Governors And Martial Law: Who Declares And When?

Martial law is a controversial topic that has been used and debated throughout US history. While there is no universal definition, it generally refers to the use of the military for law enforcement, and it can be declared by a US president, a state governor, or a local military commander in limited emergencies. Nearly every state governor has the power to impose martial law within their state, and it has been used in response to natural disasters, civil unrest, and labour disputes. However, declaring martial law is typically a last resort, as it can be easily abused as a political tool to control the population. This article will explore the complexities of martial law declarations in the United States, including the historical context, legal implications, and potential consequences.

Martial law can be declared by a US president, a state governor, or a local military commander

Martial law is a complex issue in the United States, and while it can be declared by a US President, a state governor, or a local military commander, there are many nuances to this. The US Constitution does not explicitly define when a president can declare martial law, nor does it forbid it. The same is true of Congress, which has the power to declare martial law, but has not passed a law regarding when it can be done.

State governors have the power to declare martial law, granted by either the state constitution or the state legislature. This is usually done in response to natural disasters, civil unrest, or other calamities. Governors have also declared martial law during times of labour unrest, although this is now considered controversial.

Local military commanders can also declare martial law, but only in limited emergencies. A military commander's authority under martial law is almost unlimited, but Department of Defense personnel are limited in their ability to enforce civil law.

Martial law has been declared in the US at least 68 times, according to the Brennan Center for Justice. It has been used in response to war or invasion, domestic war or insurrection, riot or civil unrest, labour disputes, and natural disasters.

It has been declared 68 times in the US, including 29 times during labour disputes

Martial law in the United States has been declared 68 times, according to the Brennan Center for Justice. This includes 29 instances of labour disputes, such as the Paint Creek-Cabin Creek Strike in 1912, where Governor William Glasscock declared martial law in response to violent clashes between miners and mine owners. The West Virginia strike resulted in the violent deaths of over 50 people.

In nearly every state, the governor has the power to impose martial law within the borders of the state. This power is granted by the state constitution or the state legislature. Governors have historically declared martial law during times of labour unrest, natural disasters, or other calamities. For example, in 1845, Nauvoo, Illinois, was stripped of its charter for abuse of authority, leading to the Illinois Mormon War. During this conflict, Joseph Smith, the leader of the Mormon movement, declared martial law in Nauvoo and called upon a city militia of about 5,000 men to protect the city from outside violence. Smith was later arrested for treason against the state of Illinois and murdered while awaiting trial.

On a national level, both the US President and Congress can impose martial law, as they are in charge of the militia. However, there is no clear definition or federal law outlining when a president can declare martial law, and it is not explicitly mentioned in the US Constitution. The Posse Comitatus Act, enacted in 1878, prohibits federal forces from assisting in domestic law enforcement unless directed by the President under the Insurrection Act or related laws.

Martial law is a last resort, as it can be abused as a political tool to control the population

Declaring martial law is a significant step for any government or leader to take, and as such, it is considered a last resort. While there is no universal definition of martial law, it generally refers to the use of the military for law enforcement. In the US, the president, state governors, and in limited emergencies, local military commanders, can declare martial law. While the US Constitution does not explicitly define when a president can declare martial law, it also does not forbid it.

Martial law is a last resort as it can be abused as a political tool to control the population, especially political dissenters. In the past, state governors have declared martial law during times of labor unrest, and this has been seen as a controversial move. For example, in 1845, Nauvoo was stripped of its charter for abuse of authority after Joseph Smith, the founder of Mormonism, was accused of using martial law to avoid arrest. In another instance, General Andrew Jackson imposed martial law in New Orleans in 1814, imposing strict curfews and travel restrictions on all residents. He also imprisoned those who challenged his authority, including judges, and this continued even after hostilities had ended.

In other countries, martial law has been used to enforce rule over the public, such as in Egypt in 2013, and in Thailand in 2006 and 2014. In China, martial law was used to suppress the Tiananmen Square protests in 1989, and in Poland in 1981, it was used to suppress political opposition. In Pakistan, President Iskander Mirza declared martial law in 1958, only to be deposed by General Ayub three weeks later, which formalized the militarization of the political system.

Martial law can be a powerful tool for a government to maintain control and enforce its rule, but it can also lead to abuses of power and the suppression of civil liberties. As such, it is generally considered a last resort, to be used only in the most extreme circumstances.

The US Constitution does not define when a president can declare martial law

The US Constitution does not explicitly authorise the president to declare martial law. The Supreme Court has never specifically held that the president can declare martial law. Therefore, it is uncertain whether the president can legally do so. However, several presidents throughout history have declared martial law.

There are two competing theories regarding the source of the power to declare martial law. The first theory suggests that martial law does not come from any direct authority but instead arises from the government's right, power, and/or duty to "maintain public order" and keep the peace. The second theory argues that the Constitution's enumerated war powers give both Congress and the president the power to declare martial law. Articles I and II of the Constitution give each branch some control over America's military forces.

Congress may be the only governmental branch that can legally declare martial law, and the president can only act according to its actions. Congress might be able to authorise a presidential declaration of martial law, but this has not been conclusively decided. The exact scope and limits of martial law will remain unclear until Congress and state legislatures enact new laws that better define them.

Martial law has been declared in response to natural disasters, invasions, civil unrest, and insurrection

In the United States, martial law has been declared in response to natural disasters, invasions, civil unrest, and insurrection on several occasions.

Natural disasters, such as the Great Chicago Fire of 1871 and the 1906 San Francisco earthquake, have prompted the declaration of martial law. In the aftermath of these events, local leaders sought to maintain order and protect themselves from potential mob violence. Similarly, during the Illinois Mormon War, Joseph Smith, the leader of the Mormons in Nauvoo, Illinois, declared martial law to defend the city from outside violence. This was also the case during the Utah War, where Governor Brigham Young of the Utah Territory declared martial law to protect against the perceived threat of a large US military force.

In the context of invasions, the imposition of martial law has been observed. During the colonial era, the Continental Army's invasion of Canada during the American Revolutionary War led to the declaration of martial law in the territory of Quebec. Additionally, in 1776, following the British capture of New York City, martial law was imposed to restore order and reinforce British authority.

Civil unrest, riots, and protests have also triggered the declaration of martial law. For instance, during the Civil Rights Movement, martial law was imposed in response to the Cambridge riot of 1963. Similarly, in 1934, martial law was declared during the West Coast waterfront strike due to the chaos associated with rioting and protests.

Insurrection and domestic conflict have also led to the imposition of martial law. In 1775, Lord Dunmore, the royal governor of Virginia, declared martial law to disrupt the colonial rebellion by offering freedom to those who joined British forces. In 1863, during the Civil War, President Lincoln imposed Congressionally authorized martial law on Kentucky, Maryland, and Missouri, suspending habeas corpus and civil rights.

These examples demonstrate that the declaration of martial law in the United States has been utilized in response to a range of crises, including natural disasters, invasions, civil unrest, and insurrection.

Frequently asked questions