Exploring Space Law: Do Constitutions Apply In Orbit?

The exploration of space has long been a topic of fascination for humanity, and with recent advancements in technology, it is now more accessible than ever. As our reach extends beyond the Earth's atmosphere, questions arise about the applicability of constitutional laws in this new frontier. This discussion is particularly pertinent given the increasing diversity of actors involved in space exploration, including private entities and non-traditional players. The governance of space is a complex issue that involves international, regional, and national laws, as well as regulatory institutions and agreements. The foundation of space law lies in the five international treaties overseen by the United Nations Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space (UNCOPUOS). These treaties address matters such as the preservation of the space and Earth environment, liability for damages caused by space objects, the settlement of disputes, the rescue of astronauts, and the sharing of information about potential dangers in outer space. The delimitation between airspace and outer space remains legally undefined, creating uncertainty in the application of specific laws. While all states are free to explore outer space according to the Outer Space Treaty, the extent to which their activities must benefit other states is unclear. The interpretation of vague treaty language and the lack of universal participation in treaty-making have led to challenges in global space governance. As space activities continue to evolve, the need for effective international cooperation, inclusive participation, and sustainable practices becomes increasingly crucial.

The application of constitutional laws in space

International Space Law:

The exploration and utilisation of outer space is governed by a body of laws and agreements known as international space law. This encompasses various international treaties, conventions, United Nations General Assembly resolutions, and rules established by international organisations. The five foundational treaties of international space law, overseen by the United Nations Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space (UNCOPUOS), are:

• Outer Space Treaty (1967): This treaty sets the foundational principles for space exploration and the use of outer space, the Moon, and other celestial bodies. It asserts that space is for the benefit of all nations, prohibits claims of sovereignty, bans weapons of mass destruction, and establishes astronauts as envoys of mankind.
• Rescue Agreement (1968): This agreement outlines the obligations of signatory states to assist and rescue astronauts in distress and return them to their launching nation. It also addresses the return of space objects that land outside the launching country.
• Liability Convention (1972): The convention outlines the liability of states for damage caused by their space objects, both on Earth and in space. It establishes procedures for settling damage claims and holds states responsible for any incidents caused by their space assets.
• Registration Convention (1976): This convention focuses on registering space objects. It requires launching states to maintain a registry of their space objects and provide information to the UN for an international register.
• Moon Treaty (1984): This treaty reiterates the peaceful purposes of exploring and using the Moon and other celestial bodies. It prohibits the use or threat of force, weapons of mass destruction, and military installations. It also emphasises the Moon as the common heritage of mankind.

National Space Legislation:

In addition to international treaties, many countries have enacted national space legislation to govern space-related activities. For example, the United States, Luxembourg, and Japan have passed laws regarding space resource exploitation and private space activities. The Outer Space Treaty assigns responsibility for regulating space activities, including those of the private sector, to individual countries where the activities take place. However, the interpretation of jurisdiction becomes complex when a spacecraft is launched in a different country from the one where it was built or owned.

Challenges and Future Developments:

The current global space governance framework faces several challenges, including the increasing number of space actors, the rapid pace of technological advancements, and the lack of inclusiveness in decision-making. There is a growing recognition of the need for more inclusive and democratic participation in space exploration and infrastructure. Additionally, the commercialisation of space, with the involvement of private entities, has introduced new considerations for governance.

To address these challenges, there have been calls for the establishment of new multilateral agreements and the revision of existing ones to adapt to the evolving nature of space activities. The development of effective bilateral agreements between like-minded allies has been suggested as a way to foster space sustainability and overcome international gridlock.

Furthermore, the issue of space debris and its potential impact on the space environment has prompted discussions about the need for a code of space ethics and the establishment of governance regulations that treat orbital space as an "additional ecosystem" or part of the human environment, subject to similar concerns and regulations as Earth's oceans.

