Florida's Stand Your Ground Law: Renters' Rights And Protections?

Florida's stand your ground law is a controversial self-defence statute that permits citizens to use deadly force and receive immunity from prosecution. The law, codified at Chapter 776 of the Florida Statutes, allows a homeowner or tenant to use deadly force if they reasonably believe that they or members of their household are in danger of imminent death or bodily harm. This law expands the castle doctrine, which refers to a person's right to defend themselves and their property in their home, to include other premises besides an individual's home. However, it is important to note that stand your ground only applies when the person using deadly force is legally allowed to be in that place and is not committing a crime.

Florida's stand your ground law and renters

Florida's "Stand Your Ground" law, enacted in 2005, is a self-defence statute that permits citizens to use deadly force and receive immunity from prosecution. The law states that a person in their dwelling, residence, or occupied vehicle has the right to stand their ground and use or threaten to use deadly force if they reasonably believe such force is necessary to prevent imminent death, great bodily harm, or the commission of a forcible felony. This law expands the "castle doctrine", which refers to a person's right to defend themselves in their home, to include other premises besides their home.

The "Stand Your Ground" law applies to renters in that it allows them to use deadly force in self-defence when threatened outside their home. However, it is important to note that this law only applies when the person using deadly force is in a place they are legally allowed to be and is not committing a crime. Additionally, stand your ground does not apply if the person using deadly force provoked the other person or if the other person was attempting to leave the premises. It also does not apply if force is used against a law enforcement officer performing their official duties.

To claim the "Stand Your Ground" defence, a person must have a reasonable belief of impending death or great bodily harm. There is a presumption of intent for death or great bodily harm when the person harmed by deadly force was attempting to unlawfully or forcibly enter a dwelling, residence, or occupied vehicle. For example, this could include a burglar breaking into a home or a kidnapper attempting to kidnap someone in a home or car.

In terms of prosecution, under the Florida statute, prosecutors may determine that a person standing their ground is immune from criminal and civil liability. If the prosecutor determines that the stand your ground defence does not apply, the defendant must raise the defence themselves. Once the defendant establishes all the elements of the defence, the prosecution must prove by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant was not standing their ground.

Stand your ground law and the castle doctrine

The "castle doctrine" refers to a person's right to defend themselves against a threat to themselves or their family in their home. In many states, this is expanded to include other premises besides their home. Under the castle doctrine, a person has the right to use deadly force to protect themselves and their property, without the obligation to retreat.

The "stand your ground" law is similar to the castle doctrine in that it provides people with the right to use deadly force when they reasonably believe it is necessary for self-defence. However, stand-your-ground laws apply to people in places outside their homes where they are lawfully present.

Florida's stand-your-ground law goes further than the statutes in other states, as it permits individuals to use force in self-defence when threatened outside the home. Florida citizens are also permitted to use deadly force to prevent the commission of a felony.

In 2017, Florida amended its stand-your-ground law to place the burden of proof on the prosecution, requiring them to present clear and compelling evidence that the act was not justified under the state's stand-your-ground criteria.

The right to stand your ground and the duty to retreat

The "duty to retreat" is a provision that, under certain circumstances, strips one of their right to use deadly force for self-defence if they fail to retreat from a confrontation. In other words, in jurisdictions that implement a duty to retreat, even a person who is unlawfully attacked may not use deadly force if it is possible to instead avoid the danger with complete safety by retreating.

The alternative to the duty to retreat is the "stand your ground" law, which provides that people may use deadly force when they reasonably believe it to be necessary to defend against certain violent crimes, without any duty to retreat, so long as they are in a place where they are lawfully present. Florida is one of the 35 states that have stand-your-ground laws.

In 2005, Florida revised its stand-your-ground law, a controversial self-defence statute permitting citizens to use deadly force and receive immunity from prosecution. The key change in the 2005 stand-your-ground law is protection from prosecution if one is found to be within their rights to protect themselves. If charged with a crime, one's charges would be dropped if their attorney proves that they were lawfully permitted to be where the event occurred, that they reasonably believed they were in danger, and that the other party did not try to de-escalate or retreat from the situation.

Immunity from prosecution under stand your ground law

Florida's Stand Your Ground Law provides immunity from prosecution for citizens who use deadly force in self-defence. This law was revised in 2005, removing the obligation for someone to retreat before using deadly force in self-defence.

The Stand Your Ground Law in Florida permits citizens to use deadly force and receive immunity from prosecution if they can prove they believed they or another person was in imminent danger of bodily harm or death, or if they used deadly force to prevent the commission of a felony.

To be granted immunity from prosecution, an individual's lawyer must prove that their client was lawfully permitted to be where the event occurred, that they reasonably believed they were in danger, and that the other party did not try to de-escalate or retreat from the situation.

If a defendant can demonstrate by a preponderance of the evidence that they used deadly force in a manner authorised by Florida's Stand Your Ground Law, they should be declared immune from prosecution.

Immunity from prosecution can be granted in two forms: use and derivative use immunity. Use immunity protects a witness from having their own testimony used against them, but it does not prevent other evidence obtained from independent sources from being used. Derivative use immunity, on the other hand, provides broader protection by preventing any evidence or information derived from the witness's testimony from being used against them.

Limitations of stand your ground law

Florida's stand-your-ground law, which came into effect on October 1, 2005, has been criticised for its lack of clarity and its potential to be abused by violent individuals. Here are some of the limitations of the law:

No Duty to Retreat

The stand-your-ground law removes the duty to retreat, meaning that individuals are not required to try to retreat before using deadly force in self-defence. This is a broader level of permission for justifiable force than other states, and it has been argued that this could lead to a “shoot first” mentality and an increase in homicides. The subjective nature of "reasonable belief" has also been criticised, as it may be harder to justify the use of force if retreating would have been a safe and easy option.

Increased Risk for Minorities

There is a concern that stand-your-ground laws could disproportionately affect racial and ethnic minorities due to negative stereotypes. This could result in minorities being at greater risk of experiencing or perpetrating violence under the law.

Potential for Abuse

Critics argue that stand-your-ground laws can be abused by violent individuals who may take the opportunity to kill even when they could have safely walked away. There is also a risk that criminals could use the law as a defence for their crimes, and that it could encourage people to use deadly force when it is not necessary.

Difficulty in Investigation and Prosecution

Florida's stand-your-ground law makes it harder for law enforcement to properly investigate cases where the defence is being used. It limits their ability to arrest someone who claims to have acted in self-defence, and it can be challenging to prove that the individual did not reasonably believe they were in danger.

Limited Effectiveness

There is mixed evidence on the effectiveness of stand-your-ground laws in reducing crime. While some argue that it can increase safety for victims and potentially lead to a drop in violent crime, others claim that it may lead to an increase in crime, particularly homicide. Some studies have found that stand-your-ground laws are associated with an increase in firearm homicides and the total number of homicides.

Frequently asked questions