Law Corporations: Can Broker-Dealers Be Structured This Way?

The relationship between broker-dealers and the law is a complex one. In the United States, broker-dealers are subject to regulatory oversight by the SEC and must be registered with them, unless certain exemptions apply. For example, employees of an issuer may be exempt from registration as brokers for certain limited work selling the issuer's securities. Broker-dealers must also be members of one or more self-regulatory organizations, such as the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC), and may be subject to regulation under state blue sky laws. They are also often members of exchanges, including swap exchanges, and are often clearing members of clearinghouses. The relationship between broker-dealers and the law is further complicated by the fact that each state has its own requirements for individuals or firms conducting business as broker-dealers within that state. This raises the question of whether a broker-dealer can be a law corporation, with the power to create and enforce its own laws.

Broker-dealer registration requirements

Broker-dealer registration is a critical and complex step for financial services firms in the United States. It is essential for any firm or individual planning to conduct securities transactions in the country.

Registration Bodies

In the US, broker-dealers must register with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and become members of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA). The SEC is the federal agency responsible for enforcing securities laws and overseeing the registration process. FINRA is a self-regulatory organisation that regulates member brokerage firms and exchange markets.

Registration Requirements

To register with FINRA, firms must apply and meet certain membership standards. Applicants are asked to review and understand all of FINRA's substantive and procedural requirements prior to applying. These can be found in the FINRA Rule 1000 Series and FINRA Rule 1014, as well as on the FINRA website.

Additionally, applicants should review the applicable FINRA and SEC rules. The SEC provides a comprehensive guide to broker-dealer registration, including the laws, rules, and regulations.

Exemptions

Certain entities and individuals may not need to register, depending on the nature and scope of their activities. For example, employees and other associated persons of an issuer may be exempt from registration as brokers for certain limited work selling the issuer's securities. This is known as the "'issuer's exemption'" and does not apply to personnel who routinely engage in the business of buying and selling securities for the company.

Furthermore, the SEC has permitted certain financial institutions, such as credit unions, to make securities available to their customers without registering as broker-dealers. This is done through "networking" arrangements, where an affiliated or third-party broker-dealer provides brokerage services for the financial institution's customers.

State-Specific Requirements

It is important to note that each state has its own requirements for individuals or firms conducting business as broker-dealers within that state. State securities laws and regulations must be complied with, and these may differ from federal laws. As such, it is essential to understand the specific requirements of each state in which one intends to operate.

Broker-dealer regulation

The SEC provides a comprehensive guide to broker-dealer registration, outlining the specific requirements and processes. This includes the “issuer's exemption,” which exempts employees and associated persons of an issuer from registration for certain limited work selling the issuer's securities. However, this exemption does not apply to individuals who routinely engage in buying and selling securities for the company or receive compensation for such activities.

Additionally, broker-dealers must be members of the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC), unless their principal business is conducted outside the United States or involves the sale of specific financial products. The SIPC provides protection to customers of its members, insuring up to $500,000 per customer in the event of a member's liquidation.

Beyond federal regulations, each state has its own requirements for individuals or firms conducting business as broker-dealers within its jurisdiction. State securities laws and regulations must be adhered to, and licensed broker-dealers are often required to comply with local laws. Failure to comply with state regulations can result in legal repercussions, including the need to return raised capital to investors.

Furthermore, broker-dealers dealing with "penny stocks" have enhanced suitability and disclosure obligations to their customers. These obligations aim to protect investors from the higher risks associated with penny stocks, which are typically defined as any equity security with a transaction price below $5 and traded outside the major exchanges.

Overall, broker-dealer regulation seeks to maintain the integrity of the securities industry, protect investors, and ensure compliance with federal and state laws. By registering with the SEC and adhering to various regulatory requirements, broker-dealers can facilitate transactions, connect businesses with investors, and navigate the complex landscape of securities laws.

Broker-dealer as a legal entity

A broker-dealer is a financial entity that trades securities on behalf of clients and for itself. Broker-dealers act as brokers or agents when executing orders on behalf of their clients and as dealers or principals when trading for their own accounts. They perform a dual role, facilitating the free flow of securities in the open market and ensuring there is a market for the securities they trade for their clients.

