Citizens' Power: Can We Repeal A Law?

Citizens can play a role in repealing a law, although the process is complex and varies depending on the country and state. In the United States, the president can propose repealing legislation to Congress, and Congress can repeal laws by passing a bill that the president signs. Courts can also declare a law unconstitutional, which would make it null and void, but they cannot repeal it. In some states, such as Michigan, North Dakota, Washington, Nebraska, and Arkansas, there are specific requirements for repealing approved citizen initiatives, such as supermajority votes. Citizen's arrest laws are an example of statutes that some argue should be repealed to achieve equal justice under the law.

Citizen's arrest laws

Citizens can't directly repeal a law, but they can propose a repeal to Congress. In the United States, Congress is responsible for proposing and passing legislation. The president can propose repealing legislation to Congress, and can veto legislation. The president can sign the legislation into law or decline it by returning it with a veto message for reconsideration.

Courts can declare a law unconstitutional, which will normally make the law in question null and void, but they cannot repeal it. Repealing a law occurs when an old statute is no longer valid and has been replaced by a new law.

Some states require a supermajority vote to amend or repeal approved citizen initiatives. For example, Michigan requires a three-fourths supermajority vote, while North Dakota, Washington, Nebraska, and Arkansas require two-thirds supermajority votes.

The president's role in repealing legislation

Citizens can repeal a law, but the process varies depending on the state. For example, Michigan requires a three-fourths supermajority vote to amend or repeal approved citizen initiatives, while North Dakota, Washington, Nebraska, and Arkansas require two-thirds supermajority votes.

The president can propose to repeal legislation to Congress, and can veto legislation. The president can sign the legislation into law or decline it by returning it with a veto message for reconsideration. The president can also propose repealing legislation to Congress, which can then be passed as a bill that the president signs.

The process of repeal

At the state level, the process of repeal can vary. For example, Michigan requires a three-fourths supermajority vote to amend or repeal approved citizen initiatives, while North Dakota, Washington, Nebraska, and Arkansas require two-thirds supermajority votes. In North Dakota and Washington, the state legislature may amend or repeal an approved citizen initiative with a simple majority vote after a period of time has passed (two years in Washington and seven years in North Dakota). Other states, such as Alaska and Wyoming, have time requirements of two years before repeal, though the legislature can amend an initiative at any time.

Supermajority votes to repeal citizen initiatives

In the United States, the president can propose to repeal legislation to Congress, which can then be signed into law by the president. Courts can also declare a law unconstitutional, which would normally make the law null and void, but they cannot repeal it.

In some states, supermajority votes are required to repeal approved citizen initiatives. For example, Michigan requires a three-fourths supermajority vote, while North Dakota, Washington, Nebraska, and Arkansas require two-thirds supermajority votes. After a certain period of time, some states allow the state legislature to amend or repeal an approved citizen initiative with a simple majority vote. For example, in Washington, the state legislature can amend or repeal an initiative two years after it was approved, while in North Dakota, the time period is seven years.

'Stand your ground' laws

Citizens can repeal a law by proposing a bill to Congress, which the president must sign.

Stand Your Ground laws, sometimes called 'line in the sand' or 'no duty to retreat' laws, are based on the 'castle doctrine'. This doctrine removes the duty to retreat from an intruder when acting in self-defence in the home if the home-dweller reasonably believes they are in danger. The law provides that people may use deadly force when they reasonably believe it to be necessary to defend against certain violent crimes. Stand Your Ground laws exist within a broader context of systemic racism and racial injustice that has resulted in the death, injury, and dehumanisation of Black people. In many cases, Stand Your Ground laws even protect individuals who go after what they perceive as a 'threat'. At the crux of these 'shoot first' laws lies the belief that lethal force should be used on first instinct, instead of turning to it as a last resort.

Stand Your Ground laws are currently on the books in a majority of states. However, there are some states that require a supermajority vote to amend or repeal approved citizen initiatives. For example, Michigan requires a three-fourths supermajority vote, while North Dakota, Washington, Nebraska, and Arkansas require two-thirds supermajority votes.

Frequently asked questions