In-Laws And Divorce: When Mothers-In-Law Interfere

A mother-in-law can be a blessing and a support to some marriages, but she can also create unnecessary strife by sharing her thoughts and opinions about her son or daughter's spouse. This can lead to a rift between the couple, especially if the mother-in-law displays toxic behaviours such as jealousy, competition, criticism, or controlling and opinionated behaviours. In some cases, this can lead to one spouse feeling alienated or bullied, which can ultimately lead to divorce. However, it is important to note that divorce is often the result of years of problems that have piled on, and it is possible to save a marriage by seeking professional help and maintaining a unified front as a couple.

Toxic mother-in-laws

A toxic mother-in-law can be a significant source of stress and unhappiness in a marriage, and in some cases, this can lead to divorce. While it is not the sole reason for a marriage ending, it can be a contributing factor.

A mother-in-law's behaviour can cause issues, especially when she feels her authority and role as the "cruise director" of the family unit is challenged by the new spouse and their traditions and family influence. This can lead to controlling, opinionated, and inflexible behaviours, which can be toxic to the couple's relationship. The mother-in-law may also feel anxious about losing time with her child and grandchildren, leading to overstepping boundaries, particularly when grandchildren are involved. This can result in unsolicited opinions and advice, criticism, and attempts to control or make decisions for the couple.

In some cases, the spouse may feel their partner is siding with their family, causing division and drama within the marriage. This can be a result of unrealistic expectations about the role of the in-laws and a lack of understanding of the boundaries that need to be set. It is important for couples to present a unified front and work together to resolve issues, rather than turning on each other.

If you are dealing with a toxic mother-in-law, it is crucial to take time to evaluate the situation and develop a plan. It is essential to maintain boundaries and remove yourself from uncomfortable or disrespectful situations. Seeking professional help from a therapist or counsellor can also be effective in navigating these challenges.

Additionally, it is important to remember that if your parent is the one causing issues, it is your responsibility to confront the situation and support your spouse. Open communication and considering your partner's needs and feelings can help strengthen your relationship and enable you to move forward as a team.

Unresolved family drama

In a study by psychologist Terri Apter, more than 60% of women reported long-term unhappiness and stress due to their relationship with their mother-in-law. This conflict often stems from perceived criticism or undermining, influenced by persistent gender norms.

Maintaining healthy boundaries is crucial to managing family drama. It is essential to remember that you cannot control your mother-in-law's behaviour, but you can control your response. Couples should present a unified front, addressing issues together and supporting each other. It is the responsibility of the individual whose parent is causing the drama to take the lead in setting boundaries and protecting their spouse from feeling alienated or bullied into agreements.

If you are facing challenges due to a difficult mother-in-law, it is important to evaluate the situation calmly and rationally. Seek a quiet, distraction-free space to process your feelings and develop a plan. Try to understand your mother-in-law's perspective, as her behaviour may stem from larger issues or fears of losing time with her child.

Consider couples therapy to help navigate these challenges and strengthen your marriage. Remember, the best divorce is the one that never takes place. By addressing issues early, maintaining boundaries, and supporting each other, couples can resolve family drama and protect their relationship.

Unmet expectations

• Differing family dynamics and traditions: A mother-in-law, accustomed to being the authority figure and decision-maker in her child's life, may struggle to adapt to the presence of a new spouse and their separate family influence. This can lead to feelings of anxiety and fear of losing time with her child, and a desire to maintain control, resulting in unsolicited advice, criticism, or attempts to influence her child's spouse negatively.
• Unresolved feelings and competition: Jealousy and competition between a mother-in-law and daughter-in-law can create mutual unease and conflict. This may stem from persistent societal norms and expectations about female relationships, leading to a perception of criticism or undermining even when none is intended.
• Lack of boundaries and respect: When a mother-in-law fails to respect the boundaries of the marital relationship, it can create significant strain. This includes overstepping by offering unsolicited opinions on various aspects of the couple's life, such as child-rearing, financial decisions, and relationship dynamics. It is essential for couples to establish and maintain healthy boundaries, ensuring that the mother-in-law "stays in her lane."
• Enabling behaviour from the spouse: If an individual feels that their spouse prioritises their mother's feelings and needs over their own, it can create a sense of alienation and betrayal. Spouses should be mindful of taking sides and instead focus on supporting each other, maintaining a unified front, and prioritising their marriage.
• Accumulation of unresolved issues: Unaddressed problems within the marriage, especially those related to the mother-in-law, can pile up over time. If left unresolved, these issues can reach a breaking point where one or both partners feel they can no longer continue in the relationship.

While a mother-in-law's influence can be a contributing factor to divorce, it is often a combination of unmet expectations, unresolved conflicts, and a lack of mutual support between spouses that leads to the ultimate decision to separate. Seeking professional help from therapists or counsellors can be an effective way to navigate these challenges and find a resolution that strengthens the marital bond.

Lack of boundaries

A mother-in-law can cause conflict and discord when a couple has kids, as she may be around them too much, allowing her more opportunities to offer opinions and unsolicited advice. This can lead to a rift between the couple, especially if the mother-in-law does not like or trust her child's spouse.

A mother-in-law may also display "controlling, opinionated or inflexible behaviours" because of her fears of losing time with her child and the changing family dynamics. This can cause a strain on the relationship between the couple, and the longer this goes on, the more difficult it will be to reassert healthy boundaries and regain privacy and control over the marriage.

It is important to remember that you have no control over your mother-in-law's behaviour, but you do have control over removing yourself from uncomfortable or disrespectful situations. If your mother-in-law is causing issues, it is important to maintain a unified front with your spouse and work together to resolve the problem. This may involve setting and maintaining strong boundaries to protect your marriage.

If your parent is the one meddling in your marriage, it is your responsibility to confront the situation and support your spouse. Involve your partner and allow them to express their feelings, and remind them that you are on their side. If your spouse's parent is the issue, do not address the situation without first talking to your spouse. It is important to maintain a unified front and be a close-knit team when dealing with parents-in-law and extended family drama.

Unaddressed feelings

A mother-in-law can cause a lot of stress in a marriage, and this can lead to divorce. However, it's important to remember that divorce is usually the result of many problems that pile up over the years. A mother-in-law's negative influence can be a contributing factor, but it's often not the sole reason for a marriage ending.

In some cases, the spouse might feel torn between their parent and their partner, which can be challenging to navigate. They might struggle with confronting their parent about their behaviour and risk upsetting their spouse if they don't take action. It's crucial for the spouse to take responsibility, confront the situation, and actively support their partner. This can be an opportunity for the couple to strengthen their bond by prioritising their marriage and presenting a unified front against external influences.

The feelings of the mother-in-law herself should not be overlooked. She might be anxious about losing time with her child or worried about changes to family dynamics, leading to controlling behaviours. Understanding her perspective can help the couple address the root causes of the conflict and find more effective solutions. It's important to remember that while you can't control your mother-in-law's behaviour, you can control how you respond to it and set healthy boundaries to protect your marriage.

Dealing with a difficult mother-in-law can be challenging, but it's crucial to address the situation early on. By acknowledging and addressing unaddressed feelings, couples can work together to minimise the negative impact on their relationship and prevent the issues from escalating. Open communication, empathy, and a unified approach can help navigate this complex family dynamic and prevent it from leading to divorce.

Frequently asked questions