Lease Agreements: Can They Override State Law?

The relationship between lease agreements and state law is a complex one, with landlords and tenants needing to be aware of their rights and responsibilities. While leases can impose certain requirements on tenants, they cannot supersede state law. For example, a lease cannot require a tenant to give up any right or protection afforded under the law, such as security deposit rules. In the case of a conflict between a lease and state law, the law controls. However, local laws vary, and a lease agreement that is legal in one state may be illegal in another.

Lease termination and notice period

In California, for instance, tenants are generally required to give landlords advance written notice before terminating a tenancy. The specific notice requirements depend on the type of tenancy. For a fixed-term tenancy, tenants must provide written notice to vacate at least a month before the termination of the tenancy. On the other hand, a month-to-month tenancy can be terminated by either the landlord or the tenant by giving a notice of a rent increase or termination, respectively, with at least 30 days' notice.

In the state of Ohio, a 30-day written notice is generally considered acceptable for lease termination. However, some leases may stipulate a longer notice period, such as 60 days, which would be binding on the tenant if agreed upon.

In New South Wales, the minimum notice period for ending a residential tenancy agreement depends on the type of agreement and the reasons for termination. For periodic tenancy agreements, landlords must provide a 90-day termination notice, and tenants are not required to pay rent after vacating the premises before the 90 days have expired. For fixed-term agreements, the termination date cannot be before the end of the fixed term.

It is important to note that lease agreements are legally binding contracts, and specific provisions related to lease termination, notice periods, termination reasons, and prescribed procedures should be carefully reviewed to ensure compliance with the law and prevent potential legal disputes. Seeking legal advice is always recommended to understand the specific requirements and regulations governing lease termination notices in the relevant jurisdiction.

Landlord's liability for property conditions

A lease cannot override state law. However, landlords are responsible for tenant injuries in the rental property's common areas. They are also responsible for the structural elements of the rental unit and common areas. For example, if a landlord is aware of a dangerous dog on the premises, they are responsible for having it removed. If they fail to do so and the dog bites someone, the landlord is liable.

Landlords are also responsible for keeping common areas clean and free of debris, and they must advise tenants and visitors of any dangers, such as a broken step. If a landlord's negligence caused an injury, they are liable for it. In addition, landlords can be held liable if they fail to provide reasonable security in a high-risk environment. For instance, if a tenant is attacked because of a broken lock, despite previous complaints, the landlord may be held liable.

In some cases, a tenant's actions or inactions could reduce or eliminate the landlord's liability. For example, if a tenant caused the hazardous condition, failed to notify the landlord about a known danger, or was acting recklessly at the time of the injury.

To hold a landlord liable for an injury, a tenant must typically prove the following:

• Duty: The landlord had a duty to fix the dangerous condition within a reasonable amount of time.
• Breach: The landlord failed to meet their duty to address the dangerous condition.
• Causation: The cause of the injury was the failure to repair the dangerous condition, and the landlord's negligence directly and foreseeably caused the injury.
• Damages: Injuries (damages) resulted from the landlord's behaviour.

Security deposits and refunds

In Texas, for instance, the Texas Property Code (Sections 92.101 to 92.110) outlines the legal protections for tenants who have paid a security deposit. According to Section 92.103, landlords are required to refund the security deposit to the tenant within 30 days of the tenant vacating the premises. However, Section 92.107 provides an exception, stating that landlords are not obligated to return the deposit or provide a written description of damages until the tenant provides their forwarding address for the refund. Nevertheless, even without a forwarding address, tenants do not forfeit their right to a refund. Additionally, Section 92.104 clarifies that landlords cannot retain any portion of the security deposit to cover normal wear and tear, which is defined as deterioration resulting from the intended use of the dwelling.

In California, the state law establishes a four-year statute of limitations for tenants to pursue legal action for habitability issues. However, a lease contract may include a clause that shortens this timeframe, which can create ambiguity. In such cases, the doctrine of contra proferentem dictates that the interpretation favouring the party who did not draft the contract (typically the tenant) should prevail.

In the case of Masseroli v. Gatfield in Westchester County, the court ruled that the law supersedes the lease agreement. In this instance, the lease stated that the security deposit would be returned within 30 days, while the law required it to be returned within 14 days. The landlord was ordered to return the full security deposit plus interest, but the plaintiff's request for punitive damages was denied as the landlord was not aware of the 14-day requirement.

