Employment Law: Can Employers Change Contract Terms Unilaterally?

Employers can change the terms of employment in certain circumstances, even without the employee's consent. However, this is a complex area of the law, and employers must carefully consider the potential legal and practical implications of their actions. Employees have certain protections, such as not being terminated due to their protected status or activities, and employers must also consider the individual needs of their employees when making changes. Employees have the right to refuse changes to their contracts in some cases and may have legal recourse if the changes result in a fundamental breach of contract or unfair dismissal.

Can employer change terms of employment law enforcement?

Employers can change job duties, pay rate, title, hours, benefits, etc

In general, employers can change the terms of employment for their at-will employees, including their job duties, pay rate, title, hours, benefits, and more. At-will employment means that an employee can be fired at any time, and it covers most employees in the United States, except in Montana, where employees who have completed a probationary period are protected from being fired without cause.

However, this can be a risky strategy, as it can cause discord among the workforce and may even result in legal disputes or claims for breach of contract or unfair dismissal. Employers should carefully consider the economic and operational needs of their business, as well as the individual needs of each employee affected by the change. It is also important to note that employers cannot terminate employees because of their protected status, such as age, race, gender, religion, or disability, or for engaging in protective activities, such as reporting discrimination or unsafe working conditions.

To change the terms of employment, employers can include a flexibility or variation clause in the contract, allowing for changes to be made. Alternatively, changes can be made by mutual or collective agreement, where the employee individually agrees or where an agreement is negotiated with a trade union or staff association. In the case of a proposed change, the employee has the opportunity to accept or decline the new terms. If the employee does not agree, this will lead to the termination of the contract, and the employer must provide the necessary notice period or pay in lieu of notice.

It is important to note that employment contracts are legally binding, and any changes made to them must comply with the applicable employment standards legislation and/or common law to avoid potential legal issues. Both parties must receive new consideration, meaning that the employer must provide an additional benefit beyond the value of employment itself. Additionally, some state and local predictive scheduling laws require businesses to provide workers with advance notice of their schedules or face penalties.

Employees can refuse changes, but there are exceptions

Employees can refuse changes to their employment terms, but there are exceptions. Employees are well within their rights to refuse changes to their employment terms, and employers cannot force them to accept the changes. However, if the employee's contract allows the employer to make the specific changes, and the changes are reasonable, the employee's refusal may not be valid.

In the case of an employee refusing to accept changes to their employment terms, the employer may terminate the contract by providing the necessary notice period or pay in lieu of notice. This will constitute a termination of employment. Employees can also request a trial period to work under the new terms before deciding whether to accept them. If the employee continues to work for the employer under the new terms without making it clear that they do not accept the changes, the employer may take this as their agreement to the changes.

If an employee's refusal to accept changes to their employment terms results in their termination, they may be able to bring a claim for unfair dismissal. This is a high-risk option, and employees should seek legal advice before taking this step. It is important to note that the employee will no longer be entitled to pay or benefits if they resign to claim unfair dismissal.

Additionally, if an employee is covered by a collective bargaining agreement or is a part of a union, they may be protected by "just cause" clauses that prevent the employer from making unilateral changes to their employment terms.

To avoid potential legal issues and maintain positive employee relations, employers should carefully consider the impact of any changes to employment terms and seek mutual agreement with employees. This includes providing a reasonable period for employees to decide whether to accept the changes and offering to discuss any concerns they may have.

Employers must provide written notice to employees within one month

In the context of changing terms of employment, employers must tread carefully to avoid legal issues and maintain positive employee relations. While an employer can change an at-will employee's job duties, pay rate, title, hours, benefits, and more, they must follow certain procedures.

When making changes to an employee's contract, employers must provide written notice to the affected employees within one month. This is a critical step to ensure the enforceability of the amendments. The notice period is important, as it gives employees the opportunity to accept or decline the new terms. If an employee does not agree to the changes, it may constitute a termination of employment, and the employer will need to provide the necessary notice period or pay in lieu of notice.

