Census Data: A Tool For Law Enforcement?

Census data is highly sensitive and protected by confidentiality laws, with the U.S. Census Bureau committing to keep individual responses confidential and use the data for statistical purposes only. This data is used to inform funding for social services like schools, healthcare, and roads. However, there have been concerns about how this data could be used against vulnerable communities, especially with the addition of a citizenship question in the 2020 Census. While the Census Bureau can release aggregate statistical data, such as the number of people under 18 in a county, it cannot disclose individual responses or personal information. This distinction is important when considering the use of census data for law enforcement purposes, such as in the Census of State and Local Law Enforcement Agencies (CSLLEA).

Census data is confidential and protected under Title 13 of the US Code

The confidentiality of census data is a serious matter, and it is protected under Title 13 of the US Code. This means that private information is never published. It is against the law to disclose or publish any private information that could identify an individual or business, such as names, addresses (including GPS coordinates), Social Security numbers, and telephone numbers. The Census Bureau collects this information to produce statistics, and personal information cannot be used against respondents by any government agency or court.

The law is very clear on this matter, and any disclosure of private information is illegal, no matter the reason. This includes the use of census data for law enforcement, which would not be considered a statistical purpose. The Census Bureau employees are sworn to protect the confidentiality of the data and are legally required to do so for life, with severe penalties for violating this law, including a federal prison sentence of up to five years, a fine of up to $250,000, or both.

The protection of confidential information under Title 13 applies to all government departments, bureaus, agencies, officers, and employees, except for the Secretary, who may require copies of census reports for the statistical purposes outlined in the title. These copies are immune from legal process and cannot be used without the consent of the individual or establishment in any action, suit, or other judicial or administrative proceeding.

The US Census Bureau cannot disclose individual census responses

The US Census Bureau is committed to protecting the confidentiality of its data. Under Title 13 of the US Code, responses to Census Bureau surveys and censuses must be kept confidential and can only be used for statistical purposes. This means that the Census Bureau cannot release individual data or personal responses, such as the names of people living at a specific address. This information cannot be released to any other party for any purpose or reason.

The Bureau's commitment to confidentiality is essential to maintaining the trust of the American people and ensuring their willingness to participate in future censuses and surveys. All staff working with confidential information at the Census Bureau take a lifetime oath to protect the privacy and confidentiality of respondent information. Unlawful disclosure is a federal crime punishable by a fine of up to $250,000, five years in prison, or both.

The Bureau understands that its success depends on the voluntary participation of households and businesses, and it takes this responsibility seriously. They are at the forefront of researching and developing best practices for data protection, including how to apply disclosure avoidance procedures to data products. The Bureau also collaborates with leading industry and academic experts to safeguard the information entrusted to them.

The confidentiality laws apply equally to data provided online, in person, over the telephone, or through the mail. While the Census Bureau can provide aggregate statistical data, such as the number of people under age 18 in a county, this information does not identify specific individuals or households. This type of general statistical data is used for legitimate purposes, such as identifying disparities in learning opportunities for different racial and ethnic groups by the Department of Education.

In summary, the US Census Bureau is legally and ethically bound to protect the confidentiality of individual census responses. Any disclosure of personal information is a serious offence and is punishable by law. These strict confidentiality measures are in place to ensure that the census data is used solely for statistical purposes and cannot be used to harm or target specific individuals or communities.

Census data can be used to identify vulnerable communities

The Census Bureau's Community Resilience Estimates program provides data and tools that help decision-makers understand their communities' vulnerabilities. This data can be used to identify areas with higher social vulnerability, such as coastal and large counties, which are often more distressed and vulnerable when disasters strike. Additionally, the Bureau can produce aggregate statistical data, such as the number of people under 18 in a county, to identify disparities in learning opportunities for different racial and ethnic groups.

Census data can also be used to address social inequalities and improve community resilience in the face of climate change. For example, a climate-focused data product found that almost one in four individuals in the United States has low resilience to extreme heat exposure due to social factors. This information can be used to develop interventions and policies to support vulnerable communities in adapting to and mitigating the impacts of climate change.

However, there are concerns about how census data could be used against vulnerable communities. For example, the addition of a citizenship question to the 2020 Census in the United States raised fears that certain communities might be targeted or deprived of resources and representation. Nevertheless, it is important to note that laws protect the confidentiality of individual responses, and this information cannot be used by law enforcement for statistical purposes.

Census data helps determine funding for social services

Census data plays a pivotal role in shaping various aspects of society, including the allocation of resources for social services. This data helps governments understand the demographic makeup and needs of their constituents, allowing for more informed decisions about funding allocation.

The information collected through censuses provides valuable insights into the size and characteristics of different communities. For example, aggregate statistical data, such as the number of people under 18 in a county, can be used by the Department of Education to identify disparities in learning opportunities for different racial and ethnic groups. This, in turn, can inform funding decisions to address these disparities and improve educational outcomes for underrepresented groups.

Similarly, census data can be used to determine the allocation of resources for healthcare services. By understanding the demographics and health needs of a community, policymakers can make informed decisions about funding allocations to ensure that healthcare services are adequately resourced and accessible to those who need them. This includes considering factors such as the age distribution, prevalence of chronic diseases, and access to primary care providers when allocating healthcare funding.

Census data is also essential for infrastructure planning and funding. For instance, transportation planners can use census data to understand population distribution and travel patterns, helping them decide where to allocate funding for road construction and maintenance. Additionally, census data on population density and growth rates can inform decisions about funding for other critical infrastructure projects, such as the expansion of water and electricity systems.

The confidentiality of individual responses is of utmost importance in the census process. Laws such as Title 13 of the U.S. Code protect the privacy of respondents by requiring the Census Bureau to keep all responses confidential and use them solely for statistical purposes. These legal safeguards ensure that census data cannot be used to harm individuals or communities and that personal information will not be shared with law enforcement or immigration enforcement agencies. The Census Bureau takes extensive measures to protect respondent privacy, including oaths of confidentiality taken by all staff handling confidential information.

Census data can be used for law enforcement staffing

Census data can be used to inform law enforcement staffing decisions. While census data is protected by confidentiality laws and cannot be used for law enforcement directly, aggregate statistical data can be used for legitimate purposes. For example, the number of people under the age of 18 in a county can be used by the Department of Education to identify disparities in learning opportunities for different racial and ethnic groups. Similarly, census data can be used to understand the number of law enforcement officers required to serve a given population.

The Census of State and Local Law Enforcement Agencies (CSLLEA) in 2018 collected data from nearly 20,000 agencies operating nationwide. This included the number of sworn and civilian personnel by state and type of agency, as well as the functions performed by each agency. This data can be used to inform law enforcement staffing decisions, ensuring that agencies have the necessary resources to effectively serve their populations.

For example, the 2018 CSLLEA data showed that local police departments accounted for 67% of state and local law enforcement agencies, employing 59% of full-time sworn personnel. Sheriffs' offices accounted for 17% of agencies and employed 24% of full-time sworn personnel. This information can be used to allocate resources and staff law enforcement agencies appropriately, ensuring that they are adequately equipped to serve their communities.

It is important to note that while census data can inform law enforcement staffing decisions, it is subject to confidentiality laws and cannot be used to target or harm specific individuals or communities. The Census Bureau is committed to protecting the confidentiality of respondent information and takes steps to ensure that statistical products do not identify individuals, households, or businesses. Any unlawful disclosure of census information is a federal crime punishable by a fine, imprisonment, or both.

Frequently asked questions