Law Firms As Trustees: Ethical And Legal Complexities

A trustee is someone who has been given the authority to hold and manage assets or property for the benefit of another person, and they can be an individual or an institution. Lawyers are often asked by clients to be their trustees, and while this is allowed, there are ethical and legal conflicts that must be addressed. For example, a lawyer acting as a trustee might have to make decisions that could benefit themselves financially, creating a conflict of interest. In some states, rules and procedures have been adopted to address these issues. Additionally, a lawyer acting as a trustee must also be aware of their duty of confidentiality, which is broader than that of a typical agent in a principal-agent relationship.

Lawyers as trustees: conflicts and ethical considerations

Lawyers are often asked by clients to act as trustees, especially when the client has no one else to appoint. A lawyer may be the best person to serve as a trustee because they know the terms of the will and trust better than anyone else, including the client. They also have legal and ethical training, knowledge and expertise that can add value for the client.

However, there are conflicts and ethical considerations to take into account. Lawyers must explain the potential risks and advantages of their appointment as a trustee, as well as the alternatives, such as appointing a family member or an institution. There is also the issue of compensation, as trustees are typically paid a fee that is much lower than what an attorney would normally charge for legal counsel.

Another conflict of interest may arise when the lawyer has to make decisions that could benefit themselves or their family financially. This can be mitigated by drafting clear and concise trust documents with the help of a lawyer who has no conflicts of interest. A lawyer acting as a trustee must always act in the best interests of the beneficiaries and not their own interests. They must also use due care when making investment decisions and diversify their investments to minimize risk.

In some states, such as Georgia, there are express rules and procedures that must be followed when a lawyer acts as a trustee. The Model Rules, adopted in most states, include rules on conflicts of interest and informed consent. It is important to note that a lawyer acting as a trustee has a duty of confidentiality that is broader than that of a typical agent in a principal-agent relationship or the duty of a trustee in an express trust.

The duty of loyalty and duty of prudence

A law firm can be a trustee, and when acting as one, it owes a fiduciary duty to the beneficiaries. This means that the law firm must act with the utmost loyalty and prudence in the best interests of the beneficiaries.

The Duty of Loyalty

The duty of loyalty requires that the trustee administers the trust solely in the interest of the beneficiaries. In other words, the trustee must make decisions that are in the best interest of the beneficiary who holds equitable title to the property. This duty prohibits trustees from using their position for personal gain or to further their interests or those of a third party.

The Duty of Prudence

The duty of prudence requires that the trustee administers the trust with the degree of care, skill, and caution that a prudent trustee would exercise. This includes a responsibility to inform and account to beneficiaries, to act impartially, and to keep trust property separate from personal property. The trustee is held to an objective standard of care in managing the trust property and can be personally liable for breaches of fiduciary duty.

When acting as a trustee, law firms must be aware of the significant responsibilities and potential liabilities involved. They must ensure that they act in the best interests of the beneficiaries at all times and fulfil their duties without violating the law. Law firms can employ agents and attorneys to help facilitate these duties and avoid liability, but ultimately, the law firm serving as trustee is accountable for any breaches of fiduciary duty.

The legal and financial complexities of trust administration

Trust administration is a complex process that requires a deep understanding of the legal and financial concepts involved. A trustee is a person or institution entrusted with the authority to hold and manage assets for the benefit of another person, the beneficiary. They are legally required to act in the best interests of the beneficiaries and must exercise prudence in investment decisions, ensuring diversification to minimise risk. Trustees must also keep accurate records, inform beneficiaries of their rights and responsibilities, and avoid self-dealing transactions.

The legal and ethical duties of a trustee can be challenging, and conflicts of interest may arise. For example, a trustee might face a conflict when making decisions that could financially benefit themselves or their family. In such cases, seeking guidance from a lawyer with no conflicts of interest is advisable. Additionally, the trustee role may not be appealing to lawyers due to potential limitations on their compensation. Trustees are typically paid a fee, but this may be lower than the standard rates for legal services.

