Prenuptial Agreements: Overriding California Law?

Prenuptial agreements, also known as prenups, are a legally complex document that can provide financial security and reduce conflict and stress in the event of a divorce. While prenups can be written by the couple themselves in California, they must follow all the requirements of a valid prenuptial agreement and comply with state law to be enforceable. Certain rights, such as a child's right to child support, cannot be overridden by a prenup. This article will explore the extent to which a prenuptial agreement can supersede California state law and the steps necessary to ensure its validity.

Spousal support waivers

In California, a prenuptial agreement, or prenup, can include spousal support waivers. This is where the future spouses agree to waive their right to receive spousal support from each other in the event of a separation or divorce. However, it is not a requirement to include such a waiver in a prenuptial agreement.

To ensure that a spousal support waiver is enforceable, it is important to seek independent legal counsel before agreeing to a prenuptial arrangement. An attorney can help ensure that the waiver is drafted in a way that complies with current law and adequately protects the rights and interests of both parties.

In California, a prenuptial agreement must be in writing and signed by both parties in the presence of a notary to be valid. It is recommended that each party seeks independent legal counsel to ensure their rights and interests are protected, especially if spousal support provisions are included.

Independent legal counsel

In California, a prenuptial agreement is a legally binding contract between two persons intending to marry. This contract establishes what property and income belong to each spouse in the event of a divorce.

In California, you can create your own prenuptial agreement as long as it is in writing and follows all the requirements of a valid prenuptial agreement. However, it is highly recommended that both parties seek independent legal counsel to ensure that their rights and interests are adequately protected. This is especially important if spousal support provisions are included in the prenuptial agreement, as California requires both spouses to seek independent counsel before agreeing to these provisions. Independent legal counsel ensures that both parties fully understand their rights and obligations under the agreement and are not subject to undue influence or coercion.

The famous case of baseball player Barry Bonds and Susann “Sun” Bonds highlights the importance of independent legal counsel in prenuptial agreements. Shortly after meeting in 1988, the couple entered into a prenuptial agreement that waived any interest in Bonds’ income during the marriage and were married the following day. As a result of this case, the California Legislature amended the law, creating an “anti-Bonds” provision. A premarital agreement is now deemed to have been entered involuntarily unless the non-enforcing party was represented by independent counsel at the time of signing, or they expressly waived, in separate writing, representation by counsel after being fully informed of that right.

To ensure the validity of a prenuptial agreement in California, it is also important to have the final form of the document in the hands of each party at least seven days before signing, allowing both parties adequate time to review and consider the terms. Additionally, the agreement must be signed in the presence of a notary. Seeking independent legal counsel can help ensure that a prenuptial agreement complies with state law and adequately protects the rights and interests of both parties.

Child support and custody

In California, prenuptial agreements are a legally binding document that details how a couple will divide their property in the event of a divorce. While prenups can be beneficial for any couple, they are especially crucial when one or both parties have been married before, have significant property or savings, or have children from a previous relationship.

In California, prenuptial agreements cannot regulate child custody or child support. These are areas that are left to the court's authority, which will act in the best interests of the child. Child support is considered a child's right and cannot be contracted away by parents. Prenups also cannot limit a family court's ability to decide matters of visitation.

However, a prenuptial agreement can be used to protect child support cash received from a previous relationship, ensuring that children are still provided for in the event of a divorce. Additionally, if you are receiving child support for children from a previous relationship, you can name your children as partial or full beneficiaries in the event of your spouse's death during the marriage.

While California law allows spouses to waive or limit spousal support under certain conditions, it requires prenuptial agreements to be reasonably fair to both spouses. If a prenup disproportionately favors one spouse over the other, a judge may find the agreement unenforceable. To ensure fairness, it is recommended that both parties seek independent legal counsel before entering into a prenuptial agreement.

Division of marital assets

In California, a prenuptial agreement can be used to determine the division of marital assets, rather than being subject to the state's community property laws. This allows couples to classify what is and is not separate property, and how community property will be divided and distributed.

California's community property law emphasizes equality, meaning that in the absence of a prenup, the court will divide all marital assets equally. Marital property includes all assets gained during a marriage, with some exceptions. If one spouse receives a gift or inheritance during a marriage, this is considered their separate property. If one spouse obtains property by using their own separate assets, the acquired property is also separate. However, separate assets can become marital assets, either purposefully or accidentally. For example, if spouses without a prenuptial agreement commingle their personal property with community property, the former may become community property subject to 50/50 division.

A prenup allows couples to specify what property belongs to each spouse and how they would like to distribute the assets in the event of a divorce. It can also address issues such as spousal support, inheritance rights, and property division. For example, a prenup can ensure that one spouse is not obligated to pay the other spouse's student loan or credit card debt in the event of a divorce.

It is important to note that certain rights cannot be bargained away in a prenuptial agreement due to legal requirements. For instance, a future spouse cannot waive their right to share in an ERISA-governed employee benefit plan as only a current spouse can do so according to federal law. Additionally, a prenup cannot negatively affect a child's right to child support or take away a court's power to control child custody and visitation after marriage.

To be valid in California, a prenuptial agreement must be in writing, signed by both parties, and comply with state law. It is recommended that both parties seek independent legal counsel to ensure their rights and interests are protected and to understand the legal and financial implications of the agreement.

Validity and enforceability

The validity and enforceability of prenuptial agreements in California are subject to specific requirements and legal principles. Firstly, it is crucial to understand that prenuptial agreements are complex legal documents, and improper drafting can lead to future liability. While couples are legally allowed to create their own prenuptial agreements in California, it is strongly advised to consult a qualified attorney specializing in family law to ensure compliance with state and local laws.

To be valid, a prenuptial agreement must be in writing and signed by both spouses in the presence of a notary. This agreement becomes effective once the couple marries. Additionally, if spousal support provisions are included, both parties must seek independent legal counsel to ensure they fully understand their rights and obligations. This requirement helps protect against undue influence or coercion.

The content of the prenuptial agreement must also be carefully considered. Certain rights cannot be bargained away, such as a child's right to child support or a court's power to control child custody and visitation. Furthermore, the agreement must be fair and not excessively favour one spouse over the other. If a court finds the agreement to be unconscionable or unjust, it may be deemed invalid and unenforceable.

Prenuptial agreements can be revised or overridden by a postnuptial agreement, also known as a postmarital contract. This requires the valid consent of both spouses and must be drafted as a separate document. Proper legal procedures and the advice of legal professionals are essential to ensure the validity and enforceability of both prenuptial and postnuptial agreements.

Frequently asked questions