Green Card Holders: Can They Face Deportation?

Despite the securities offered by holding legal status in the U.S., green card holders can be deported. Under the Immigration and Nationality Act, green card holders do not need to be convicted of a crime to be removable. Reasons for deportation may include termination of conditional permanent resident status, knowingly helping someone enter the U.S. illegally, and involvement in espionage, sabotage, or violations of law prohibiting the export of goods, technology, or sensitive information. In the case of Mahmoud Khalil, a green card holder and permanent resident, the Trump administration attempted to deport him due to his role in pro-Palestinian protests, arguing that his presence in the country hindered U.S. foreign policy.

Grounds for deportation

Green card holders can be deported if they are found to be violating immigration rules or US law. While green card holders have certain rights to live and work in the US, they can face deportation or removal if they don't follow certain rules and avoid certain types of legal violations.

The grounds for deportation include criminal convictions, prostitution, and domestic violence. One of the more obscure grounds for deportation is that the Secretary of State can put someone into deportation proceedings if they determine that the person's presence has serious adverse foreign policy consequences. This was seen in the case of Mahmoud Khalil, a green card holder who was arrested by Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents due to his role in pro-Palestinian protests. The Trump administration also attempted to deport Chung, a 21-year-old legal permanent resident, under the same rationale, but a federal judge ruled that the government must halt its attempts as there was nothing in her record to suggest she was a "foreign-policy risk".

Other grounds for deportation include termination of conditional permanent resident status, knowingly helping someone enter the US illegally, and involvement in espionage, sabotage, or violations or evasions of any law prohibiting the export of goods, technology, or sensitive information. In addition, green card holders who spend 180 continuous days or more outside the US may face deportation.

It is important to note that green card holders have the right to defend their case in immigration court and may be eligible to apply for a waiver to avoid deportation.

Deportation of students

The deportation of students has been a topic of discussion in the United States, particularly in relation to green card holders and student visa holders. While green card holders have lawful permanent resident status, allowing them to live and work in the US indefinitely, this status does not make them immune to deportation.

Grounds for Deportation

Under the Immigration and Nationality Act, green card holders can be deported without a conviction. If the Secretary of Homeland Security or the Attorney General has reasonable grounds to believe that a green card holder has engaged or is likely to engage in terrorist activities, they can be deported. This has been a particular concern for students who have been involved in protests or expressed political opinions, as seen in the case of Mahmoud Khalil, a Palestinian activist and student at Columbia University. Khalil was arrested by Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents due to his role in protests related to the Israel-Hamas conflict and was accused of being a "terrorist sympathizer".

Student Visa Holders

Student visa holders face stricter rules and have fewer protections compared to green card holders. They can be deported for violating visa conditions, overstaying, or committing crimes. For example, foreign students on student visas who are arrested for drunk driving often have their visas cancelled by the State Department. It's important to note that students on visas must maintain full-time enrolment and avoid unauthorized work, with limited legal remedies available.

Legal Protections

Students facing deportation, whether on a green card or student visa, do have some legal protections. They have the right to defend their case in immigration court and may seek relief through waivers, cancellation of removal, or other legal defences, especially if they have strong family ties or have lived in the US for an extended period. Additionally, students with green cards generally require an immigration judge to determine their deportability, providing an opportunity for legal representation and due process.

Policy Changes

The Trump administration's policies and enforcement have impacted the deportation of students. There has been a focus on cancelling green cards, arresting green card holders for constitutionally lawful activities, and deporting them, which represents a shift in American policy. Additionally, the administration has cited a seldom-used statute authorising the Secretary of State to revoke visas of non-citizens deemed a threat to foreign policy interests, impacting students who express certain political views.

In summary, the deportation of students in the United States is a complex issue that involves the intersection of immigration laws, visa requirements, and political considerations. While green card holders have more protections than student visa holders, both groups can face deportation under certain circumstances, and it is important for students to be aware of their rights and the potential consequences of their actions.

