Inheritance Law: Sisters-In-Law And Their Rights

Inheritance laws can be confusing, and it's not always easy to understand who can and cannot inherit. The laws vary from state to state and country to country, and the presence or absence of a will, trust, or other legal documents can significantly impact the outcome. In the case of a sister-in-law, she is not a statutorily-protected relation, meaning that she can be barred from inheriting from her in-laws' will. However, if her spouse has access to the inheritance, there is no way to prevent her from accessing it as well.

Can a sister-in-law inherit?

Inheritance laws vary by state and country

In the absence of a will, intestate laws come into play, and the order of inheritance typically follows: spouse, children/grandchildren, parents, siblings, and other extended family. This means that in most cases, siblings are not high in the order of inheritance and are considered only if there are no other closer relatives of the deceased. However, if the deceased had no will and no surviving spouse, children, or parents, their estate would pass to their siblings, assuming they are considered heirs under state law.

The definition of "sibling" can vary when it comes to inheritance. For example, in Louisiana, the law defines siblings based on family relations rather than personal relationships. This means that half-siblings, step-siblings, and even adopted siblings or friends considered siblings may inherit, depending on the specifics of the will or state intestacy laws.

The situation becomes more complex when dealing with shared property, such as a house inherited by multiple siblings. In such cases, disagreements may arise regarding whether to keep, rent, or sell the property. While some states may allow an executor to sell the property without the consent of the beneficiaries, it is generally advisable for siblings to discuss their wishes early on and try to reach a compromise to avoid costly legal battles.

Additionally, the existence of a will does not always prevent disputes. For example, a parent may wish to exclude a daughter-in-law from inheriting their estate, but once their son inherits, it becomes his property, and he may choose to leave it to his wife. In some jurisdictions, certain relatives cannot be disinherited without their consent, but a daughter-in-law is typically not one of the protected relations.

Intestacy laws favour siblings when there are no closer relatives

Intestacy laws, or laws that dictate how a decedent's assets are distributed upon their death without a will, generally favour closer relatives over distant ones. While the order of inheritance varies across different states, the first in line to inherit assets are typically the surviving spouse, domestic partner, or biological/adopted children of the deceased.

However, if the deceased has no surviving spouse, partner, or children, then the inheritance will go to the decedent's other surviving kin, which may include their siblings. In such cases, intestacy laws would favour siblings, and they will inherit the estate.

For example, if a person dies without a will and has no living spouse, partner, or children, but has three living siblings, these siblings would be entitled to an equal share of the inheritance. The same would apply if the deceased's spouse, partner, or children died before them.

It is important to note that inheritance laws can vary from state to state, and there may be complexities and exceptions to these general rules. For instance, in some states, step-siblings are considered legal siblings and have the same rights as blood-related siblings, while in others, they are not included in the line of succession unless they were adopted by the decedent's parents.

To avoid confusion and ensure your wishes are carried out, it is recommended to create a will or trust that outlines your desired distribution of assets.

A will can outline conditions for inheritance

In the absence of a will, inheritance laws can be confusing and vary from state to state. Generally, siblings are not high in the order of inheritance, and adult siblings are not seen as close relatives when it comes to inheritance laws. In most cases, the order of inheritance is as follows: spouse, children (and/or grandchildren), parents, siblings (and other descendants of their parents, such as nieces and nephews), and finally, aunts and uncles.

However, if the deceased had no spouse or partner, no children or legal stepchildren, and their parents are also deceased, then intestacy laws would favour siblings. In such cases, the surviving siblings would inherit the entire estate.

To avoid confusion and ensure your wishes are carried out, it is advisable to create a will or trust. A will allows you to determine what will happen to your property after your death. You can outline specific conditions for inheritance, such as excluding certain individuals or leaving specific portions of your estate to chosen beneficiaries. For example, you can include a clause that states, "all to my wife, but if she dies before me, all split evenly among children A, B, C, and D."

While it is possible to write a simple will on your own, it is recommended to consult an attorney to ensure the document is valid and enforceable. By creating a will, you can prevent disputes among your loved ones and guarantee that your wishes are respected.

In addition to a will, you may also consider setting up a trust. A trust can provide you with more control over what happens to your assets after your death. For example, you can leave your assets to a sibling through a trust that allows them to use the money during their lifetime, with the remainder going to their children after their death. This is known as a "claw-back" provision, which can help ensure that your assets ultimately benefit those you intend.

Siblings can be excluded by compulsory heirs

In the context of inheritance, the term “compulsory heirs” refers to individuals who are legally entitled to a portion of the deceased's estate, irrespective of the will's provisions. Intestacy laws or intestate succession laws come into play when a person dies without a will or trust, or when the benefactors named in the will are deceased. Intestate succession laws outline the order of inheritance, which is typically as follows:

• Spouse or domestic partner
• Children (biological and adopted)
• Grandchildren
• Parents
• Siblings
• Aunts and uncles

The above order of inheritance is not set in stone and can vary from state to state. For example, in the Philippines, inheritance laws are governed by the Civil Code, which recognizes illegitimate children as compulsory heirs, although their share is generally less than that of legitimate children.

In most cases, siblings are not high in the order of inheritance and can be excluded by certain compulsory heirs. This means that siblings will only inherit if there are no other closer relatives of the decedent to inherit the estate. If the decedent is survived by their spouse and siblings, the surviving spouse typically gets half of the estate, with the remaining half going to the siblings. If there is only one surviving sibling, they will inherit the entire estate; if there are four, each will inherit 25%.

The presence of a will or trust can further complicate the matter. For instance, if a sibling is living in a deceased parent's home during the administration of the estate, the executor or administrator should collect rent from them to avoid being held personally liable for any subsequent loss in value of the estate or trust. Additionally, if there is a disagreement among siblings over how to divide inherited property, it is recommended to hire a property dispute lawyer to represent their interests and enforce their rights.

Inheritance disputes can lead to legal action

Inheritance laws can be confusing, and it is not always clear who can and cannot inherit. Disputes can arise over the validity of a will, the interpretation of a will, or the distribution of assets. In some cases, these disputes can lead to legal action.

Common Causes of Inheritance Disputes

Inheritance disputes can arise for several reasons. One common cause is a lack of estate planning documents, such as a will or trust. If a person dies without a will, their estate will be subject to intestate rules, which are set by the state and may not reflect the wishes of the deceased.

Another common cause of inheritance disputes is perceived inequality. For example, if a decedent with two children leaves one child significantly more assets than the other, the child who receives less may raise a dispute. Disputes can also arise when a decedent leaves property to someone other than their spouse or children, or when there are changes in circumstances since the will was made, such as a remarriage or the birth of a child.

Legal Action

If an inheritance dispute cannot be resolved amicably, legal action may be taken. In some cases, a potential beneficiary may have a recourse against a wrongdoer who interfered with their expected inheritance. This is known as a claim for intentional interference with inheritance (IIWI). To establish liability, a plaintiff must prove that they had an expectation of receiving an inheritance and that the defendant interfered with that expectation by committing fraud or some other wrongful conduct.

In other cases, a dispute may arise over the validity of a will, with claims that it was procured by coercion, duress, or undue influence. In these instances, a will contest may be submitted to probate court to determine the validity of the will. If the will is found to be invalid, the estate will be distributed according to intestacy rules.

Preventing Inheritance Disputes

The best way to prevent inheritance disputes is to create a thorough and detailed estate plan, including a will, powers of attorney, an advance directive, and, if appropriate, a trust. By clearly outlining your wishes in these documents, you can help to ensure that your estate is distributed according to your wishes and reduce the likelihood of disputes arising.

Frequently asked questions