It is important to note that an employment contract cannot be changed solely because the employer revises it and the employee signs it. For the new contract to be enforceable, there must be mutual consideration. Both parties must receive something of value that they were not already entitled to. This means the employer must provide an additional benefit beyond the value of employment itself.

Furthermore, employers should be mindful of the individual needs of each employee affected by the changes. By handling the matter carefully and sensitively, employers are more likely to secure the necessary agreement to effect the changes lawfully. While an employer can impose changes, it can lead to a breach of contract or unfair dismissal claims. Therefore, it is essential to obtain the agreement of the employee or any relevant trade union or representative to vary the contract lawfully.

In summary, while employers have the right to make changes to employment contracts, they must follow the necessary procedures, including providing written notice within one month. This helps to ensure a smooth transition and maintain positive relationships with employees while also mitigating legal risks.

Employers can't terminate employees due to protected status or activities

While employers can change the terms of employment for at-will employees, they cannot terminate employees because of their protected status or activities. Protected characteristics include age, race, gender, religion, and disability, among others. Employees are also protected from termination for engaging in protective activities, such as reporting illegal or unsafe practices, or filing complaints about discrimination or harassment.

In the United States, federal and state laws prohibit employers from terminating employees based on their protected characteristics or activities. These laws include the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA), the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), the Family Medical Leave Act (FMLA), and various anti-discrimination laws enforced by the Department of Labor.

If an employer attempts to terminate an employee based on their protected status or activities, the employee may have legal recourse. This could include filing a wrongful termination claim or a discrimination lawsuit. Additionally, employees who are terminated may be eligible for unemployment benefits if they meet the eligibility requirements and are unemployed through no fault of their own.

To avoid legal issues, employers should ensure that any changes to employment contracts are made in accordance with applicable laws and regulations. This includes providing proper notice, obtaining employee consent or agreement from a trade union, and ensuring that any revisions provide mutual consideration and benefit to both parties.

Employees who believe they have been terminated illegally should seek legal advice and may be able to take action against their former employer. It is important to note that employment laws can vary by state and country, so understanding the specific laws and protections in your jurisdiction is crucial.

Employees can claim unfair dismissal or breach of contract

In the United States, wrongful dismissal refers to firings for illegal reasons, such as violating employment laws or the employee's contract. This is also known as wrongful termination. In contrast, the term "unfair dismissal" is less commonly used in the US and typically refers to firings that the employee deems unjust, even if they don't violate employment laws or contracts.

In the United Kingdom, unfair dismissal refers to any illegal termination. To bring an unfair dismissal claim in the UK, employees must generally have been employed for two years, with certain exceptions, such as in cases of discrimination or automatically unfair dismissal. Examples of automatically unfair dismissal include dismissal for health and safety reasons, whistleblowing, or on grounds of race, sex, disability, age, sexual orientation, or religion/belief.

If an employee feels they have been unfairly dismissed, they can make an unfair dismissal claim, which may result in the employer being ordered to reinstate the employee or pay compensation. Employees should carefully consider their options before resigning and claiming constructive dismissal, and it is recommended that they seek advice beforehand.

To avoid unfair dismissal claims, employers should ensure they have reasonable grounds for firing an employee and follow a fair dismissal process. This includes investigating the issue, informing the employee of the problem, holding a meeting to discuss it, providing an opportunity for appeal, and offering the right to be accompanied during these meetings. Employers should also stay up-to-date on relevant employment laws and ensure they are providing the necessary notice period to mitigate the risk of a constructive dismissal claim.

Additionally, when proposing changes to an employment contract, employers should be aware that both parties must receive new consideration to make the revised contract enforceable. This means that the employer must provide an additional benefit beyond the value of employment itself. If an employee does not agree to the changes, this can be treated as a breach of contract or lead to a claim of constructive dismissal.

Frequently asked questions