The Evolution Of City Laws: Understanding Urban Legislation

The ability of a city to make laws depends on the country and the type of government it operates under. In the United States, for example, cities can make laws, but these are known as ordinances and are limited to local issues not already covered by state or federal law, such as zoning, parking, and public health and safety. The process of creating a law typically involves the public and careful stewardship by clerks and councils. In Germany, the constitution grants certain rights to federated states, which are then delegated to local authorities, who have the power to pass local ordinances. In Japan, any prefecture or municipality may pass ordinances under Article 94 of the Constitution.

City ordinances

A city ordinance is a law, rule, or regulation enacted by a local government. They are established by a municipal authority, such as a city council or local government, and are considered the most authoritative form of action taken by a city council. Ordinances are drafted with the help of other officials, such as the city administrator or city manager. Once passed, they are included in a collection of laws referred to as city or municipal code.

The process of creating a city ordinance involves the public and careful stewardship by clerks and councils. Cities across the US rely on a similar parliamentary process to move from concern or opportunity to law (municipal ordinance). These steps ensure that the public is educated, informed, and involved in the creation of laws that affect their daily lives. In the US, there are two types of states: "home rule" states and "Dillon's Rule" states. Dillon's Rule states are prescriptive, meaning cities can only control the things that the state government allows them to.

In some states, local law cannot duplicate state law, and some subjects are prohibited from being covered by local ordinance. For example, in Maryland, local governments are expressly prohibited from passing gun control laws or other ordinances dealing with firearms or ammunition. In other states, such as California, local ordinances can further regulate the use of e-bikes, as long as it is allowed by the state.

State laws vs local laws

In the United States, there are 50 states, each with its own system of laws and courts. These laws apply to people who live or work in a particular state, commonwealth, territory, county, city, municipality, town, township, or village. State laws can address a wide range of legal issues and govern almost every aspect of daily life. For example, each state has its own license requirements and traffic laws, and sets its own laws addressing criminal conduct.

State laws are created through a parliamentary process, and each state has its own constitution or code, a judicial system, and police power to enforce the law.

Local laws, on the other hand, refer to the laws of a specific city, town, or village within a state. These laws are often created by a local council with a mayor or a city manager, and they can cover a variety of topics, including zoning, taxation, criminal and civil courts, and business law. Local laws are usually created to address specific concerns or opportunities that arise within a community.

While cities can create their own laws, they are still legally approved by and subservient to the state. This means that if there is a conflict between a state law and a local law, the state law will override the local ordinance. However, many states allow local courts to handle certain types of disputes within their municipalities.

Additionally, it's important to note that there are "home rule" states and "Dillon's Rule" states. Dillon's Rule states are prescriptive, meaning cities can only control the things that the state government allows them to. In contrast, home rule states may provide cities with more autonomy in creating their own laws.

Municipal codes

The process of creating a municipal code typically involves the public and the careful stewardship of clerks and councils. Cities often rely on a parliamentary process to move from concern or opportunity to law. For example, a problem may be identified by a citizen or council member, which then prompts the city to consider creating a new law to address it.

It is important to note that the relationship between municipal codes and state laws can vary. While municipalities have the power to create their own laws, they are often legally approved by and subservient to the state. In the US, there are "home rule" states, where cities have more autonomy, and "Dillon's Rule" states, where cities can only control what the state government allows. Additionally, if there is a conflict between state and municipal laws, state laws typically override municipal ordinances.

Resolutions

Cities can pass "resolutions" which are not laws but provide a perspective on a subject. For example, the City of Santa Cruz approved a resolution relative to eminent domain. This resolution was about a specific property and not a part of the body of ordinances. Resolutions are a common mechanism to do city business. To pass an ordinance or resolution, there is a predetermined process that must be followed. This process is part of the law and safeguards democracy by ensuring the work is done in public with opportunities for citizen voices to be heard.

In the US, there are two types of states: "home rule" states and "Dillon's Rule" states. Dillon's Rule states are prescriptive; cities can only control the things the state government allows them to. Cities across the US rely on a similar parliamentary process to move from concern or opportunity to law (municipal ordinance). These critical steps create a process that involves the public and careful stewardship by clerks and councils. Most cities are legally approved by and subservient to the state. If the state allows a city to add ordinances, then research can proceed. It is always positive for local laws to be similar for ease of understanding by citizens and for enforcement.

Local government law and municipal law address much of our day-to-day life, covering various topics and issues. Generally, a council with a mayor governs municipalities. Some cities use a city manager to run the municipality with the city council. Each municipality has its own way of running, so a local attorney can help navigate the system in your area. School districts may have their own rules governing a school system. These rules apply to that specific area. There are also special districts that can function autonomously. Counties often have a municipal charter, provide local ordinances, and dictate the powers of the government.

A local ordinance is a law issued by a local government such as a municipality, county, or parish. An ordinance is a type of law, rule, or regulation enacted by a local government. When city council members draft a law, it becomes an ordinance, as opposed to a law made by a state or national government. Ordinances address a variety of local matters not already covered by state or federal law, such as issues pertaining to public health and safety, zoning, fire and safety regulations, housing standards, and parking regulations. Cities and local municipalities are able to pass ordinances on matters the state government allows to be regulated at the local level. A city ordinance is a legally binding and enforceable rule established by a municipal authority (such as a city council or local government) within the jurisdiction of the local municipality or city.

Home rule vs Dillon's Rule

Dillon's Rule and Home Rule are two different approaches to local governance that significantly impact the laws and ordinances municipalities can pass in each state. Named after Iowa Supreme Court Justice John F. Dillon, Dillon's Rule takes a narrow approach to local authority, stating that local governments only have the powers expressly granted to them by the state. In other words, local governments may only exercise powers that the state specifically grants them to determine the bounds of their legal authority. This means that a city or county must obtain permission from the state legislature if it wishes to pass a law or ordinance not explicitly permitted under existing state legislation. Dillon's Rule generally requires local officials to spend a lot of time lobbying the state legislature to approve bills granting local authority and disapprove bills imposing restrictions.

On the other hand, Home Rule gives local governments greater autonomy and limits the power of states to interfere in local affairs. A municipality with Home Rule status can exercise any power and perform any function unless it is specifically prohibited from doing so by state law. In states with strong Home Rule protections, municipalities are more likely to pass new forms of legislation and defend their right to do so in court. For example, they can establish local laws stricter than state law unless the state expressly prohibits this. The majority of U.S. states apply both Dillon's Rule and Home Rule in some way, with most states using a blend of the two principles.

Frequently asked questions