Law Firm Ownership: Non-Lawyers In Texas

In the United States, the general rule is that only licensed attorneys can own law firms. However, there are a few exceptions to this rule, and the trend is moving towards allowing non-lawyer ownership. For example, in Washington, D.C., non-lawyers can hold minority stakes, and a few states, including Arizona, Utah, and California, have taken steps towards allowing non-lawyer ownership of firms. While Texas considered allowing non-lawyer ownership of law firms, it ultimately decided against the idea. Only licensed attorneys in good standing with the State Bar of Texas or those with special permission from the Texas Supreme Court may practice law in Texas.

Non-lawyer ownership of law firms in Texas

In the United States, the default rule has been that only licensed attorneys can own law firms. This rule has been adopted by state bars across the country, barring non-lawyers from holding any ownership interest in law firms. However, this trend is slowly changing, with a growing recognition that non-lawyer ownership of firms may not be harmful. As a result, several states have started to relax this prohibition and are considering or adopting reforms to allow non-lawyer ownership of law firms.

Texas is one of the states that has recently explored the idea of allowing non-lawyer ownership of law firms. While Texas has strict rules regarding the unauthorized practice of law, it is not clear if these rules extend to ownership of law firms. Texas law prohibits non-attorneys from providing legal advice, representing clients in personal injury or property damage matters, and appearing in court on behalf of incarcerated individuals. However, there are some exceptions, such as allowing non-attorneys to represent individuals in certain federal administrative agencies and justice courts.

Currently, there are a few states that allow non-lawyers to hold ownership interests in law firms under limited circumstances. These states include the District of Columbia, Arizona, Utah, and Washington, D.C. In these jurisdictions, non-lawyers can hold minority stakes or have limited ownership interests in law firms. Other states, like California and Massachusetts, have taken more modest steps toward allowing non-lawyer ownership by permitting greater fee-sharing with non-attorney-owned organizations that qualify as nonprofits.

While the traditional view has been that only lawyers can own law firms, the trend in the U.S. is slowly shifting towards allowing non-lawyer ownership. This change may provide law firms with more opportunities and allow for lower rates for clients. However, the primary concern with non-lawyer ownership is maintaining professional independence and preventing the prioritization of profits over ethical duties and client interests. As a result, any reforms or pilot projects in this area will need to carefully balance these considerations to ensure that the interests of clients and the legal profession are protected.

Unauthorized practice of law in Texas

In Texas, it is illegal to practice law without a license. The Texas Unauthorized Practice of Law Committee (UPLC) is responsible for investigating complaints and taking action against individuals engaged in unauthorized practice. The UPLC may pursue both civil and criminal actions. Practicing law includes activities such as preparing legal documents, offering legal advice, or representing someone in a legal proceeding without a license.

The Texas Disciplinary Rule 5.05, titled "Unauthorized Practice of Law," provides that a lawyer licensed to practice in Texas shall not "assist a person who is not a member of the bar in the performance of activity that constitutes the unauthorized practice of law." If a licensed Texas attorney assists an out-of-state attorney in engaging in any legal representation of clients in Texas, the Texas attorney becomes subject to discipline under the Texas Disciplinary Rules.

The Professional Ethics Committee does not have the authority to issue opinions about what constitutes the unauthorized practice of law in Texas. However, the committee assumes that the representation of clients in Texas by an out-of-state attorney solely on issues of federal law in the area of immigration and nationality law does not constitute the unauthorized practice of law, regardless of whether the out-of-state attorney lives in or outside of Texas or is employed by a licensed Texas attorney.

It is important to note that Texas law allows non-attorneys to act on another individual's behalf in eviction cases, and some federal administrative agencies, such as the Social Security Administration, permit non-attorney representatives.

While the general rule in the U.S. is that only licensed attorneys can own law firms, there are a few exceptions. For example, in Washington, D.C., non-lawyers can hold minority stakes, and states like Arizona and Utah have made similar reforms. Texas previously considered allowing non-lawyer ownership of law firms but ended its exploration of this idea.

