Catholics And Law Of Attraction: Is It Compatible?

The Law of Attraction is a New Age concept that suggests an individual's thoughts can directly influence their life outcomes, attracting positive or negative experiences. While some people find it compatible with their religious beliefs, the question arises: Is the Law of Attraction compatible with Catholicism? This topic has sparked debates among Catholics, with some embracing it as a tool for spiritual growth and others considering it contradictory to core Catholic teachings.

The Law of Attraction is incompatible with Catholic thinking

The "Law of Attraction" (LOA) is a New Age concept that suggests a person can attract positive or negative experiences into their life by focusing on positive or negative thoughts. In other words, "think it, and make it so".

While some argue that the LOA is not incompatible with the Catholic Church or Christianity, many Catholics believe that the LOA is at odds with Catholic thinking. Here are some reasons why:

• The LOA suggests that individuals are in control of their destiny and can use their thoughts to control the universe. This contradicts the Christian ethos, which holds that God is in control and has established the laws of nature. Catholics believe that their prayers will be answered through Jesus Christ in accordance with His will, not their own.
• The LOA can be seen as a form of superstition or even satanic. It may lead people to believe that they are just as powerful as God, which is considered the height of pride, one of the seven deadly sins. Catholics believe that only God, as the Creator of the universe, can provide and that positive or negative outcomes are not solely due to an individual's thoughts.
• The LOA may detract from the importance of faith and good works in Catholic teaching. While positive thinking and a good outlook can be beneficial, Catholics believe that true change and conversion come from submitting to God's will and grace, not solely from one's thoughts or mindset.
• The LOA may lead to an emotional rollercoaster and a sense of self-blame if things do not go as envisioned. Catholics are called to have faith in God and accept His will, rather than relying solely on their thoughts to manifest their desires.

While there may be some overlap between the LOA and Catholic teachings, such as the importance of positive thinking, the LOA in its essence, which suggests that individuals can control their reality through their thoughts, is not compatible with the fundamental tenets of Catholic thinking.

The Law of Attraction is a New Age concept

The Law of Attraction (LOA) is a New Age concept that has gained popularity in recent years due to books and movies such as "The Secret" and "The Power". It is a philosophy that suggests positive thoughts bring positive outcomes into a person's life, while negative thoughts attract negative experiences. This idea of "like attracts like" is one of the 12 universal laws that ancient cultures are believed to have always intuitively known.

The LOA is often associated with positive thinking and manifestation techniques, where individuals use mental visualization and positive affirmations to attract their desires. While some supporters of the LOA refer to scientific theories to back their claims, there is no scientific evidence to support the effectiveness of the LOA. Critics argue that it is based on superstition and that it contradicts Christian teachings, particularly Catholic beliefs.

In Catholicism, the idea that one's thoughts can control the universe is considered contrary to Christian ethos. It is seen as an act of pride, one of the seven deadly sins, as it implies that individuals are as powerful as God. Catholic apologists argue that while positive thinking can positively impact one's life, it is not a magical attraction of desires but rather a natural outcome of a positive outlook.

However, some Catholics argue that the LOA is not incompatible with their faith. They believe that the LOA is a way to connect with God and ask for guidance and support. They view it as a form of prayer, where they start with an optimistic mindset and believe that God will provide what is needed for a positive outcome.

The debate among Catholics regarding the compatibility of the LOA with their faith highlights the complexity of integrating New Age concepts with traditional religious beliefs. While some find value in the LOA's ability to enhance their spiritual practice, others view it as a deception that contradicts the core tenets of Catholicism.

The Law of Attraction replaces God with the universe

The "Law of Attraction" (LOA) is a New Age concept that has been described as "think positive thoughts and positive things will happen to you". In other words, "think it, and make it so". The LOA suggests that positive thoughts are sent out to the universe and rewarded, while negative thoughts return negative effects.

The LOA is not compatible with Catholic Church teachings. This is because the LOA replaces God with the universe. The universe is a created thing and has no power to bless or curse—that power belongs to God alone. God created the universe and established the laws of nature. The LOA, therefore, gives a false sense of control.

