Ilhan Omar's Legal Troubles: Breaking The Law?

Ilhan Omar is a Somali-American politician and the first Somali-American in the US Congress. She is also one of the first two Muslim women to serve in Congress. Omar has been the subject of several controversies, including accusations of antisemitism, campaign finance violations, immigration fraud, and support for the anti-Semitic Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement.

In 2019, Omar and fellow Muslim Congresswoman Rashida Tlaib were barred from entering Israel due to their support for the BDS movement and for listing their destination as Palestine instead of Israel. This led to accusations that Omar had broken the law and calls for her expulsion from Congress, denaturalization, and deportation. However, there is no evidence that Omar has committed any crimes that would result in the loss of her citizenship or seat in Congress. While she has faced criticism and censure for some of her comments and actions, she remains a sitting member of Congress.

Ilhan Omar's swearing into Congress using the Quran

On January 3, 2019, Ilhan Omar, the first Somali-American Member of Congress, the first woman of color to represent Minnesota, and one of the first two Muslim-American women elected to Congress, was sworn in as the Representative from Minnesota's 5th Congressional District.

At her ceremonial swearing-in, Omar used a Quran that belonged to her grandfather. This was not the official swearing-in ceremony of the House, as no religious text is used during the official ceremony. The use of the Quran during the ceremonial swearing-in was not illegal. Article VI of the U.S. Constitution states that U.S. senators and representatives "shall be bound by Oath or Affirmation, to support this Constitution; but no religious Test shall ever be required as a Qualification to any Office or public Trust under the United States."

Omar's use of the Quran during her ceremonial swearing-in into Congress sparked controversy, with some people claiming that she had committed treason by taking the oath on a book recognizing Sharia Law, which they believed was in conflict with U.S. Constitutional Law. However, these claims were flagged as false by Facebook as part of their efforts to combat misinformation.

Omar's use of the Quran is not without precedent. In 2007, Representative-elect Keith Ellison, the first Muslim elected to the United States Congress, used former President Thomas Jefferson's copy of the Quran for his swearing-in ceremony. In 1825, former President John Quincy Adams swore his oath on a law book, and in 2013, Representative Tulsi Gabbard, a Hindu, swore on a copy of the Bhagavad Gita.

Accusations of Ilhan Omar committing immigration fraud

Ilhan Omar, the U.S. Representative for Minnesota's 5th congressional district, has been accused of committing immigration fraud. The accusations claim that Omar married her brother, Ahmed Nur Said Elmi, to help him gain American citizenship. Omar has publicly denied these claims, stating that Elmi is not her sibling. However, she has not provided any documentation to support her denial.

The accusations of immigration fraud against Omar are part of a larger set of allegations, including misuse of campaign funds and bigamy. In 2019, Minnesota's Campaign Finance Board found that Omar had filed tax returns stating she was married to one man when she was, in fact, married to another. As a result, she agreed to pay back thousands in fines and back taxes.

While there have been calls for Omar's expulsion from Congress and denaturalization, no legal proceedings or investigations are currently ongoing. Omar's team has confirmed that she is not under any formal investigation. The FBI has reportedly looked into the issues but has not revealed any findings.

Ilhan Omar's alleged allegiance to Somalia over the US

Ilhan Omar, the first Somali-American in the US Congress, has been accused of having an allegiance to Somalia over the US. In 2024, Omar gave a speech at a celebration of the recent election in Puntland, a region of Somalia. In the speech, Omar addressed the dispute between Somalia and the breakaway republic of Somaliland, which had recently made a sea access deal with landlocked Ethiopia. Omar told the audience that Somalia would remain united, and that she would use her influence to keep it that way.

Following the speech, Omar faced a wave of criticism and accusations of failing to state her allegiance to the US. Republican lawmakers and commentators, including Minnesota colleague US Rep. Tom Emmer, called for her to "resign in disgrace". Social media posts asserted that Omar had said that she was "Somalian first, Muslim second". However, independent translations of Omar's speech, including one by a certified court interpreter, show that she did not say "Somalian first, Muslim second". Indeed, the term "Somalian" is not used by Somalis, who prefer the term "Somali".