In the United States, broker-dealers must generally register with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and become members of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA). Each state has its own requirements for individuals or businesses operating as broker-dealers within its borders, and state securities regulators can provide information on these requirements. The SEC provides a comprehensive guide to broker-dealer registration, covering the relevant laws, rules, and regulations.

Certain financial institutions, such as credit unions, are permitted by the SEC to make securities available to their customers without registering as broker-dealers. This is done through "networking" arrangements, where an affiliated or third-party broker-dealer provides brokerage services for the financial institution's customers.

Broker-dealers are essential in the financial industry, performing several critical functions. They provide investment advice to customers, facilitate trading activities, supply liquidity through market-making activities, publish investment research, and raise capital for companies. When acting as an agent of the issuing company, broker-dealers enter into a contractual arrangement, committing to distribute a certain amount of the securities offered to the public in exchange for an underwriting fee.

Overall, broker-dealers are financial entities that play a crucial role in facilitating securities transactions and providing investment-related services to their clients. They must adhere to various regulatory requirements and industry standards to ensure compliance and protect the interests of investors.

Compliance and legal repercussions

Additionally, every registered broker-dealer must be a member of the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC), unless their principal business is conducted outside the United States or involves the exclusive sale of investment company shares, variable annuities, or insurance. SIPC membership provides customer protection, ensuring that customers receive their cash and securities up to a certain limit in the event of the broker-dealer's liquidation. Failure to adhere to SIPC requirements can lead to financial losses for customers and damage to the broker-dealer's reputation.

Moreover, broker-dealers must comply with state-specific regulations. Each state has its own securities laws and requirements, and broker-dealers must navigate these varying regulations when conducting business across multiple states. Non-compliance with state laws can result in enforcement actions and legal consequences. For instance, specific state laws, such as California's Corporations Code Section 25110, outline unlawful activities related to the offer or sale of securities, and non-compliance can lead to legal repercussions.

Furthermore, broker-dealers must adhere to enhanced suitability and disclosure obligations when dealing with "penny stocks." These obligations ensure that customers are adequately informed about the risks associated with such investments. Failure to meet these obligations can result in regulatory action and legal claims.

Additionally, broker-dealers must supervise the securities activities of their personnel, including employees and independent contractors. Allowing unregistered entities to receive commission income on their behalf is prohibited. Proper supervision ensures compliance with regulations and helps prevent unauthorized activities that could lead to legal repercussions for both the broker-dealer and the associated individuals.

Broker-dealer registration exemptions

Broker-dealer registration is a complex process that varies depending on the nature of the business, the state in which it operates, and the specific securities being traded. While I cannot ascertain if a broker-dealer can be a law corporation, I can outline some exemptions from registration.

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has outlined several exemptions from broker-dealer registration requirements. These exemptions often depend on the nature of the business, the type of securities being traded, and the state in which the business operates. Here are some key exemptions:

• Issuer's Exemption: Issuers, or companies issuing their own securities, are generally not considered "brokers" or "dealers" because they sell securities for their own accounts and not for the accounts of others. However, this exemption does not apply to personnel who routinely engage in the business of buying and selling securities for the company, especially if they are compensated for these activities.
• Municipal Securities Dealers: Firms that limit their securities business to buying and selling municipal securities for their own accounts must register as municipal securities dealers, not general-purpose broker-dealers.
• Financial Institutions: Certain financial institutions, such as banks, thrifts, and credit unions, have specific exemptions from broker-dealer registration. For example, credit unions can make securities available to their customers through "networking" arrangements with affiliated or third-party broker-dealers.
• M&A Brokers: Congress enacted an exemption from federal broker-dealer registration for M&A brokers involved in certain "control" transactions with eligible privately held companies. However, this exemption does not preempt state law broker registration requirements, and M&A brokers must still comply with state-specific regulations.
• Online Platforms: The JOBS Act added an exemption from broker-dealer registration for online platforms used to market securities in Rule 506 offerings, also known as "Regulation D portals."
• State-Specific Exemptions: Some states have their own exemptions from broker-dealer registration requirements. For example, California's Corporations Code Section 25110 outlines specific conditions under which the sale of securities in the state is exempt from certain registration requirements.

It is important to note that these exemptions may have specific conditions and limitations, and businesses should carefully review the relevant laws and regulations before relying on any exemption. Failure to comply with broker-dealer registration requirements can result in legal repercussions, including SEC enforcement actions and investor lawsuits.

Frequently asked questions