authorities. This can create a cycle of fear and further marginalization.

Community impacts

The effects of deportation are not limited to individuals and families but can also affect entire communities. The loss of community members can lead to a decline in social cohesion and trust, as well as a reduction in economic activity and contributions to public services.

Overall, the consequences of deportation are wide-ranging and can have long-lasting impacts on individuals, families, and communities. It is important to consider these consequences when discussing and implementing immigration policies.

Frequently asked questions