Town Governance: Can A Town Pass A Law?

A town can pass a law, also known as a local ordinance, which is issued by a local government such as a municipality, county, or parish. The process of passing a law varies depending on the location and type of government. In the United States, for example, a bill must be passed by the local council and approved by the mayor to become a law. In other countries like Germany and Japan, local authorities have the power to pass ordinances, but these must follow a public disclosure and consultation procedure and be approved by the local assembly and an elected representative. The laws passed by towns and cities cover a range of topics, from public safety and land use to civil rights and business regulations, and play a significant role in shaping the day-to-day lives of their residents.

Local ordinances

A local ordinance is a law issued by a local government such as a municipality, county, parish, prefecture, or similar. In the United States, local ordinances are enforced in addition to state law and federal law. In states like Connecticut, legislative bodies at the local level develop city and town ordinances to govern the public. Local ordinances in the US can address criminal law, but due to the Double Jeopardy Clause of the Fifth Amendment, a person cannot be prosecuted under both local ordinance and state law for the same offence.

In Hong Kong, all laws enacted by the Legislative Council are known as Ordinances. The German Constitution grants federated states certain exclusive rights, including police and public order powers. Local authorities have the power to pass local ordinances, for example, to determine the use of land, planning, public order, and transport issues. The ordinance must follow a public disclosure and consultation procedure and then be approved by the local assembly and the elected representative of the executive, such as the mayor.

In Japan, ordinances may be passed by any prefecture or municipality under authority granted by Article 94 of the Constitution. Ordinances must generally be approved by a local assembly and promulgated by the mayor or governor of the local government, who may demand a second vote but cannot veto.

In the US, the process of passing a local ordinance is predetermined and must be done in public with opportunities for citizen voices to be heard. The first draft of a proposed ordinance is read aloud during a council meeting, followed by a "First Reading" where citizens can provide their perspective. The council will then vote on whether to move forward. Passed bills are forwarded to the mayor for approval, and if vetoed, the council will reconsider the bill. If at least six councilmembers vote to override the veto, the bill becomes law.

State laws

In the United States, towns can pass laws, known as ordinances, at a local level in addition to state laws. Each state has its own executive, legislative, and judicial branches, and they can address a broad range of legal issues. However, if there is a conflict between state and local laws, state laws override municipal ordinances.

Local ordinances are issued by a local government, such as a municipality, county, or town. They are often used to address specific issues within a certain geographic area. For example, a municipality may designate an area for industrial use only, with regulations for dimensions, placement of utilities, parking, and types of buildings.

The process of passing a local ordinance typically involves a predetermined, democratic process. This includes public disclosure and consultation, approval by a local assembly and elected representative (e.g. a mayor), and the opportunity for citizen input. In the US, citizens can provide input through public hearings, addressing the council, or contacting councilmembers directly.

In some cases, there may be conflicts between local ordinances and state laws. For example, in North Carolina, the state government overturned an ordinance passed by Charlotte, NC, that protected LGBT people from discrimination. The state also passed a law barring cities from enacting non-discrimination regulations. Similarly, in Pennsylvania, there was a conflict between Grant Township's Home Rule Charter, which aimed to protect the environment, and state oil-and-gas policies. These cases highlight the dynamic relationship between state laws and local ordinances, where state laws can sometimes restrict the autonomy of towns and municipalities in passing certain ordinances.

Municipal laws

Municipalities have the power to make laws for specific purposes and geographic areas. For example, a municipality may designate an area for industrial use only, with regulations for dimensions, placement of utilities, parking, and types of buildings. These laws are known as zoning ordinances and can apply to both businesses and residential areas.

The process of creating or changing a municipal law typically involves the local legislative body, such as a city council, proposing an ordinance. This proposed ordinance is then subject to a predetermined, democratic process, which includes public disclosure and consultation, and approval by the local assembly and the elected representative, such as the mayor. The exact process can vary between municipalities. For example, in Seattle, proposed ordinances are reviewed by the Law Department and must include a Fiscal Note describing the financial impact. In contrast, in Germany, citizens with a strong interest in the outcome may object to the final implementation of an ordinance.

Zoning ordinances

A town can pass a law in the form of a local ordinance. A local ordinance is a law issued by a local government such as a municipality, county, or town. In the United States, local ordinances are enforced in addition to state law and federal law.

Changes to zoning ordinances can create tension among current and prospective residents and landlords. For example, if a new business intends to move to a specific city, but the zoning rules change in that geographic region, the business may no longer be able to operate there. In some cases, existing tenants may be forced to relocate due to these changes. However, zoning ordinances sometimes contain legacy clauses, also known as grandfather clauses, which exempt existing tenants from being impacted by changes to the zoning rules.

Resolutions

In the United States, towns can pass laws at a local level in addition to state law and federal law. These laws are known as local ordinances. In some states, such as Connecticut, local legislative bodies develop town ordinances to govern the public. However, it is important to note that a local ordinance is considered the same as a state law for criminal processing purposes due to the Double Jeopardy Clause of the Fifth Amendment. This means that an individual cannot be prosecuted under both a local ordinance and a state law for the same offense.

The process of passing a local ordinance varies but typically involves a predetermined procedure that includes public input and approval by a local assembly and an elected representative, such as a mayor. For example, in Seattle, a proposed ordinance undergoes a "First Reading" during a city council meeting, followed by a period for "public comment." The council then votes on whether to move forward with the ordinance. If passed, the ordinance is forwarded to the mayor for approval. If the mayor vetoes the ordinance, the city council can override the veto with a vote of at least six councilmembers.

In other countries, the ability of towns to pass laws varies. For instance, in Germany, the constitution grants federated states certain exclusive rights, including police and public order powers, which can be delegated to local authorities. These local authorities have the power to pass ordinances on matters such as land use, planning, public order, and transport. Similarly, in Japan, prefectures or municipalities may pass ordinances under the authority granted by Article 94 of the Constitution. These ordinances must comply with overlapping statutes and be related to the affairs of the local government.

While towns can pass laws through local ordinances, it is important to note that state laws generally override municipal ordinances in case of a conflict. This was seen in the case of Charlotte, North Carolina, where the state government overturned an ordinance protecting LGBT individuals from discrimination. Additionally, the concept of "home rule," where a town adopts its own Bill of Rights and charter to assert its right to self-govern, has gained traction in recent years. However, even with home rule, towns must ensure that their laws do not conflict with state or federal law.

Frequently asked questions