Gavin Howe
While it is legally acceptable for someone to date their brother-in-law's niece, it is generally considered taboo. A 40-year-old man dating his 20-year-old brother-in-law's niece sparked intense debate on Reddit, with some users calling the situation messy and disgusting. The man, who is not blood-related to his girlfriend, expressed his desire to move in with her and stop keeping their relationship a secret. This scenario raises questions about the boundaries of acceptable dating within extended families and the potential consequences of crossing those boundaries.
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Relation | Not blood-related but part of the same extended family |
| Age Gap | 20 years |
| Public Opinion | Some believe it is messy and disgusting, while others find it amusing that people find it controversial |
| Term | Co-niece-in-law |
Explore related products
$9.99 $18.95
$19.89 $24.99
What You'll Learn
- The couple are not blood-related but are part of the same extended family
- The man is 40, his girlfriend is 20 -- she is 20 years his junior
- The couple want to move in together but are keeping their relationship a secret
- The man is concerned about how his family will react to the news
- Some people believe dating within the family is disgusting, even if not blood-related
The couple are not blood-related but are part of the same extended family
While it is not illegal to date your brother-in-law's niece, it is certainly a situation that can be considered controversial. The couple in this scenario are not blood-related but are part of the same extended family. In English law, your sister-in-law's nieces and nephews are not related to you, and the same would apply to the brother-in-law's nieces and nephews.
However, the relationship can be considered incestuous by some, as it involves individuals who are part of the same family, even if they are not blood-related. The term "co-niece-in-law" has been used to describe the relationship between the child of one's co-sibling-in-law, which is a term that has stemmed from South Indian languages.
The couple in this situation may face social stigma and judgment from others, as seen in the example of the 40-year-old man dating his 20-year-old brother-in-law's niece. They chose to keep their relationship a secret due to concerns about how their families would react, which indicates that they anticipate disapproval or negative consequences.
The man in the relationship justifies their decision by stating that they did not know each other previously and that their relationship is based on mutual attraction and consenting adults. While some may argue that dating within a family, even without blood relations, is unacceptable, others may not see it as an issue. Ultimately, the decision to pursue such a relationship depends on personal and familial values, cultural norms, and individual circumstances.
In conclusion, while dating your brother-in-law's niece is not illegal, it can be a complex and controversial situation due to the involvement of extended family members. The social implications and potential family dynamics should be carefully considered by the couple before deciding to disclose their relationship to their families.
Planned Communities: Enforcing Dumb Laws?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The man is 40, his girlfriend is 20 -- she is 20 years his junior
In a Mirror Online article, a 40-year-old man took to Reddit's Age Gap forum to explain that his 20-year-old girlfriend is his brother-in-law's niece. The couple is not blood-related but are part of the same extended family. They had not met until a year ago when they hit it off immediately. The man expressed his concerns about keeping the relationship a secret, especially from his brother-in-law, with whom he shares a good relationship. He also acknowledged the potential for controversy and messiness in the situation.
The man's story sparked intense debate in the comment section, with some users finding the situation "gross" or "disgusting," while others did not see it as controversial, given that the couple is not blood-related. One user pointed out that the man had chosen to date someone within his extended family when there were "millions of 20-year-olds" he could have dated instead.
While the term "brother-in-law's niece" may imply a family connection, it is important to note that, legally, your brother-in-law's niece is not a blood relative. In English law, your sister-in-law's nieces are not related to you, and the same would apply to your brother-in-law's nieces. However, the social perception of dating a "family member," even without a blood relation, can be complex and controversial, as evidenced by the mixed reactions in the Reddit forum.
The man in this situation is facing a dilemma between his desire to be open about his relationship and the potential fallout from his family, especially his brother-in-law. It is important for him to consider the potential consequences and dynamics within the family before deciding to disclose the relationship. While the couple may not see an issue with their age gap and familial connection, it is clear that others may have differing and strong opinions on the matter.
State Law Violation: Felony or Misdemeanor?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The couple want to move in together but are keeping their relationship a secret
While the couple is not blood-related, they are part of the same extended family. The man is the brother-in-law's wife's brother, and the woman is her niece. In English law, your sister-in-law's nieces are no relation to you. However, the couple's relationship is considered taboo by some, and they are keeping it a secret, especially from the man's brother-in-law, with whom he shares a good relationship.
The couple wants to move in together and feels that keeping their relationship a secret is no longer sustainable. They are facing a dilemma as they are unsure how their families will react to the news. The man refers to the situation as "cloak and dagger", indicating a need for secrecy and discretion. It is likely that they are concerned about potential judgment or disapproval from their families, given the taboo nature of their relationship.
