Passing Bills: House Vs. Senate—Who Needs Whom?

The process of how a bill becomes a law is complex and rarely predictable. The two chambers of the US Congress—the House and the Senate—have equal legislative functions, but different ways of processing legislation. The House can initiate revenue legislation, while the Senate confirms presidential nominations and approves treaties. The House passes legislation through a majority vote, while the Senate prioritizes deliberation and debate before voting. The House and Senate have different rules and practices, with the House allowing a numerical majority to act quickly, and the Senate providing more leverage to individual senators. A bill can be introduced in either chamber and must pass both chambers in identical form before becoming a law.

The House can initiate revenue legislation

The process of passing a bill differs between the House and the Senate. The House of Representatives is the more representative branch of the state legislature, and as such, all bills for raising revenue must originate in the House. This is known as the Origination Clause, sometimes called the Revenue Clause, which is Article I, Section 7, Clause 1 of the U.S. Constitution. The clause was part of the Great Compromise between small and large states, which sought to offset the unrepresentative nature of the Senate.

The Origination Clause stemmed from a British parliamentary practice that all money bills must have their first reading in the House of Commons before moving to the House of Lords. This practice was intended to ensure that the power of the purse is possessed by the legislative body most responsive to the people. However, the British practice was modified in America by allowing the Senate to amend these bills.

The Senate may propose or concur with amendments to revenue bills, as with other bills. The Origination Clause was later modified in 1787 to reduce the House's power by allowing the Senate to amend revenue bills and by removing appropriation bills from the scope of the clause. This modification was part of the compromise to allow equality in the Senate, regardless of a state's population.

The House and the Senate have disagreed over the scope of the Origination Clause, specifically regarding the removal of appropriation bills. The U.S. Supreme Court has expressed willingness to address issues related to the Origination Clause, indicating that laws passed in violation of the clause would not be immune from judicial scrutiny.

The Senate confirms presidential nominations

The process of a bill becoming a law involves several steps. In the United States, the House and the Senate have distinct roles in this process. While the House initiates the process by introducing a bill, the Senate plays a crucial role in confirming presidential nominations. Here is a detailed overview of the Senate's role in confirming presidential appointments:

The Senate's responsibility in confirming presidential nominations is a significant aspect of the legislative process. This process typically begins after an election, when the president or president-elect starts making crucial decisions regarding Senate-confirmed appointments. The transition team's staff conducts thorough background reviews of potential candidates for these positions. Once the president has made their selection, an official written nomination is sent to the Senate, marking the beginning of the Senate's formal role in the process.

The nomination is then forwarded to the appropriate committee within the Senate. Each committee has its unique set of procedures, including background investigations, financial disclosure forms, and committee questionnaires. These questionnaires delve into biographical and financial matters, and some committees may also request responses to policy-related questions. It is essential for nominees to promptly complete and return the required paperwork to demonstrate their commitment and professionalism.

After the committee has received all the necessary information, they may schedule a hearing for the nominee. This hearing can be intimidating, but it is an honour to serve as a presidential appointee. Nominees should prepare by familiarizing themselves with relevant resources and maintaining an open and prepared demeanour during the hearing. The Senate's scrutiny of nominees is typically rigorous, but ultimately, most nominees are confirmed.

Nominees for Senate-confirmed appointments need to secure a simple majority support of senators present and voting to advance their nomination. Once the Senate has voted in favour of a nominee, the clerk of the Senate notifies the White House to prepare the presidential commission. This commission is signed by the president and undergoes further official procedures before the nominee can assume their appointed position.

The House passes bills through a majority vote

The House of Representatives and the Senate are the two chambers of the United States Congress, which is responsible for creating and modifying laws. While both chambers are equal in their legislative functions, they have different ways of processing legislation. The House passes bills through a majority vote, which allows for relatively quick processing. On the other hand, the Senate favours deliberation and debate prior to voting.

For a bill to become a law, it must be passed by both chambers of Congress in identical form and then signed by the President. The process begins with the introduction of a bill, which can be proposed by a sitting member of the House or Senate, during an election campaign, or through a petition by citizens or citizen groups. Once introduced, the bill is assigned to a committee that researches, discusses, and makes changes to it. The bill is then voted on by the chamber. If it passes, it goes through a similar process in the other chamber. If both chambers pass the bill, they must work out any differences between their versions and then vote on the same version. If this version passes, it is presented to the President.