Licensed attorneys in Texas

In Texas, only licensed attorneys can own law firms. While some states, such as Washington D.C., Arizona, and Utah, allow non-lawyers to hold minority stakes in law firms, Texas has not adopted these reforms. In fact, Texas recently ended its exploration of the idea of allowing non-lawyers to own law firms.

The State Bar of Texas offers a range of benefits to its members, including travel, technology, and office-related perks. It also provides resources for those considering a career as a lawyer, with information on Texas law schools, the Texas Board of Law Examiners, and the Law School Admissions Council. The Texas Young Lawyers Association has also produced a program called "What Do Lawyers Do?", which offers valuable insights into the profession for high school and college students, as well as mentoring opportunities.

Attorneys in Texas can also take advantage of the Lawyer Referral & Information Service, which helps Texans find the right lawyer for their needs. Additionally, the Texas State Law Library publishes legal research guides to assist both self-represented litigants and attorneys in locating the legal information they need.

For those interested in the licensing and certification process for attorneys in Texas, the Supreme Court of Texas is responsible for issuing Ceremonial License Certificates and Certificates of Good Standing. These certificates can be ordered online and come with a fee, which includes postage and handling. The State Bar of Texas website provides further information on attorney licensing and name changes.

Non-attorney employees representing a corporation

In Texas, non-attorney employees are generally prohibited from representing a corporation in court. Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 7 states that a business must be represented by a licensed attorney, and Texas courts have long upheld this requirement. Engaging in the "'unauthorized practice of law'" is a criminal offense under Texas Code § 38.123, which may result in civil and criminal penalties.

However, there is an exception for small claims courts. Under Texas Code § 28.003(e), corporations need not be represented by an attorney in small claims court, where the amount in controversy does not exceed $5000. Nevertheless, even in small claims court, non-attorney representatives of a corporation will be held to the same standards as an attorney, and it is recommended that they consult with corporate counsel before proceeding.

While Texas currently prohibits non-attorney ownership of law firms, it is considering reforms. In recent years, several states, including Arizona, Utah, and Washington D.C., have allowed non-lawyers to hold ownership stakes in law firms, and Texas has shown interest in exploring similar options.

The traditional rule prohibiting non-lawyer ownership of law firms stems from concerns about prioritizing profits over ethical duties and protecting attorney-client confidentiality. However, there is a growing recognition that non-lawyer ownership may have benefits and that blanket prohibition may not be necessary.

As for the formation of corporations in Texas, it is generally recommended that individuals consult with an attorney when selecting a business structure and filing a certificate of formation with the Texas Secretary of State.

Non-lawyer ownership in other states

Texas has ended its exploration of the idea of non-lawyer ownership of law firms. However, non-lawyer ownership of law firms is permitted in a few other states in the US.

The District of Columbia has long been the sole jurisdiction in the country where non-lawyers can hold minority stakes in law firms. In 2020, Utah instituted a regulatory "sandbox" to oversee non-traditional firms with non-lawyer ownership. The Utah model allows for the licensing of traditional law firms with non-lawyer ownership, as well as non-lawyer-owned entities employing lawyers to practice law. Arizona has also eliminated its Rule 5.4, creating a new licensing requirement for Alternate Business Structures (ABS) that are partially owned by non-lawyers but that provide legal services. Each ABS must include at least one lawyer to serve as compliance counsel.

Other states have taken more modest steps toward allowing non-lawyer-owned firms. A 2021 amendment to California's version of Rule 5.4 permits greater fee sharing with non-attorney-owned non-profit organizations that qualify as nonprofits under IRS Rule 501(c)(3). A similar amendment in Massachusetts permits fee sharing with a "qualified legal assistance organization" as long as the fee-sharing is disclosed to and approved by the client. In Georgia, attorneys may work with and share fees with law firms and legal organizations in other jurisdictions, even if those entities have non-attorney ownership. North Carolina and Washington are also considering non-lawyer law firm ownership.

While the trend in the US is toward allowing non-lawyer ownership of firms, most jurisdictions continue to prohibit the practice.

Frequently asked questions