Truman's War: Legal Or Not?

Harry S. Truman was the 33rd president of the United States, serving from 1945 to 1953. Truman's presidency was marked by significant foreign policy decisions, including the use of atomic bombs against Japan, the establishment of the Truman Doctrine, and the US entry into the Korean War.

Truman's decision to use atomic bombs against Hiroshima and Nagasaki in 1945 remains one of the most controversial aspects of his presidency. Truman argued that the bombings saved lives by avoiding a prolonged invasion of Japan, but critics argue that the use of nuclear weapons was unnecessary and constituted a war crime.

Truman also played a key role in the onset of the Cold War. The Truman Doctrine, announced in 1947, pledged American support for democracies against authoritarian threats, particularly in countering the growth of the Soviet bloc. This shift in US foreign policy led to the formation of NATO in 1949.

In 1950, Truman sent US troops to aid South Korea against communist forces from North Korea, marking the US entry into the Korean War. This decision was controversial and led to a lengthy stalemate, damaging Truman's popularity.

While Truman's foreign policy decisions are a significant part of his legacy, his administration also faced challenges on the domestic front, including labor disputes, economic issues, and civil rights. Truman proposed liberal domestic reforms but was often blocked by the conservative coalition in Congress.

Truman's use of the atomic bomb

The Decision

Harry S. Truman, the 33rd president of the United States, assumed office in April 1945, following the death of Franklin D. Roosevelt. At the time, World War II was raging, and Truman was faced with the daunting task of ending the war with Japan. Within weeks of taking office, Truman learned about the Manhattan Project—a secret initiative to develop an atomic bomb.

Truman had four options: continue conventional bombing of Japanese cities, invade Japan, demonstrate the bomb on an unpopulated island, or drop it on an inhabited city. Conventional bombing campaigns had already resulted in hundreds of thousands of Japanese casualties, but Japan remained steadfast in its refusal to surrender. An invasion of Japan, as demonstrated by the battles of Iwo Jima and Okinawa, would likely result in massive casualties on both sides.

Truman formed the Interim Committee to advise him on the use of the atomic bomb. The committee recommended the direct military use of the bomb, concluding that a demonstration might not be effective and could embolden Japan if the weapon malfunctioned.

The Bombing

On August 6, 1945, an American B-29 bomber, the Enola Gay, dropped the atomic bomb "Little Boy" on Hiroshima, Japan. The blast and its after-effects killed approximately 80,000 people instantly and injured 35,000 more. Truman released a statement, warning Japan to surrender or face "a rain of ruin from the air, the like of which has never been seen on this earth."

On August 9, another atomic bomb, "Fat Man," was dropped on Nagasaki, killing 39,000 and injuring 25,000. The death toll from the two bombings eventually climbed to over 200,000. On August 14, 1945, Japan surrendered, bringing an end to World War II.

Truman's Justification

Truman defended his decision, arguing that it saved countless lives on both sides. He believed that a ground invasion of Japan would have resulted in far more casualties, with some estimates projecting over a million American deaths and millions of Japanese casualties.

Truman also asserted that his primary goal was to destroy Japan's ability to wage war without destroying its culture or people. He specifically avoided targeting cities of traditional cultural significance, such as Kyoto.

Ethical Debate

The use of atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki sparked intense ethical debates that continue to this day. Critics argue that the use of nuclear weapons was unnecessary and that a demonstrative bombing of an uninhabited area might have forced Japan's surrender. Some assert that the attacks constituted a war crime.

However, supporters of Truman's decision maintain that the bombings saved hundreds of thousands of lives and that the alternative options were far worse. They point to the tenacity of Japanese defense and the strong resistance from civilians, including women and children, who had been trained to fight.

Legacy

Truman's decision to use the atomic bomb had far-reaching consequences. It marked the first and only use of nuclear weapons in warfare, demonstrating their destructive power and changing the nature of global conflicts. The bombings also accelerated the end of World War II, saving countless lives that would have been lost in prolonged fighting.

The emergence of nuclear weapons as a viable military option also shaped the Cold War dynamics between the United States and the Soviet Union, with both countries engaging in an arms race to develop more powerful weapons. Truman's decision set a precedent for the potential use of nuclear force as a deterrent or a tool to compel surrender.

Truman himself grappled with the weight of his decision, acknowledging that it was the hardest choice he ever had to make. While he never apologized for it, he refused to use nuclear weapons in subsequent conflicts, such as the Korean War.

Truman's role in rebuilding postwar Europe

Harry S. Truman was the 33rd president of the United States, serving from 1945 to 1953. Truman played a key role in rebuilding postwar Europe. Here is a detailed overview of his contributions:

• The Marshall Plan: Truman implemented the Marshall Plan, a massive economic recovery program for postwar Europe. The plan provided $13 billion in aid over four years (1948-1951) to 17 nations in western and southern Europe. It aimed to stabilize Europe economically and politically, prevent the spread of communism, and rebuild agricultural and industrial productivity.
• The Truman Doctrine: Truman announced the Truman Doctrine in 1947, pledging American support for democracies against authoritarian threats. This doctrine committed the US to aid Greece and Turkey, which were under pressure from the Soviet Union and communist forces. Truman requested and received $400 million in aid for these countries, marking a shift in US foreign policy towards possible intervention in far-away conflicts.
• NATO: Truman played a crucial role in the formation of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), a military alliance established in 1949. NATO aimed to contain Soviet expansion in Europe and assure France and other allies of US support. Truman also negotiated the creation of other international organizations, such as the United Nations, to promote international cooperation and prevent another world war.
• Berlin Airlift: In 1948, Truman oversaw the Berlin Airlift, which supplied West Berlin with food and other essential supplies during a Soviet blockade. This successful operation demonstrated American commitment to Europe's security and was a significant foreign policy achievement for Truman.
• Point Four Program: Truman initiated the Point Four Program in 1949 to provide technological aid to poor developing countries. This program, later known as the International Cooperation Administration, promoted private investment and technical development in countries like Nepal, Iran, and others.
• European Recovery: Truman's administration also contributed to the recovery of specific European countries, such as West Germany and Japan. The US supervised the reconstruction of Japan, and Truman made the key decision to rebuild West Germany as an economic power.