The House has four calendars of business: the Union Calendar, the House Calendar, the Private Calendar, and the Calendar of Motions to Discharge Committees. When a public bill is reported favourably by all committees, it is assigned a calendar number on either the Union Calendar or the House Calendar. Bills can be brought to the floor when a majority of the Senate chooses. The Speaker of the House may also create select committees or task forces to study specific issues and report on them to the House.

The House has certain exclusive powers in the legislative process. For example, only the House can originate revenue legislation and initiate tax-related measures. Additionally, the House can release bills from committee without a proper committee vote through a discharge petition signed by a majority of its members. The House's rules and practices enable it to process legislation efficiently, demonstrating the important role of majority votes in its legislative function.

The Senate passes bills through deliberation and debate

The process of passing a bill into law is a complex one, with many stages and requirements. The Senate plays a crucial role in this process, and it is here that bills are passed through deliberation and debate.

The Senate's role in passing bills is distinct from that of the House. While the House processes legislation through a majority vote, the Senate operates through deliberation and debate prior to any vote. This means that senators introduce, discuss, and amend bills, and the process of reaching a final vote can be lengthy. The Senate's rules provide no way to impose a time limit on debates, and this allows senators to use a filibuster to delay or even prevent a final vote. A filibuster is when a senator, or group of senators, attempts to indefinitely delay a bill without a supermajority, preventing it from ever reaching a vote. This can be achieved by insisting on extended debate. The use of the filibuster has increased in recent years, and critics argue that it has slowed down the Senate's business, impacting its ability to pass laws.

However, there are ways to limit debate and move towards a vote. Senate Rule XXII, or the cloture rule, allows a supermajority to limit debate and amendments to a bill. A cloture motion must be signed by at least 16 senators, and two days later, a vote on the motion takes place. If three-fifths (60 senators) agree, then further consideration of the bill is limited to 30 hours, after which a final vote takes place, requiring a simple majority for approval. This process of reaching a final vote can take about a week.

Once a bill is introduced, it is assigned to a committee that will research, discuss, and make changes. If a majority of the committee votes in favour, the bill moves to the Senate floor for debate. Once the bill reaches a vote, it requires a simple majority of 51 votes to pass. However, before it can get to this stage, it takes 60 votes to cut off debate and end filibustering.

The Senate, therefore, plays a critical role in passing bills, and its processes of deliberation and debate are central to how it functions.

The House can pass a bill without the Senate if it's a simple resolution

The process of passing a bill in the United States is a complex one. The House and the Senate have different procedures and requirements for passing a bill, and the two chambers must ultimately agree on the same bill for it to become a law. However, there is an exception to this process when it comes to simple resolutions.

A simple resolution is designated as H.Res. in the House and S.Res. in the Senate, followed by a number. It addresses matters within the prerogative of one house, such as revising the standing rules of one chamber. Simple resolutions are also used to express the sentiments of a single house, such as offering condolences to the deceased member of Congress. They do not require approval from the other house or the president's signature, and they do not carry the force of law.

The House of Representatives has four calendars of business: the Union Calendar, the House Calendar, the Private Calendar, and the Calendar of Motions to Discharge Committees. When a public bill is reported favorably by all committees, it is assigned a calendar number on either the Union Calendar or the House Calendar. The Speaker of the House or the presiding officer in the Senate refers the bill to the appropriate committee. The Speaker may also set time limits for committees to consider the bill.

In the case of simple resolutions, the House can pass them without the Senate's approval. This is because simple resolutions pertain to matters within the sole jurisdiction of one house and do not require the concurrence of the other. However, it is important to note that simple resolutions do not carry the force of law and are primarily used for procedural or internal purposes within the House.

While the House can pass a simple resolution without the Senate, it is just one type of resolution. Other types, such as joint resolutions and concurrent resolutions, require the approval of both the House and the Senate. These resolutions address issues that require the input and agreement of both chambers, such as continuing or emergency appropriations, constitutional amendments, or expressing the sentiments of both houses.

Frequently asked questions