Mayoral Powers: Influence Beyond City Limits?

Mayors in the United States have varying levels of power depending on the state and city they govern. While they typically control local law enforcement, they do not have executive power over the town or city sheriff, who is an elected leader of the police. Mayors are also not responsible for levying taxes, as this is done by the legislative branch at the municipal level, usually the City Council. However, mayors decide how to spend the collected taxes. Governors, on the other hand, are responsible for implementing state laws and can even remove a mayor from office under certain conditions. This complex relationship between mayors and state laws raises questions about the influence mayors have on state-level decision-making and the potential consequences for their communities.

Explore related products

From Boss Crump to King Willie: How Race Changed Memphis Politics

$19.11 $24.95

Governors can remove mayors from office

While mayors can influence state laws to an extent, their powers are limited by the separation of powers, as well as what is imposed by state and federal levels. The mayor is responsible for spending the collected taxes, which are decided on by the City Council. The mayor also runs the police, but the City Council votes on the police budget and laws governing police conduct.

In the United States, governors have the power to impose their decisions on towns and restructure or take over municipal administrations. The scope of their power varies from state to state. Governors are responsible for implementing state laws and overseeing the operation of the state executive branch.

In the state of New York, the governor can remove the mayor from office. Governor Kathy Hochul considered removing Mayor Eric Adams from office following a five-count criminal indictment, including bribery and illegal campaign contributions. This power is derived from the broad powers granted to the governor in the state Constitution and the New York City Charter. According to the New York City Charter, the governor must first inform the mayor of the charges against them and provide an opportunity for the mayor to respond and defend themselves. This process includes a question-and-answer trial period. During this time, the governor can suspend the mayor temporarily, for up to thirty days.

The decision to remove a mayor is a serious matter and is often influenced by political considerations. It is worth noting that the removal of a mayor can be followed by a period of uncertainty and a potentially different administration from what the voters initially chose.

Mayors control local law enforcement

Mayors usually control local law enforcement, though the powers of a mayor may vary from state to state and city to city. As the chief executive of the city, the mayor has a strong influence over police departments, including setting the city's policy priorities and approaches. Mayors also hire and fire police chiefs, who run the departments. Mayors decide who is allowed to serve on public safety boards, which determine whether there is cause to fire an officer, and who is appointed to independent review boards that investigate and prosecute police misconduct.

Mayors are also typically charged with developing city-wide budgets, where additional funding can be allocated to services and infrastructure like mental health services, harm reduction programs, shelters, and traffic-calming measures, which could help address issues that would otherwise be dealt with by law enforcement. Mayors can also create or strengthen civilian review panels that provide oversight and generate new initiatives regarding police relations with local communities.

Mayors must do everything within their power to prevent officer misconduct and prepare to respond to incidents if police violence occurs under their leadership. They should know which powers are in their authority and what state-level laws may preempt their actions. Mayors should also be prepared for outspoken pushback, especially from police unions.

It is important to note that while mayors have control over local law enforcement, they do not have control over the Sheriff, who is an elected leader of the police. Typically, sheriffs are county-wide law enforcement, unless there is a major city making up the entirety of the county.

Mayors cannot levy taxes

In the United States, the political system is designed on a fractal level, with each level of government featuring a separation of powers. While mayors typically control local law enforcement, they do not have the power to levy taxes. The power to levy taxes lies with the legislative branch, usually the City Council, which decides how collected taxes are spent.

The majority of non-property taxation in the US is levied at the federal level, with some taxes levied at the state level, and a very small amount at the local level. Some larger cities, like New York City, may have a municipal income tax, but most smaller cities do not. While mayors can influence the collection and spending of taxes, they cannot change tax rates without permission from the state.

In some states, cities, counties, and municipalities are allowed to levy their own separate income taxes in addition to state income taxes. For example, in Alabama, Bessemer, Birmingham, and Macon County levy an income tax of 1%, while Gasden levies an income tax of 2%. In California, the city of San Francisco levies a 0.38% income tax.

While mayors can propose and advocate for changes to tax policies, the power to levy taxes ultimately rests with the legislative branch of the municipal government, typically the City Council. This separation of powers ensures that no single individual, including the mayor, has unchecked authority over taxation or any other aspect of governance.

State governors can impose decisions on towns

In the United States, state governors are responsible for implementing state laws and overseeing the operation of the state executive branch. They can use emergency powers to modify their state's statutory, regulatory, and legal framework. Governors have a lot of power, but the scope of their power varies from state to state. For example, the governor of New York can remove the mayor from office, as Governor Kathy Hochul considered doing with Mayor Eric Adams.

State governors usually have executive power to impose their decisions on towns and can restructure or take over municipal administration. However, it is not done arbitrarily, as it is bad politics for state legislators to appear to usurp local authority.

During the COVID-19 pandemic, several state governors imposed decisions on towns. For example, Texas Governor Greg Abbott's order ending the state's stay-at-home order "superseded all local orders." In Mississippi, Governor Tate Reeves's statewide mandatory stay-at-home order prevented localities from enforcing stricter restrictions, forcing the cities of Tupelo and Oxford to rescind local measures.

Mayors typically control local law enforcement and are responsible for spending collected taxes, but they do not levy taxes, which are usually state sales taxes. The only taxes that are mostly at the municipal level are property taxes.

Governors are responsible for implementing state laws

The executive branch executes laws passed by the state legislatures, with state agencies, departments, or boards instructed to implement those laws. Governors are charged by their state constitutions with ensuring that the laws are faithfully executed by the people and organizations that make up the executive branch. Day-to-day administrative responsibilities are delegated to state agencies supervised by the governor. State cabinets serve as advisory councils to governors, and they are generally made up of officials appointed by the governor to head state departments and agencies.

The role of the states has changed over time, and revitalized states now have greater responsibilities and require better governmental structures to carry out their duties. State bureaucracies have grown in size and scope, and they play a significant role in governing. Governors cannot implement state laws on their own but are assisted by thousands of public officials who comprise the executive branch.

While the governor's role in implementing state laws is crucial, the political system in the United States is designed with a separation of powers at the federal, state, and municipal levels. This separation of powers limits the governor's influence and ensures that law enforcement remains a function of the executive branch at all levels. Mayors, for example, typically control local law enforcement, and their powers may vary from state to state and city to city.

In summary, governors play a vital role in implementing state laws, but their power varies across states, and they must share authority with other branches of government to maintain a balanced and effective political system.

Frequently asked questions