Deportation and Trump's immigration policy

Trump's immigration policy has been described as a ""deportation dystopia"" and for good reason. The former US president's plans for mass deportations would have required a vast expansion of the already massive federal deportation system, which is overseen by the Department of Homeland Security. Trump's vision included deploying the military, federal agents, and state and local police to arrest, detain, and remove millions of immigrants without legal status. This would have been a costly, inhumane, and devastating endeavour, as immigrant advocates have pointed out.

To understand the implications of Trump's immigration policy, it's important to know who is at risk of deportation. While Trump's focus was primarily on undocumented immigrants, even those with legal status in the US, such as visa holders and green card holders, are not completely protected from the threat of deportation.

Green card holders, or lawful permanent residents, do have certain rights to live and work in the United States long-term. However, they can still be deported if they violate certain rules and laws. For example, a green card holder can be deported for criminal convictions, prostitution, or domestic violence. Interestingly, they don't need to be convicted to be deemed "removable"; if the secretary of homeland security or the attorney general has reasonable grounds to believe they are engaged in or likely to engage in terrorist activities, they can be deported.

The Trump administration's hardline stance on immigration has caused anxiety among legal residents, as seen in the case of Palestinian protester Mahmoud Khalil, a green card holder who was arrested and detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents. Khalil's arrest was tied to his participation in protests, raising concerns about the protection of free speech and the right to due process for immigrants.

Trump's deportation plans faced significant legal, practical, and moral challenges. To deport immigrants on the scale he envisioned, Trump would have had to navigate a complex process that includes arrests, removal proceedings before immigration judges, litigation in immigration courts, and appeals. This process is already lengthy and cumbersome, and Trump's plan would have required an unprecedented expansion of resources and personnel, potentially leading to a violation of constitutional rights.

Deportation hearings

Green card holders, or lawful permanent residents, can be deported if they are found to be violating immigration rules or US law. Deportation hearings are a part of removal proceedings, which are initiated by the federal government. The government must charge the green card holder with a condition under immigration laws that make them "deportable". This term refers to conduct defined in a set of provisions, most of which involve criminal activity.

At the deportation hearing, the government must prove deportability by "clear and convincing" evidence. The specific procedures for conducting these hearings include affording the green card holder notice of the charges against them, the right to confront the evidence, the right to present their own evidence, and the right to a lawyer.

In the case of Mahmoud Khalil, a green card holder and pro-Palestinian protester, the Department of Homeland Security issued a notice to appear before an immigration judge for deportation proceedings. The Trump administration sought to deport Khalil, arguing that his case was not about free speech but rather about his right to be in the United States. A federal judge temporarily blocked Khalil's deportation, pending a separate hearing in immigration court to determine his status.

It is important to note that green card holders do not need to be convicted of a crime to be considered "removable". For example, the Secretary of Homeland Security or the Attorney General may have reasonable grounds to believe they engaged or are likely to engage in terrorist activities. However, green card holders have certain rights, such as the right to a lawyer and a hearing before an immigration judge.

Rights of green card holders

Green card holders have the right to live and work permanently in the United States, provided they do not commit any actions that would make them removable under immigration law. This includes working in any legal profession of their choosing, although some jobs are limited to US citizens for security reasons.

Green card holders are also protected by all laws of the United States, their state of residence, and local jurisdictions. However, they do not have an indefinite right to remain in the country, and can be deported if they violate certain rules or immigration laws. For example, green card holders can be deported if they are found to be violating immigration rules, engaging in criminal activities, or if they are absent from the country for 180 continuous days or more.

In the case of deportation, green card holders have the right to defend their case in immigration court. They may also apply for a waiver (legal forgiveness) for certain types of deportability. If a final order of removal (deportation) is issued, the individual will be sent back to their home country or, if they are stateless, to another country that agrees to accept them.

It is important to note that green card holders do not need to be convicted of a crime to be considered "removable." The secretary of homeland security or the attorney general has the authority to revoke a green card if they have reasonable grounds to believe the individual has engaged or is likely to engage in terrorist activities.

Green card holders also have the right to free speech and the right to due process, which includes the right to have their case heard in court.

Frequently asked questions