Disbarred Lawyers: Can They Practice Law In California?

Disbarment is the removal of a lawyer's license to practice law, and it is considered a great embarrassment and shame. Disbarment is usually a punishment for unethical or criminal conduct but may also be imposed for incompetence or incapacity. In the United States, disbarment rules vary by state, and it is not always permanent. Suspended or disbarred lawyers in California may be able to practice law again after meeting certain conditions and requirements. This paragraph introduces the topic and provides an overview of the key issues surrounding disbarment and the possibility of reinstatement for lawyers in California.

Disbarred lawyers cannot practice law in California

Attorneys may be disbarred for various reasons, including disciplinary actions, failure to comply with requirements imposed by the California Supreme Court or the State Bar Court, or conviction of a crime involving moral turpitude. Disbarment is a serious consequence for attorneys who violate ethical standards or engage in misconduct.

It is important to note that California's Rule of Professional Conduct 1-311 allows bar members to employ disbarred lawyers for specific tasks that do not constitute practicing law, such as legal research, drafting, and clerical activities. However, the employing lawyer must notify the state bar and clients and ensure that the disbarred attorney does not engage in rendering legal advice, representing clients, or handling client funds.

While disbarred lawyers cannot practice law directly, they may find limited employment opportunities within the legal field under the supervision of an active attorney. This distinction highlights the strict regulations surrounding legal practice in California, ensuring that only qualified and ethical professionals can provide legal services to the public.

In summary, disbarment in California results in the inability to practice law and requires proper notification to protect the public and maintain the integrity of the legal profession.

Suspended lawyers cannot practice law in California

In California, a suspended lawyer is strictly prohibited from practicing law. This means they cannot work in any capacity that would constitute practicing law in the state. The State Bar Court of California has made it clear that suspended lawyers are not allowed to hold themselves out to the public and the courts as attorneys. For example, the use of "Esq." after one's name or referring to oneself as "Attorney" or "Law Offices of [Name]" in various pleadings and correspondence is prohibited during a period of suspension. Such actions may create a misleading impression that the suspended lawyer is currently licensed to practice law.

Business and Professions Code Section 6125 states that only active members of the State Bar can practice law in California. Additionally, Section 6126 criminalizes holding oneself out as an attorney during any period of suspension. Suspended lawyers are required to notify their clients and others of their ineligibility to practice law and must comply with conditions of probation, if any. They may also be required to pass the Multistate Professional Responsibility Examination (MPRE) and must refrain from engaging in the actual practice of law.

While suspended lawyers cannot practice law, they may be allowed to work for other lawyers in a limited capacity. Rule 1-311 of California's Rules of Professional Conduct permits bar members to employ suspended lawyers for specific tasks, such as legal research, drafting, and clerical activities. However, the employing lawyer must notify both the state bar and individual clients when taking on a suspended attorney. The suspended lawyer must not provide legal advice, represent clients, or handle client funds.

It is important to note that failure to comply with the rules and conditions of suspension can have serious consequences. A suspended lawyer's willful failure to comply with the provisions may result in disbarment, revocation of pending probation, or punishment for contempt or a crime. Therefore, it is crucial for suspended lawyers to adhere to the requirements and restrictions imposed during the period of suspension.

Disbarred or suspended lawyers must notify their clients

Disbarred or suspended lawyers in California are required by law to notify their clients of their status and consequent inability to practice law. This is to ensure that clients are aware that the lawyer is no longer qualified to act as their legal representative and that they need to seek legal advice elsewhere. The lawyer must also inform their clients about the urgency of finding new legal representation.

The Supreme Court may include this directive in an order of disbarment or suspension, specifying the time frame within which the lawyer must inform their clients. This notification must be sent via registered or certified mail, with a return receipt requested, and must include an address where further communications may be directed. The lawyer must also file an affidavit with the Clerk of the State Bar Court, confirming their compliance with the notification requirements.

Failing to comply with these rules can result in serious consequences for the lawyer. For disbarred or resigned lawyers, willful failure to notify clients can be grounds for denying their application for reinstatement or readmission. For suspended lawyers, non-compliance can lead to disbarment, suspension, revocation of probation, or punishment for contempt or a crime.

It is important to note that even if a lawyer is temporarily suspended, they must still adhere to the notification requirements. This means that they cannot continue with their current legal work and must inform their clients promptly. Additionally, they may be required to return any client papers or property and withdraw from representation.

Disbarred or suspended lawyers can work for other lawyers

In California, disbarred or suspended lawyers cannot practice law. However, they can work for other lawyers in a limited capacity. California's Rule of Professional Conduct 1-311 allows bar members to employ a disbarred, suspended, resigned, or involuntarily inactive member for tasks such as legal research, drafting, and clerical activities. The employing lawyer must notify both the state bar and individual clients when taking on a suspended attorney. The suspended attorney must not engage in specific acts such as rendering legal advice, representing clients, or handling client funds.

When an attorney is disbarred, their name is removed from the roll of California attorneys by the California Supreme Court, and they are deemed ineligible to practice law. They may be required to notify their clients and other specified parties of their disbarment. Similarly, attorneys under suspension are ineligible to practice law for a specified period and must comply with conditions of probation. They may be required to pass the Multistate Professional Responsibility Examination (MPRE) and notify relevant parties of their suspension.

Attorneys who fail to comply with the requirements imposed by the California Supreme Court or the State Bar Court may face disbarment or further suspension. A disbarred or resigned licensee's willful failure to comply with the provisions of Rule 9.20, which outlines the duties of disbarred, resigned, or suspended attorneys, can result in the denial of their application for reinstatement or readmission.

It is important to note that other states have different rules regarding the employment of suspended or disbarred lawyers. For example, Washington State does not allow disbarred lawyers to be employed as paralegals, law clerks, or legal researchers.

Disbarred or suspended lawyers can be reinstated

In California, disbarred or suspended lawyers are ineligible to practice law. However, reinstatement is possible, although it is a complex process that requires careful planning and preparation.

When an attorney is disbarred, their name is removed from the roll of California attorneys by the California Supreme Court, and they are required to notify their clients and other specified parties of their ineligibility to practice law. Similarly, suspended attorneys are prohibited from practicing law during their suspension period and must also notify their clients and comply with any conditions of probation.

To be reinstated after disbarment or suspension, attorneys must demonstrate that they have rehabilitated themselves from the misconduct that led to their discipline. They must provide clear and convincing evidence of their good moral character, current learning and ability in the law, and fitness to practice. This includes passing the Multistate Professional Responsibility Examination (MPRE) and, in some cases, retaking and passing the Bar exam.

The attorney must also reimburse the State Bar for any disciplinary costs and Client Security Fund payouts. The process of reinstatement is often vigorously opposed by the State Bar, and attorneys may need to wait at least five years from the date of disbarment before applying for reinstatement.

It is important to note that even during suspension, attorneys must be cautious in their use of titles and designations to avoid creating the misleading impression that they are currently licensed to practice law. Failure to comply with these rules can result in further disciplinary action, including disbarment.

Frequently asked questions