It is essential to review the specific laws and regulations in your state or country regarding security deposits and refunds. These laws outline the rights and obligations of both tenants and landlords, ensuring a fair and transparent process for handling security deposits. While lease agreements may contain specific terms and conditions, they cannot override the protections afforded by state or local laws.

Rent increases and pro-rata payments

While a lease generally cannot supersede state law, it is important to note that a lease can contain specific clauses that may impact your rights and obligations as a tenant. For example, a lease might include a clause that allows for early termination with a specific notice period. In the context of rent increases and pro-rata payments, here are some key considerations:

Rent Increases

As a tenant, it is essential to be aware of your rights regarding rent increases. While lease agreements typically outline the terms of rent, including the amount and payment schedule, landlords may implement rent increases during the lease term. However, rent increases are often subject to state and local regulations, which may dictate the allowable frequency and magnitude of rent adjustments. It is crucial to review applicable laws and understand the valid reasons for rent increases to ensure that any changes are reasonable and compliant.

Pro-Rata Payments

Pro-rata payments, also known as prorated rent, come into play when there is a change in rent or when a tenant moves in or out before the end of a rental period. Here's how it works:

• Calculating Pro-Rata Payments: Pro-rata payments are calculated by assigning a daily rent amount. This is done by dividing the rent for the payment period by the number of days in that period. Then, the daily rent amount is multiplied by the number of days for which the pro-rata payment is owed. Finally, any rent already paid is subtracted to arrive at the pro-rata amount.
• Examples: Suppose you pay rent monthly, and your rent increases during the month. If you pay $2700 per month and your rent increases to $3000 on the 10th day of the month, each day for the first 10 days represents $90 in rent, and each day after the increase represents $100 in rent. For the remaining 20 days of the month, you will owe a pro-rata payment of $200 ($10 difference multiplied by 20 days). In this case, your next regular rent payment will include the new rent amount of $3000, plus the $200 pro-rata payment for the past 20 days.
• Prorated Rent upon Move-In or Move-Out: When a tenant moves in or out before the end of a rental period, landlords may prorate the rent for the partial month. This calculation is based on the number of days the tenant occupies the property. For example, if a tenant moves in on August 20th with a rent due date of September 15th, the prorated rent for August would be calculated by dividing the monthly rent by the number of days in August, then multiplying it by the number of days occupied (12 days in this case).
• State Regulations: It is important to note that some states have specific regulations regarding prorated rent. For instance, in California, landlords must use a flat 30-day cycle (banker's month) option, while in Texas, prorated rent must be calculated using the exact number of days in the given month.

In summary, while the lease agreement itself may not supersede state law, specific clauses within the lease can impact your rights and obligations as a tenant. Regarding rent increases and pro-rata payments, tenants should be aware of their rights under state and local laws while also understanding the terms outlined in their lease agreement.

Lease agreements and local laws

In general, a lease agreement cannot supersede state law. Local laws may prohibit certain provisions in lease agreements, but this is not always the case, and laws can vary from state to state. For example, in Washington State, rent control is not legal, whereas in California, there are specific laws regarding the timing constraints for raising claims in court after lease termination. It is important to be aware of the local laws and adapt any lease agreement to comply with them.

The fundamental principle is that a lease cannot contradict the law, and the law always controls. For instance, if local law states that a deposit must be returned within 30 days, a lease cannot extend this deadline, even with the tenant's agreement. Similarly, a lease cannot require a tenant to give up any rights or protections afforded under the law. Provisions regarding the payment of attorney fees, forgoing litigation, or waiving a landlord's liability for property conditions may be deemed illegal.

However, there are grey areas and complexities. For example, a lease may require a tenant to actively do something, such as clean up after a pet, which may not necessarily breach local laws. Additionally, there may be situations where a lease agreement can provide benefits or protections beyond what is required by law. In the case of a dispute, the doctrine of contra proferentem may come into play, favouring the party who did not draft the contract in situations of ambiguity.

It is essential to be aware of the specific local laws and to tailor lease agreements accordingly. Seeking legal advice and having a lease agreement reviewed by a lawyer before signing can help prevent potential issues.

Frequently asked questions