Truman's containment of communism

Harry S. Truman's containment of communism was largely focused on countering the growth of the Soviet bloc during the Cold War. This was known as the Truman Doctrine.

The Truman Doctrine was announced to Congress by Truman on March 12, 1947, and further developed on July 4, 1948. It pledged American "support for democracies against authoritarian threats". Truman told Congress:

> I believe it must be the policy of the United States to support free peoples who are resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or by outside pressures.

Truman argued that if Greece and Turkey did not receive aid, they would fall out of the United States' sphere of influence and into the communist bloc, which would have grave consequences throughout the region. Truman also contended that because totalitarian regimes coerced free peoples, they automatically represented a threat to international peace and the national security of the United States.

The Truman Doctrine was the first in a series of containment moves by the United States, followed by the Marshall Plan and the formation of NATO in 1949. The doctrine was a highly publicised commitment that set a precedent for American assistance to anti-communist regimes throughout the world. It shifted US policy toward the Soviet Union from a wartime alliance to containment of Soviet expansion.

Truman's involvement in the Korean War

On June 25, 1950, communist North Korea, backed by the Soviet Union, invaded South Korea. The invasion was a coordinated attack at several strategic points along the 38th parallel, the line dividing communist North Korea from the non-communist Republic of Korea in the south.

Fearing that the Soviet Union and Communist China might have encouraged the invasion, President Harry S. Truman committed US air, ground, and naval forces to aid South Korea. Truman also designated General Douglas MacArthur as Commanding General of the United Nations Command (UNC). Truman's decision to intervene in the Korean War was guided by the principles of containment policy, which aimed to contain Soviet expansion and "support free peoples who are resisting attempted subjugation."

Truman did not ask for a declaration of war from Congress, instead classifying the conflict as a UN-led "police action." This decision was later criticised, and some questioned whether Truman had the constitutional authority to commit American soldiers to war without a declaration of war. However, Republicans in Congress did not seriously challenge Truman's authority, and the intervention was met with overwhelming approval from Congress and the US public.

In the initial months of the war, UN forces, led by the US, pushed the North Korean army back across the 38th parallel. In October 1950, UN forces, urged by the US, moved into North Korea, aiming to unify the country under a non-communist government. This led to a full-scale attack from Chinese communist forces, pushing UNC forces back below the 38th parallel.

In April 1951, Truman relieved MacArthur of his command after the latter publicly challenged the Truman administration's conduct of the war and threatened to extend the war to China, going against Truman's war policy. By May 1951, the communists had been pushed back to the 38th parallel, where the battle lines remained until the end of hostilities. An armistice was signed on July 27, 1953, ending the war and re-establishing the division of Korea at the 38th parallel.

Truman's use of executive orders

Harry S. Truman, the 33rd president of the United States, issued 896 executive orders during his presidency. Here is an overview of Truman's use of executive orders:

Executive Orders 9980 and 9981

On June 26, 1948, Truman issued Executive Orders 9980 and 9981, which were crucial in the post-World War II civil rights movement. These orders prohibited discrimination in federal agencies and desegregated the U.S. Armed Forces. Executive Order 9981 abolished discrimination "on the basis of race, color, religion, or national origin" in the Armed Forces. This order was inspired by an attack on Isaac Woodard, an African American World War II veteran, by South Carolina police. Truman's order expanded on Executive Order 8802, establishing equality of treatment and opportunity in the military regardless of race, religion, or national origin.

Executive Order 9981 and the Korean War

Executive Order 9981 led to the re-integration of the Armed Forces during the Korean War (1950-1953). Truman's administration engaged in an internationalist foreign policy, working closely with Britain and denouncing isolationism. The U.S. involvement in the Korean War began in 1950 when North Korea invaded South Korea.

Executive Orders and the Cold War

Truman's presidency was marked by the onset of the Cold War in 1947, and his administration's foreign policy was focused on containing the expansion of Soviet communism. This policy was formalized in the Truman Doctrine, announced to Congress on March 12, 1947, and further developed on July 4, 1948. The Truman Doctrine pledged American "support for democracies against authoritarian threats," shifting U.S. policy toward the Soviet Union from an alliance to containment.

Executive Orders and Civil Rights

Truman's executive orders on civil rights extended beyond the Armed Forces. In 1946, he created the President's Committee on Civil Rights, which condemned the state of civil rights in the nation. In 1947, he gave a historic speech to the NAACP, describing civil rights as a moral imperative. Truman proposed comprehensive civil rights legislation to Congress, which was refused. In response, he issued Executive Orders 9980 and 9981 to promote anti-discrimination in the federal government.

Executive Orders and the Use of Nuclear Weapons

Truman's administration was also marked by his decision to authorize the first and only use of nuclear weapons in war against the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. This decision has been a subject of debate, with some arguing that it saved lives on both sides by ending the war and others criticizing it as unnecessary and a crime of war.

In summary, Truman's use of executive orders was a significant aspect of his presidency, particularly in the areas of civil rights, foreign policy, and military affairs. These orders had a lasting impact on U.S. society and shaped the course of history during the Cold War era.

Frequently asked questions