The legal framework of trust law varies across states and countries, and it is essential to understand the specific rules and regulations applicable to the trust's location. For instance, in California, trustees are entitled to "reasonable compensation" as per the California Probate Code, unless different terms are specified in the trust. On the other hand, some states like Georgia have adopted express rules and procedures that must be followed.

Given the complexities of trust administration, it is generally recommended that trustees, especially first-time trustees, seek the guidance of an experienced trust lawyer. This is particularly important if the trustee lacks legal or financial experience. A trust lawyer can help navigate the legal duties, ethical obligations, and financial concepts involved in managing trust assets. They can also assist in interpreting the trust document, ensuring compliance with the law, and minimising potential risks.

While it is not a legal requirement to retain a lawyer for trust administration, doing so can help prevent costly mistakes and ensure the smooth and efficient management of the trust. Trustees should carefully consider their responsibilities and seek appropriate legal guidance to fulfil their duties effectively and in the best interests of the beneficiaries.

The role of a trust corporation

A trust corporation is a separate legal entity that can hold assets in England, Wales, and overseas. It can be a wholly owned subsidiary of another company, or its shares may be held by a limited liability partnership (LLP). While a trust corporation does not have to explicitly state in its memorandum that it is "empowered by its constitution to undertake trust business", firms forming a new trust corporation may include explicit wording to this effect.

Trust corporations can act as attorneys, property and affairs deputies, and trustees. A trustee is someone who has been given the authority by the trustor to hold and manage property or assets for the benefit of the beneficiary. The trustee holds these assets in trust until certain conditions are met, at which point they are transferred to the beneficiary. Trustees must always act in the best interests of the beneficiaries and not their own interests. They must also use due care when making investment decisions and diversify their investments to minimize risk.

Lawyers are often asked by clients to act as trustees, especially when the client has no one else to appoint. Lawyers may be well-suited to this role as they have legal and ethical training, knowledge, and expertise. They may also be very familiar with the will or trust and family dynamics. However, conflicts of interest can arise when a lawyer acts as a trustee, and there may be limitations on their compensation.

In some states, such as Georgia, there are express rules and procedures in place regarding lawyers serving as trustees. It is important for lawyers to explain the potential risks, advantages, and alternatives to the client if they are considering acting as a trustee. While it is not legally required to retain a lawyer when administering a trust, it is generally advisable to do so, especially for first-time trustees or those unfamiliar with the legal and financial concepts involved.

Appointing a trustee: the trustee's consent and resignation

A law firm can be a trustee, and there are several reasons why a client may want their lawyer to take on this role. For instance, the lawyer may know the terms of the will and trust better than anyone else, including the client. The lawyer's legal and ethical training, knowledge, and expertise can also provide added value to the client.

Appointing a trustee: the trustees' consent and resignation

When appointing a trustee, it is important to obtain the consent of the new trustee. The prospective trustee should be informed about the duties and responsibilities involved and should provide their consent in writing. The process for appointing a new trustee is typically outlined in the trust deed and may involve executing a deed of appointment. The deed of appointment is a legal document that formalises the appointment of a new trustee and should include the details of the trust, the names of the existing and new trustees, and any specific provisions or conditions related to the appointment.

In the case of a vacancy, the remaining trustees are responsible for appointing a new trustee. This appointment should be made by a written instrument signed by a majority of the trustees or by a resolution of the trustees, duly adopted and recorded in the records of the trust. The new trustee must accept their appointment in writing, and the trust estate will then vest in the new trustee, together with the continuing trustees.

It is important to update the trust's records and documentation to reflect the appointment of the new trustee, including updating legal documents, financial accounts, and any registrations or filings with relevant authorities. The retiring trustee should also inform the other trustees and beneficiaries of their decision to retire, ensuring open communication and awareness of the upcoming changes.

When a trustee wishes to resign, they may need to follow specific methods outlined in the trust instrument or seek legal advice to ensure their resignation is effective. For example, in California, a trustee may only resign by following the procedures outlined in the California Probate Code. It is recommended that trustees consult with a trust litigation lawyer if they wish to resign or suspect that a petition for their removal may be filed.

Frequently asked questions