Law Journals: Primary Or Secondary Sources?

Legal research materials are divided into two categories: primary sources and secondary sources. Primary sources are the actual law, including constitutions, court cases, statutes, and regulations. Secondary sources explain, critique, and analyse the law, but do not establish binding law. Law journals are considered secondary sources and are a great place to start legal research. They are scholarly publications covering the legal field and are written by law professors and practitioners. Law journals often contain substantial citations to primary and secondary sources, which can be useful for further research. However, it is important to note that law journals are not primary sources of law.

Law journals as secondary sources

Law journals are considered secondary sources in legal research. Secondary sources explain, critique, and analyse the law but do not establish binding law. They include books and articles written about the law. Law journals are periodicals edited by law students and published by law schools, consisting of articles written by legal academics. They may cover a broad range of topics or be limited to a specific area of law. Articles in law journals usually include a summary of the legal topic at issue, as well as many citations to other secondary and primary legal sources.

Law journals are a great place to start legal research as they can help save time by providing analysis and explanations of legal principles, as well as leads to key primary sources. They can also help avoid unnecessary research since you are building on work that someone else has already done on an issue. They are also useful in providing citations to relevant primary materials.

Law journals are distinct from primary sources, which are the actual law in the form of constitutions, court cases, statutes, and administrative rules and regulations. Primary sources state the law, whereas secondary sources discuss it.

Some examples of law journals include the Yale Law Journal, Michigan Law Review, and Michigan Business & Entrepreneurial Law Review.

Primary sources and the actual law

Primary sources are the actual law, in the form of constitutions, court cases, statutes, and administrative rules and regulations. They are the books and websites that comprise the formal, written statements of law issued by government entities. The law includes everything from a state's statutes to a city's ordinances to case law published by a court.

Primary sources do not provide explanations like secondary sources. They are the controlling authority, the actual text of the law. They include constitutions (either federal or state), statutes (laws enacted by legislatures), municipal codes (enacted by local councils), and cases (opinions handed down by courts).

Secondary sources, on the other hand, explain, critique, and discuss the law, but are not the law itself. They are a great place to start legal research as they can provide an overview of a particular area of law and introduce key terminology. They include law journals, encyclopedias, and treatises. Law journals are scholarly publications covering the legal field. They publish articles that are comprehensive studies of current legal topics, generally written by law professors and practitioners. These articles generally contain substantial citations to primary and secondary sources on the topic, which may lead to additional information on the subject.

Law journals are considered secondary sources and are not primary law. However, they are still important as they can influence the creation and interpretation of the law. They are also useful for understanding the historical context of a case. For example, a law journal article might discuss and analyse an aspect of the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, providing the context for a particular case.

Law journals and citations

Law journals, also known as "law reviews", are considered secondary sources. They are periodicals edited by law students and published by law schools, consisting of articles written by legal academics. Law journals may cover a broad range of topics or be limited to a specific area of law. They are a great place to start legal research as they can help users learn about an area of law and provide citations to relevant primary materials. Articles in law reviews usually include a summary of the legal topic at issue, as well as many citations to other secondary and primary legal sources.

Law journals are not primary sources, which are the actual law in the form of constitutions, court cases, statutes, and administrative rules and regulations. Primary sources state the actual law and are issued directly from a law-making body. They include the formal, written statements of law issued by government entities, such as a state's statutes or a city's ordinances.

Secondary sources, on the other hand, explain the law but do not establish binding law. They include books and articles written about the law, such as legal dictionaries, encyclopaedias, and law journals. They can influence the creation and interpretation of the law but are not determinative. They are valuable because they can provide an overview of a particular area of law, introduce key terminology, and provide citations to important primary source materials.

When conducting legal research, it is important to consult both primary and secondary sources. Starting with secondary sources can help researchers understand the legal principles at issue and locate relevant primary sources. Law journals, in particular, can provide a comprehensive overview of current topics in law and lead researchers to additional information through their extensive citations.

Law journals as primary sources

Law journals are generally considered secondary sources. Secondary sources explain, critique, and analyse the law, but do not constitute the law itself. They are valuable because they can introduce key terminology and provide citations to important primary sources. Law journals are scholarly publications that cover a broad range of topics in the legal field. They are often written by law professors and practitioners and contain substantial citations to primary and secondary sources.

Law journals are a great place to start legal research as they can provide an overview of a particular area of law. They are also useful for locating primary sources of law, such as constitutions, court cases, statutes, and administrative rules and regulations.

However, it is important to note that law journals are not considered primary sources, which are the actual law or formal written statements of law issued by government entities. Primary sources include constitutions, court cases, statutes, and regulations. They do not provide explanations like secondary sources but are the binding law.

In some cases, law journals may include references to primary law or restatements of existing common law. For example, the 2012 William and Mary Law Review article "The Fourth Amendment Rights of Children at Home: when Parental Authority Goes Too Far" is considered a secondary source as it discusses and analyses one aspect of the Fourth Amendment, which is a primary source.

In conclusion, while law journals are a valuable resource for legal research and can provide insights into primary sources, they are not considered primary sources themselves. They serve as a tool to help navigate and understand the primary sources of law.

Law journal articles as primary sources

Law journal articles are generally considered secondary sources. Secondary sources explain the law and provide context, but they do not themselves establish binding law. They include books and articles written about the law, such as law journals, encyclopedias, and treatises.

Secondary sources can influence the creation and interpretation of the law, but they are not determinative. They are valuable because they can provide an overview of a particular area of the law, introduce key terminology, and provide citations to important primary source materials. Law journal articles are comprehensive studies of current legal topics, usually written by law professors and practitioners. They contain extensive references and citations to both primary and secondary sources.

Primary sources, on the other hand, contain the actual text of the law. They are the formal, written statements of law issued by government entities, including constitutions, court cases, statutes, and administrative rules and regulations. Primary sources do not provide explanations or commentary like secondary sources. They are the actual law, and they state the law as it is.

However, it is worth noting that the distinction between primary and secondary sources is not always clear-cut, and there may be some overlap or exceptions. For example, law journals may occasionally include primary sources, such as the full text of a court case or a statute, within the body of an article or as an attachment. Additionally, some sources may be considered persuasive authority, meaning they are not technically primary sources, but they are highly regarded and can influence legal decision-making.

In conclusion, law journal articles are typically classified as secondary sources. They provide valuable context, analysis, and commentary on the law, but they do not establish the law themselves. Researchers often use them as a starting point to gain an understanding of a legal topic before delving into the primary sources, which contain the binding law.

Frequently asked questions