Omar responded to the criticism, calling the attacks "disingenuous attempts to malign my character and question my loyalty to my home, America". She also said that the outrage was a "desperate attempt to garner attention".

Despite lacking any formal role in foreign policy, Omar has been vocal about her views on American foreign affairs. She has weighed in on the conflict between Somalia and Somaliland, stating that she supports longstanding US and Biden administration policy of a unified Somalia. Omar's comments about the relationship between Somaliland and Ethiopia are not inconsistent with American policy.

While calls have been made for Omar's deportation, these have no legal merit, according to experts. Immigration lawyer Rosanna Berardi stated that as Omar is a naturalized US citizen, calls for deportation lack legal ground unless citizenship was gained through nefarious means. Additionally, Omar's statements, whether accurate or taken out of context, are protected under the First Amendment.

Ilhan Omar's support for the BDS movement

Ilhan Omar, the US representative for Minnesota's 5th congressional district since 2019, is a supporter of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement. The BDS movement is a Palestinian-led movement that promotes boycotts, divestments, and economic sanctions against Israel. Its objective is to pressure Israel to meet its obligations under international law, including the withdrawal from occupied territories, the removal of the separation barrier in the West Bank, full equality for Arab-Palestinian citizens of Israel, and the protection of Palestinian refugees' rights.

Omar, who is one of the first Muslim women to be elected to Congress, has faced criticism and accusations of antisemitism for her support of the BDS movement. During her 2018 campaign, she stated that she did not support the BDS movement, describing it as counterproductive to peace. However, after her election, she affirmed her position as a supporter of the movement. Omar clarified that while she supports the BDS movement, she has reservations on the effectiveness of the movement in accomplishing a lasting solution.

In February 2019, Omar and Rashida Tlaib, another supporter of the BDS movement and one of the first Muslim women elected to Congress, were threatened with action by Republican House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy for their support of BDS. Omar has also faced criticism from Democratic leaders, including House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, for her comments alluding to the influence of pro-Israel lobbyists in the United States.

In July 2019, Omar introduced a resolution co-sponsored by Tlaib and Georgia Representative John Lewis, stating that Americans have the right to participate in boycotts in pursuit of civil and human rights. The resolution also opposed legislative efforts to limit the use of boycotts and urged Congress and civil rights leaders to preserve the freedom of advocacy. In the same month, Omar was one of 17 Congress members to vote against a House resolution condemning the BDS movement.

In August 2019, Omar and Tlaib were banned from entering Israel due to their support for BDS. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu attributed the ban to Israeli law, which prohibits the entry of people who call for a boycott of Israel. This decision was criticized by both Democratic and Republican legislators, who requested that Israel rescind the ban.

Ilhan Omar's criticism of Israel

Ilhan Omar, a frequent critic of Israel, has advocated for a two-state solution to resolve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. She has denounced Israel's settlement policies and military campaigns in the occupied Palestinian territories, as well as the influence of pro-Israel lobbies in American politics.

Omar has faced accusations of antisemitism for her remarks regarding Israel and the influence of pro-Israel lobbies. In 2019, she apologised for implying that money was behind support for Israel. She has also been accused of employing anti-Semitic tropes, such as conspiracy theories about Jewish control over the media and politics, as well as dual loyalty accusations. Omar has claimed to have been unaware of these tropes and has apologised for or walked back many of her comments.

In 2023, Omar was removed from her seat on the Foreign Affairs Committee by a Republican-controlled House vote, citing her past comments about Israel and concerns over her objectivity. However, she continues to criticise Israel's policies towards Palestinians and has signed onto resolutions acknowledging the importance of the US-Israel alliance while condemning antisemitism.

Omar's criticism of Israel has put her at odds with members of her own party, with some accusing her of crossing a line that cannot be crossed. Her bluntness in condemning Israel is largely unwelcome within the Democratic Party, despite a shift in Democratic views on Israel and the Palestinians.

Frequently asked questions