Lease Agreements: State Law Vs Rental Lease, Who Wins?

The relationship between rental leases and state law is a complex one, with an ongoing power struggle between the freedom to enter into contracts and the letter of landlord-tenant law. While leases can be easily changed to add or subtract provisions, they cannot contradict state law. For example, a lease cannot require a tenant to give up any right or protection afforded under the law. However, local laws may prohibit certain provisions in leases, but not all local laws do. For instance, while state law in North Carolina does not allow tenants to sign away rights regarding heat and access to water, a lease can require tenants to actively do something, such as professionally cleaning the carpets. Ultimately, the specific relationship between rental leases and state law will depend on the individual jurisdiction and the provisions in question.

Leases cannot contradict state law

Leases are legal contracts, and many people assume that the clauses in a lease are non-negotiable and legal according to federal, state, and local laws. However, this is not always the case. While leases are legal contracts, they cannot contradict or supersede state law. For example, state law may explicitly state that a landlord cannot refuse to make repairs, but there may be no law preventing a landlord from requiring a tenant to get the carpets professionally cleaned. In this case, the lease provision would not contradict state law and would be legal.

It is important to note that local laws may prohibit certain provisions in leases, but not all local laws do. As a result, it is crucial to tailor lease agreements to the specific local laws where the property is located. This can be a challenging task, especially for landlords who own properties in multiple states, as what may be acceptable in one state could be illegal in another.

To ensure compliance with the law, landlords should seek legal advice and have their lease agreements reviewed by a local landlord attorney before presenting them to tenants. This can help to avoid any illegal or unenforceable provisions in the lease. For example, a lease provision that requires a tenant to give up certain rights or protections afforded under the law would likely be unenforceable.

In some cases, leases may contain a "severability" clause, which allows any illegal portions of the lease to be severed from the rest of the contract, which remains in force. This can provide some protection for landlords who inadvertently include illegal provisions in their lease agreements. However, it is always best to ensure that the lease complies with all applicable laws to avoid any potential issues or disputes with tenants.

Local laws may prohibit certain provisions

Leases and rental agreements cannot supersede state law. However, they can include provisions that are more restrictive than state law, as long as they do not violate it. For example, a landlord can prohibit smoking in a rental unit, even if state law allows it. Similarly, landlords can set restrictions on tenants' use of the property, such as prohibiting waterbeds or plants on wood floors, as long as these restrictions are not discriminatory or retaliatory.

Landlords may also include provisions in the lease that specify the premises are "for residential purposes only," prohibiting tenants from running a business from the rental property. This is generally to prevent increased traffic and liability concerns. However, landlords may not be able to flatly prohibit certain types of businesses, such as family-run daycares, in states with laws encouraging them. In these cases, landlords may still impose limitations, such as restricting the number of children or ensuring compliance with state fire and health regulations.

Leases often contain provisions that protect the landlord's interests, such as prohibiting tenants from intentionally damaging the property or creating a nuisance for other residents. These provisions are typically enforceable as long as they do not violate tenants' rights granted by state law. For example, a landlord cannot refuse to make repairs, as explicitly stated in state law. However, a landlord may include a provision requiring tenants to get the carpets professionally cleaned, as there is no conflicting state law.

While leases can outline restrictions and responsibilities for tenants, they must still comply with local and state laws. For instance, a lease cannot include a provision that signs away rights explicitly granted by law. In the case of North Carolina law, a lease cannot state that the landlord is not responsible for providing heat and access to water in the rental property. However, the lease may require the tenant to actively do something, such as clean up after a pet, as long as it does not breach existing laws.

State law dictates timing constraints for raising claims in court

In the United States, state law dictates the timing constraints for raising claims in court, which are known as statutes of limitations. These statutes of limitations vary depending on the type of lawsuit and the state in question. For example, in California, the statute of limitations for damages is four years, whereas a rental contract may stipulate a six-month statute of limitations.

In the case of rental leases, state law takes precedence over the lease agreement. For instance, a lease might state that tenants can only pursue legal action within 30 days of terminating the lease, whereas state law may allow a longer period. In such cases, the state law would supersede the lease agreement.

However, it is important to note that the interpretation of these timing constraints can be complex. For example, the phrase "within 30 days of termination" could be construed as "by the 30th day after termination has occurred," thus extending the timeframe. Additionally, federal court rulings can also impact the applicability and enforceability of these statutes.

Furthermore, each state has its own unique set of statutes of limitations, and these laws can change over time. Therefore, it is essential to refer to the specific state laws and seek legal advice when considering raising a claim in court.

Landlords must comply with state law on repairs

Leases do not supersede state law. Landlords are responsible for making all repairs in the rented unit, except in cases where the tenant or the tenant's invitees cause the damage. Landlords must comply with state law on repairs and are required to make a diligent effort to repair a problem if it "materially affects the physical health or safety of an ordinary tenant". For example, sewage backups, roaches, rats, no hot water, faulty wiring, roof leaks, and sometimes a lack of heat or air conditioning.

State law outlines landlords' obligations to keep rented units safe and livable. Landlords must also maintain their units to comply with all local codes that govern housing quality. They must provide adequate heat and hot water, locks, and maintain all structural components in reasonably good repair, among other things.

If a landlord fails to carry out their duties, tenants may submit a good-faith estimate of the cost to perform the repairs and, if the landlord fails to commence remedial action within the applicable time period, the tenant may contract with a licensed or registered person to make the repair and deduct the cost from the rent. However, tenants must be current with their rent to access these repair remedies.

Tenants may also be liable for repairs that are the result of unreported issues in the apartment if those issues cause further damage in the unit. It is always best to document the unit before moving out to protect oneself from being charged for damages one is not responsible for.

Lease agreements must be tailored to local law

Local laws may prohibit certain provisions, but not all. For instance, a lease may require a tenant to actively do something, such as professionally cleaning the carpets, as long as it does not conflict with state law. In North Carolina, for example, a lease cannot state that the landlord is not responsible for providing heat and access to water in the house. However, a lease can require a tenant to clean up after a pet, as long as the landlord complies with rules about security deposits.

The right balance must be struck in each individual lease agreement, taking into account the local law. This can be challenging due to the nature of landlord-tenant laws, which can be reactionary, difficult to interpret, and unresponsive to the needs of landlords. Landlords should be aware that what is acceptable in one state may be illegal in another. For example, in Ohio, the law states that a 30-day notice to vacate is acceptable, while a lease may state a 60-day notice is required.

To avoid any issues, landlords should have their lease agreements reviewed by a local landlord attorney before asking a tenant to sign. This can help ensure that the lease agreement complies with local laws and does not include any illegal provisions. By following this step, landlords can avoid potential legal issues and ensure a smooth rental process.

Frequently asked questions