Some people argue that the LOA is based on Christian teachings. They argue that the LOA is about asking God to provide a clear path and believing that God will provide what is needed to ensure things go positively. However, the Bible teaches that we can trust and rely on God to take care of us. God wants us to rely on Him, and he will work all things together for our good.

The Catholic Church states that the conviction that one creates one's own reality is appealing but illusory. Our limitations are a fact of life and of being a creature.

The Law of Attraction is based on Christian teachings

There are conflicting views on whether the Law of Attraction is compatible with Catholic teachings. Some people believe that the Law of Attraction is not compatible with Catholicism. This is because the Law of Attraction is a New Age concept, which suggests that one creates one's own reality. This contradicts the Christian ethos, which states that God is in control.

However, some people argue that the Law of Attraction is based on Christian teachings. They claim that the Law of Attraction is simply another way of describing "prayers of petition", where one has faith that God is in control. In this interpretation, the Law of Attraction is not about using your thoughts to control the universe, but rather about starting with an optimistic mindset and believing that God will provide what is needed for a positive outcome.

The Bible encourages positive thinking and seeking guidance from God. For example, in Philippians 4, Paul advises avoiding anxious thoughts and provides eight principles for spiritually positive thinking. Additionally, the Bible does not advocate ignoring negative thoughts, but instead, preparing for potential negative outcomes, which is similar to the Law of Attraction's idea that positive thoughts can lead to positive outcomes.

Furthermore, some adherents of the Law of Attraction claim Bible verses to support their beliefs, such as "with God, all things are possible". They believe that the Law of Attraction is a way to get help from God and improve their relationship with Him.

While there are some similarities between the Law of Attraction and Christian teachings, it is important to note that the Law of Attraction is a metaphysical concept that attributes divine powers to the universe. It claims that thoughts and feelings, rather than righteousness, are responsible for the good or bad things that happen in our lives, which differs from the Bible's teachings.

The Law of Attraction is satanic

The "Law of Attraction" (LOA) is a New Age concept that proposes that by focusing on positive or negative thoughts, a person can bring about positive or negative experiences in their life. In other words, one's thoughts can control the universe.

While some people believe that the LOA is compatible with Catholicism, arguing that it is a form of prayer or petition, others strongly disagree, stating that the LOA is satanic and incompatible with Catholic thinking.

Pride and Temptation

The LOA is based on the idea that individuals can control their destiny and create their own reality, akin to being their own gods. This notion of self-deification directly contradicts the biblical teachings in Genesis, which warn against idolatry and making oneself a god. Pride is considered the biggest of the seven deadly sins in Catholicism, and the belief that one can control the universe through their thoughts is seen as the height of pride. Satan's temptation, both in the case of Adam and Eve and in his own fall from glory, has always been to obtain knowledge and become like God. By espousing the idea of self-deification, the LOA falls into the same trap of satanic temptation.

Superstition and Illusion

Catholic apologist Jimmy Akin acknowledges that while positive thoughts can lead to a positive outlook, which may increase the likelihood of positive events occurring, it is not due to any magical attraction. He characterizes the belief in the LOA as superstition, and the Vatican document "Jesus Christ, the Bearer of the Water of Life" supports this view, stating that the conviction of creating one's own reality is "appealing but illusory." The LOA lacks scientific evidence and reproducible results, further highlighting its illusory nature.

Misguided Focus

The LOA shifts the focus away from God and towards the individual and their thoughts. This shift contradicts the fundamental Christian and Catholic ethos of surrendering to God's will and recognizing His sovereignty. True contentment, according to Catholicism, comes from spiritual life and God, not from material possessions or personal gain, which the LOA often emphasizes.

In conclusion, while the LOA may appear harmless or even beneficial on the surface, some Catholics strongly believe that it is satanic in nature due to its encouragement of pride, its roots in superstition and illusion, and its diversion from the core principles of Catholicism.

Frequently asked questions