The Governor's Power: Lawmaking Without Congress?

In the United States, a governor is the chief executive and commander-in-chief of a state, functioning as its head of state and government. While the governor has broad executive authority to act within their state, they cannot make laws without Congress. The governor's role in the law-making process involves proposing, signing, or vetoing laws passed by the state legislative body. Governors may also use their position to influence the progress of legislation through meetings with legislators and other stakeholders. They also have the power to appoint state officials and judges, subject to confirmation by the state legislature. The scope of a governor's power varies from state to state and is defined by state constitutions, legislation, and tradition.

Governors can issue executive orders

Executive orders are directives that manage the operations of a state government. They are used for a variety of purposes, including triggering emergency powers and related response actions during natural disasters, weather events, energy crises, public health emergencies, and other situations requiring immediate attention. Governors can also use executive orders to create advisory, coordinating, study, or investigative committees or commissions, as well as to create or reorganize state agencies, boards, and commissions.

In some states, executive orders are subject to legislative review and may be overturned if they lack support by statute or the state constitution. The scope of gubernatorial power varies from state to state, and governors are ranked by political historians and other observers of state politics according to the number and extent of their powers.

For example, in 2007, Sonny Perdue, the governor of Georgia, issued an executive order for all its state agencies to reduce water use during a major drought. In another instance, Governor Jindal of Louisiana issued a GEO that suspended any legal requirements that would prohibit medical providers from coping with an emergency surge of disaster victims.

Governors can't make laws without constitutional authority

In the United States, the legislative process is a crucial aspect of the democratic system, emphasising the protection of minorities and allowing all sides to be heard. Governors play a significant role in this process, but their authority to make laws is limited and governed by the Constitution and state laws. While governors generally possess broad executive authority within their states, their ability to create laws is constrained.

The scope of a governor's power varies from state to state and is outlined in state constitutions, legislation, and tradition. One of the key powers that governors hold is the ability to veto legislative measures. Every legislative bill passed by the state legislative body is presented to the governor for signing. Governors have a specified time frame within which they can sign or veto proposed legislation. If the governor does not sign or veto within the allotted time, the legislation may become law without the governor's signature, depending on the state's rules.

Additionally, governors can influence the progress of legislation through regular meetings with legislators, legislative officials, and other stakeholders. They can also use their position as party leaders to encourage support for specific legislative initiatives. However, the power to create laws without congressional approval is not within the governor's inherent authority. The governor's authority to issue executive orders or proclamations that carry the force of law is derived from the state constitutions, case law, or the powers assigned to state chief executives.

In the case of Young v. State, the Washington court held that governors lack inherent power except as delegated by the Constitution or a statute. This means that a governor cannot create obligations, responsibilities, conditions, or processes with legal force through executive orders without statutory authority. For example, in Washington State, Executive Order 90-04, issued by Governor Gardner, related to wetland protection. However, the governor did not have the statutory authority to create obligations and responsibilities with legal force through this executive order.

In summary, while governors have a range of powers and can influence law-making, they cannot unilaterally make laws without constitutional or statutory authority. Their role in the legislative process is primarily to approve, veto, or influence bills passed by the state legislative body, rather than independently create laws.

Governors can nominate officials

Governors cannot make laws without Congress. However, they do have broad authority to nominate officials to serve in state executive branch positions, including their advisory committee, known as the "cabinet".

The governor's role as a state leader involves advancing and pursuing new and revised policies and programs using tools such as executive orders, executive budgets, and legislative proposals and vetoes. Governors are responsible for implementing state laws and overseeing the operation of the state executive branch. They also serve as the intergovernmental liaison to the federal government on behalf of the state.

In most states, governors have the authority to appoint state court judges, usually from a list of names submitted by a nominations committee. These appointments are often subject to confirmation by one or both houses of the state legislature, and many governors consult with key legislators before making formal nominations.

Additionally, governors may fill vacancies in the Senate by appointing a successor until the next election, where a successor is elected for the remaining term. This power is granted by the state legislature in most cases.

While governors have significant powers, they must work with their state legislatures and other executive branch officials to accomplish their goals. The scope of gubernatorial power varies from state to state, and governors are subject to checks and balances like all officials in the United States.

Governors can appoint state judges

Governors have broad authority to nominate officials to serve in state executive branch positions. This includes the power to appoint state court judges, although the specifics of this selection method vary by state. In some states, governors appoint judges directly without having to select from a list of names provided by a selection committee. In other states, governors may be required to choose from a list of names submitted by a nominations committee.

After a nominee is chosen, another body must confirm the appointment before the nominee can take office. This confirmation process can be used by legislatures to expand their influence on governors and their policies. For example, in California, the governor's nominee must be confirmed by the California Commission on Judicial Appointments, which is made up of the state's attorney general, the chief justice of the California Supreme Court, and the state's most senior presiding justice of the California Courts of Appeal. In New Hampshire, the governor's nominee must be confirmed by a majority vote of the New Hampshire Executive Council, whose five members are elected every two years in partisan elections.

The gubernatorial appointment method of judicial selection is one of several methods used to select judges, which also include assisted appointment, partisan and nonpartisan elections, the Michigan method, court appointment, municipal government selection, and legislative elections. The selection method can vary even within a state, as different methods may be used for different levels of courts.

Governors can veto laws

Governors cannot make laws without Congress. However, they do have the power to veto laws passed by their state legislatures. All 50 state governors have the authority to veto entire legislative measures. Governors can also veto specific parts of a bill while allowing others to pass. These include "line-item" vetoes, where a governor can strike a general item from a piece of legislation, "reduction" vetoes, where a governor can delete a budget item, and "amendatory" vetoes, where a governor can revise legislation.

The governor's veto power is a crucial aspect of the legislative process, providing a check on the power of the state legislature. It allows governors to have a say in the laws that are passed and ensures that laws align with their policies and priorities. Governors can use their role as party leaders to encourage support for legislative initiatives and influence the progress of legislation through meetings with legislators, legislative officials, and other stakeholders.

The process of vetoing a bill typically involves the governor returning the bill to the house in which it originated, along with their objections or recommended amendments. The house can then override the veto by a two-thirds vote, including a majority of the members elected to that house. If the first house overrides the veto, the bill and the governor's objections are sent to the other house, which can also override the veto by a two-thirds vote. If both houses override the veto, the bill becomes law without the governor's signature.

The time frame for a governor to veto a bill varies among states. In most states, a bill will become law if not explicitly vetoed by the governor within a specified number of days. In a few states, known as "pocket veto" states, a bill requires the governor's signature to become law, and the governor can effectively veto it by taking no action. Governors also have the authority to appoint state court judges, nominate officials to state executive branch positions, and make appointments to state judgeships, all of which can indirectly impact the creation and enforcement of laws.

Frequently asked questions