City Laws: Can They Override State Laws?

In the United States, cities are increasingly creating policies that differ from those of their states. This is known as 'home rule'. However, this has been criticised by some who argue that cities are overstepping their authority and that having a patchwork of regulations throughout a state makes it difficult for businesses to operate.

Preemption: when state law invalidates local law

In the United States, state law prevails over local law. This is called preemption – when state law invalidates local law. Just as federal law often supersedes state law, state law usually "preempts" cities from enacting ordinances that are in direct contradiction to the state law.

State statutes and state constitutions regulate the power of a city to enact ordinances. Usually, city ordinances that directly conflict with a state statute are not allowed. Counties often have a municipal charter, provide local ordinances, and dictate the powers of the government. The cities, towns, or villages within a county may have their own local laws and government.

However, the federal and state governments make laws that exist concurrently to create a balance of power. While the Supremacy Clause in the Constitution gives the federal government the power to override some state laws, this power has its limits.

For example, Judge Baxter of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania decided in favor of PGE and oil and gas development, striking down both the Bill of Rights Ordinance and the attempt of the watershed to intervene. This decision was based on preemption of state law over local law.

Federal law superseding state law

Federal law supersedes state law, and state law prevails over local law. This is called preemption – when a higher level of government uses its power to invalidate a lower level of government's law.

State statute usually "preempts" cities from enacting ordinances that are in direct contradiction to the state law. This means that cities are usually not allowed to enact ordinances that directly conflict with a state statute.

Counties often have a municipal charter, provide local ordinances, and dictate the powers of the government. The cities, towns, or villages within a county may have their own local laws and government. However, these local laws can be overridden by state law, and state law can be overridden by federal law.

The federal and state governments make laws that exist concurrently to create a balance of power. While the Supremacy Clause in the Constitution gives the federal government the power to override some state laws, this power has its limits.

State constitutions regulating the power of a city to enact ordinances

In the United States, the power to enact ordinances is typically granted to local governing bodies. These governing bodies may be known by various names, such as city councils, county commissions, or town boards. The authority to enact local ordinances is typically derived from state law. State constitutions and statutes grant local governments "home rule" authority, which enables them to create and enforce laws that reflect the unique needs and characteristics of their community. The scope of this authority can vary significantly from state to state. In some states, local governments have broad powers to enact ordinances on a wide range of issues, including zoning, land use, public health, and safety. In other states, local governments' authority may be more limited, with certain subjects reserved for state law or subject to state preemption.

State law prevails over local law. This is called preemption – when state law invalidates local law. Generally, state statutes and state constitutions regulate the power of a city to enact ordinances. Usually, city ordinances that directly conflict with a state statute are not allowed. In other words, state statute usually "preempts" cities from enacting ordinances that are in direct contradiction to the state law.

Counties often have a municipal charter, provide local ordinances, and dictate the powers of the government. The cities, towns, or villages within a county may have their own local laws and government. While the Supremacy Clause in the Constitution gives the federal government the power to override some state laws, this power has its limits.

The Supremacy Clause in the Constitution giving federal government power to override some state laws

While the Supremacy Clause in the Constitution gives the federal government the power to override some state laws, this power has its limits. The Supremacy Clause of the Constitution of the United States (Article VI, Clause 2) establishes that the Constitution, federal laws made pursuant to it, and treaties made under its authority, constitute the "supreme Law of the Land", and thus take priority over any conflicting state laws. It provides that state courts are bound by, and state constitutions subordinate to, the supreme law. However, federal statutes and treaties must be within the parameters of the Constitution; that is, they must be pursuant to the federal government's enumerated powers, and not violate other constitutional limits on federal power, such as the Bill of Rights.

The Supremacy Clause gives the federal government the power to override state laws in certain circumstances. For example, in Martin v. Hunter's Lessee, 14 U.S. 304 (1816), and Cohens v. Virginia, 19 U.S. 264 (1821), the Supreme Court held that the Supremacy Clause and the judicial power granted in Article III give the Supreme Court the ultimate power to review state court decisions involving issues arising under the Constitution and laws of the United States. Therefore, the Supreme Court has the final say in matters involving federal law, including constitutional interpretation, and can overrule decisions by state courts.

In general, state statutes and state constitutions regulate the power of a city to enact ordinances. Usually, city ordinances that directly conflict with a state statute are not allowed. In other words, state statute usually "preempts" cities from enacting ordinances that are in direct contradiction to the state law. This is called preemption – when state law invalidates local law. Counties often have a municipal charter, provide local ordinances, and dictate the powers of the government. The cities, towns, or villages within a county may have their own local laws and government.

Counties having their own local laws and government

In the US, the federal and state governments make laws that exist concurrently to create a balance of power. While the Supremacy Clause in the Constitution gives the federal government the power to override some state laws, this power has its limits. Similarly, just as federal law often supersedes state law, state law prevails over local law. This is called preemption – when state law invalidates local law.

Counties often have a municipal charter, provide local ordinances, and dictate the powers of the government. The cities, towns, or villages within a county may have their own local laws and government. However, state constitutions regulate the power of a city to enact ordinances. Usually, city ordinances that directly conflict with a state statute are not allowed. In other words, state statute usually “preempts” cities from enacting ordinances that are in direct contradiction to the state law.

Frequently asked questions