Black Holes: Do They Break Conservation Laws?

Black holes are regions of spacetime where the gravitational force is so strong that nothing, not even light, can escape. A common question that arises is whether black holes violate the law of conservation of mass. The law of conservation of mass states that mass cannot be created or destroyed, only transformed from one form to another. So, does a black hole's ability to eat matter and its powerful gravitational force break this law?

Mass is converted to energy

Mass is a form of energy. According to Einstein's theory of relativity, mass and energy are related, and the equation E=mc^2 describes the amount of energy that mass has. This means that mass can be converted into energy and vice versa.

As mass falls into a black hole, it increases the mass of the black hole, and the energy is converted into mass. This process is described by Einstein's equation E=mc^2. However, when a black hole emits Hawking radiation, the process is reversed, and mass is converted back into energy. Despite these transformations, the total mass and energy of the system remain conserved.

The conversion of mass into energy within a black hole can be understood through the concept of an accretion disk. As mass falls towards a black hole, it forms a whirlpool-like structure around it. Friction within this disk generates heat, causing the matter to radiate. As the matter moves closer to the black hole, it loses potential energy, which further contributes to the overall heat and radiation. This process can be summarised as "black hole + matter -> more massive black hole + radiation".

It is important to note that mass is not "converted" but rather possesses energy that, under certain conditions, can be transformed into different types of energy, such as radiation. This distinction is crucial because it highlights that mass itself is a form of energy, and the conversion process involves a transfer or transformation between different energy states.

In summary, the mass-energy equivalence principle, exemplified by E=mc^2, demonstrates that mass can be converted into energy and vice versa. Black holes serve as a fascinating example of this principle in action, showcasing the dynamic interplay between mass and energy in the universe.

Mass is conserved when black holes die

The concept of black holes has long been a subject of fascination and intrigue, with many questions surrounding their nature and impact on the universe. One such question is whether black holes break the law of conservation of mass. The law of conservation of mass states that the total amount of mass in a closed system remains constant over time, meaning that mass cannot be created or destroyed, only transformed. This principle is a fundamental aspect of physics and has far-reaching implications for our understanding of the universe.

So, do black holes, with their immense gravitational pull and ability to consume matter, violate this law? The answer is no. Mass is indeed conserved when black holes die. When a black hole consumes matter, such as a star, the mass of that matter is not lost. Instead, it is converted into energy, specifically the energy of the black hole's gravity. This process, known as accretion, is a crucial mechanism for black holes to increase their mass. The energy and mass of the consumed matter are added to the black hole, preserving the total energy and mass of the system.

This conservation of mass and energy can be understood through Einstein's famous equation, E=mc^2, which demonstrates the interchangeable nature of mass and energy. As matter falls past the event horizon of a black hole, its energy, including mass, is incorporated into the black hole's energy-mass. This transfer of energy and mass ensures that the overall mass and energy of the system, including the black hole and its surroundings, remain unchanged.

It is important to note that while mass is conserved during the formation and growth of black holes, there is a separate concept known as the "information loss paradox" that presents a unique challenge. This paradox suggests that as a black hole evaporates, most of the information within it is lost. However, recent studies by Hawking and other researchers have indicated that this information may be stored within the black hole itself, providing intriguing insights into the complex nature of these cosmic phenomena.

In conclusion, the law of conservation of mass remains intact even as black holes consume and eventually release matter. The mass-energy equivalence principle ensures that mass is conserved, and the total energy of the system is maintained. This understanding of mass conservation in the context of black holes contributes to our broader comprehension of the fundamental laws governing the universe.

Mass is a form of energy

In a reference frame where the system is moving, its relativistic energy and relativistic mass (instead of rest mass) obey the same formula. The mass of a system of particles is not equal to the sum of the masses of the system. This is because mass is the energy of a system in its rest frame, i.e., when the momentum of the system is zero.

In older physics terminology, relativistic energy is used in place of relativistic mass, and the term "mass" is reserved for rest mass or invariant mass. Rest mass, also called invariant mass, is a fundamental physical property of matter, independent of velocity. Massless particles such as photons have zero invariant mass but have both momentum and energy.

The mass–energy equivalence implies that when mass is lost in chemical or nuclear reactions, a corresponding amount of energy will be released. This principle is fundamental to many fields of physics, including nuclear and particle physics. It is also one of the pillars of the general theory of relativity, as it predicts that all forms of energy interact gravitationally.

The conservation of energy is a universal principle in physics and holds for any interaction, along with the conservation of momentum. The classical conservation of mass, in contrast, is violated in certain relativistic settings. While modern physics has discarded the expression 'conservation of mass', mass can be defined as equivalent to the energy of a moving system, allowing for a conservation of relativistic mass.

The mass of an object is not the sum of the masses of its parts. This is because the mass of an object is the total energy of all its parts, including kinetic and potential energy, as observed from the centre of the momentum frame.

Whenever energy is added to a system, the system gains mass. For example, a spinning ball has greater mass than when it is stationary. Its increase in mass is the sum of the kinetic energies of all its moving parts. Similarly, raising the temperature of an object increases its mass.

In summary, mass is a form of energy, and this relationship has been experimentally proven in various ways, including the conversion of mass into kinetic energy in nuclear reactions and other interactions between elementary particles.

Total mass and energy conserved in black hole evaporation

The concept of black holes and their relation to the law of conservation of mass has been a topic of debate and discussion for physicists. The law of conservation of mass states that the total mass in a system remains constant, neither being created nor destroyed but simply transformed from one form to another.

Black holes, as the name suggests, are regions in space where the gravitational force is so strong that nothing, not even light, can escape. This led to the question of whether black holes violate the law of conservation of mass.

The answer to this question lies in the understanding that mass is a form of energy, and energy is conserved. When matter falls into a black hole, it adds to the mass of the black hole, as mass and energy are interchangeable as per Einstein's famous equation, E=mc^2.

Black holes can also lose mass through a process called Hawking radiation, named after physicist Stephen Hawking, who first described this phenomenon in 1974. Hawking radiation is the emission of energy from outside a black hole's event horizon, causing a slow reduction in the black hole's mass and, consequently, its eventual evaporation.

Despite the mass loss through Hawking radiation, the total mass and energy of the system, including the black hole and its surrounding universe, remain conserved. This is because the energy emitted as Hawking radiation comes from outside the event horizon, effectively acting as if the black hole itself is slowly evaporating.

Therefore, it can be concluded that black holes do not break the law of conservation of mass. While the mass of a black hole may decrease over time due to Hawking radiation, the total mass and energy in the system are still conserved, thus upholding the fundamental principle of the conservation of energy.

Mass is locally conserved

The confusion around the conservation of mass arises from the fact that mass is not additive. In other words, the mass of a system of particles is not equal to the sum of the masses of its individual constituents. This is because mass is the norm of the four-momentum, which includes both energy and momentum. So, while the total mass of a system is conserved, the mass of its individual components may be converted into other forms of energy or momentum.

For example, when a black hole ""eats" a star, the star's mass is not lost but is converted into energy. The total energy of the system (the black hole and the star) remains unchanged. This is because, according to Einstein's equation E=mc^2, energy and mass are interchangeable. So, while the mass of the star may be destroyed, its energy is conserved and added to the black hole's energy.

When a black hole eventually ""evaporates" through the emission of Hawking radiation, the process is reversed, and the black hole's mass is converted back into energy. However, the total mass and energy of the system remain conserved.

Frequently asked questions