The woman is 20 years old, and the man is 40 years old, which contributes to the controversy surrounding their relationship. The large age gap may be a source of concern for their families and society, as some may view it as inappropriate or exploitative. The man's decision to date a much younger woman, especially one within his extended family, may be frowned upon by others.
The couple's situation has sparked intense debates online, with some people expressing disgust and others finding it amusing that others find their relationship gross. The man defends their relationship by stating that they are not blood-related and that dating within a family is different from being related by blood. He also mentions that they were strangers until a year ago when they hit it off, implying that their connection and mutual attraction are more important than their family connection.
The couple's desire to move in together and the challenges of keeping their relationship a secret highlight the complexities of dating within an extended family. While they may not be blood-related, the social and familial dynamics add layers of difficulty to their situation. As they contemplate taking the next step in their relationship, they will need to navigate these complexities and potentially face the consequences of their families' reactions, whether positive or negative.
Criminal Record and a Law Career: Is It Possible?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The man is concerned about how his family will react to the news
Dating a relative, even if not a blood relation, can be a tricky situation. While the man in this scenario is not related by blood to his brother-in-law's niece, they are part of the same extended family. It is understandable that he is concerned about how his family will react to the news.
The man's family may have certain expectations or preconceived notions about the type of person he should be dating. They may not approve of someone who is already part of the family, especially given the age difference. It is also possible that they will not be concerned about the nature of the relationship as long as both parties are consenting adults.
The man and his partner have been keeping their relationship a secret, but they want to move in together and feel that they can no longer keep it under wraps. They will need to prepare for a range of reactions from their family members, from acceptance to disgust.
It is important to consider the family dynamic and the nature of the relationship before deciding how and when to share the news. If the man and his partner are certain that their relationship is serious, it may be a good time to tell the family. They should be prepared for multiple conversations and establish healthy boundaries, such as respectful language and avoiding character judgments.
The man and his partner may choose to have a face-to-face conversation with their family, as this can elicit more empathy and provide better results. They should also consider speaking to family members individually, especially if there are sensitive souls who may feel hurt if they don't hear the news directly from them first.
Undercover Cops: Breaking Laws, Crossing Lines?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Some people believe dating within the family is disgusting, even if not blood-related
While it is not illegal to date your brother-in-law's niece, it is generally frowned upon by society. This is because it is considered to be "dating within the family", even though the individuals are not blood-related. Some people find the idea of dating within the family, even if not blood-related, disgusting. They may view it as incestuous or believe that it disrupts the natural family dynamics and relationships.
There are several reasons why dating within the family, even if not blood-related, may be seen as problematic. Firstly, it can blur the boundaries between familial and romantic relationships, leading to confusion and conflict within the family. Secondly, it can create a sense of secrecy and dishonesty, as the individuals may feel the need to hide their relationship from their family members, as seen in the example of the couple who chose to keep their relationship a secret due to uncertainty about how their families would react.
Additionally, dating within the family can lead to complicated power dynamics and roles within the family. For example, if a couple were to break up, it could create tension and divide loyalties within the family, especially if children are involved. Furthermore, some people may believe that dating within the family reinforces unhealthy relationship patterns and dynamics. Individuals who come from close-knit families may have unrealistic expectations of relationships, believing that all relationships should be conflict-free, which is not always realistic or healthy.
However, it is important to note that not everyone shares the same level of discomfort with dating within the family. Some people may be more open-minded and accepting of such relationships, especially if the individuals involved are not blood-related. They may argue that as long as both parties are consenting adults and are aware of the potential consequences, they should be free to make their own choices. Additionally, they may point out that dating within one's extended family is not uncommon, especially in smaller or more isolated communities, and that it does not necessarily lead to genetic issues or unhealthy relationships.
Ultimately, the decision to date one's brother-in-law's niece depends on personal and familial values and beliefs. While some may find it disgusting, others may be more accepting as long as the individuals involved are not blood-related. It is essential to consider the potential consequences and impact on family dynamics and relationships before pursuing such a relationship.
Scientific Laws: Immutable or Evolving?
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
Yes, it is legal to date your brother-in-law's niece as you are not blood-related, but it is generally considered taboo.
The brother-in-law's niece is a co-niece-in-law, although this term is uncommon.
The appropriate term for a brother-in-law's niece is a niece, although some people may refer to her as a niece-in-law.
No, it is not common to date your brother-in-law's niece, and it may be considered taboo or "gross" by some people.
The potential consequences of dating your brother-in-law's niece include social stigma, family disapproval, and relationship challenges due to the age gap and the nature of the relationship.