The role of the UN in space law

The United Nations Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space (UNCOPUOS) oversees the five international treaties underpinning space law. The Committee, along with its Legal and Scientific and Technical Subcommittees, is responsible for debating issues of international space law and policy. The United Nations Office for Outer Space Affairs (UNOOSA) serves as the secretariat of the committee and promotes Access to Space for All through a wide range of conferences and capacity-building programs.

The five treaties, commonly referred to as the "five United Nations treaties on outer space", are:

• The Outer Space Treaty: This treaty is the foundation of international space law for signatory nations. It presents principles for space exploration and operation, stating that space activities are for the benefit of all nations, and any country is free to explore orbit and beyond. It also forbids weapons of mass destruction in orbit and beyond, and states that no nation can claim sovereignty in space.
• The Rescue Agreement: Signatories agree to take all possible actions to help or rescue astronauts in need and, if applicable, return them to the nation from which they launched.
• The Liability Convention: Signatories take full liability for any damage caused by their space objects and agree to standard procedures for adjudicating damage claims.
• The Registration Convention: This convention expands the space object register, empowering the UN Secretary-General to maintain a register of all space objects.
• The Moon Agreement: This agreement states that celestial bodies can only be used for peaceful purposes and should not be contaminated. It also addresses the potential for resource mining on the Moon, stating that an international regime must be established to govern how those resources are obtained and used. The United States is not a signatory to this agreement.

In addition to these five treaties, the United Nations General Assembly has also adopted five declarations and legal principles that encourage the exercise of international laws and unified communication between countries. These include the Declaration of Legal Principles Governing the Activities of States in the Exploration and Uses of Outer Space and the Agreement Governing the Activities of States on the Moon and Other Celestial Bodies.

The Outer Space Treaty

The Treaty on Principles Governing the Activities of States in the Exploration and Use of Outer Space, including the Moon and Other Celestial Bodies, commonly known as the Outer Space Treaty, is the foundational text of international space law. It was signed in 1967 and currently has 108 signatory nations. The treaty lays out several principles for space exploration and operation:

Firstly, space activities are to benefit all nations, and any country is free to explore orbit and beyond. There can be no claim of sovereignty in space; no nation can "own" space, the Moon, or any other celestial body.

Secondly, the treaty prohibits weapons of mass destruction in orbit and beyond, and the Moon, planets, and other celestial bodies can only be used for peaceful purposes. Any astronaut, regardless of their nation, is considered an "envoy of mankind," and signatory states must provide all possible assistance to astronauts in need, including emergency landings in foreign countries or at sea.

Thirdly, signatory states are responsible for their space activities, including private commercial ventures, and must provide authorization and supervision. Nations are liable for damage caused by their space objects and must avoid contaminating space and celestial bodies.

Fourthly, the treaty emphasizes international cooperation and mutual assistance in space exploration. It promotes the idea that space exploration should be carried out in accordance with international law and the interests of all countries, contributing to mutual understanding and friendly relations between states.

Finally, the treaty addresses the role of non-governmental entities in space exploration. Their activities must be authorized and supervised by the appropriate state party, and they are subject to international liability for any damage caused by their space objects.

The Rescue Agreement

The agreement states that signatory states must take all possible actions to assist and rescue astronauts in need and, if necessary, return them to the nation from which their mission was launched. This includes providing help in the event of an emergency landing in a foreign country or at sea. Additionally, signatories agree to help return any space objects that land outside the country of launch to their sponsoring nation.

The Liability Convention

Under the Liability Convention, states bear international responsibility for all space objects launched within their territory. This means that, regardless of who launches the object, the state from whose territory or facility the launch took place, or the state that caused the launch to happen, is fully liable for any resulting damages. If two states work together to launch a space object, they are jointly and severally liable for any damage caused. This means that the injured party can sue either of the two states for the full amount of the damage.

Claims under the Liability Convention must be brought by a state against a state. The convention was created to supplement existing and future national laws providing compensation to parties injured by space activities. While under most national legal systems, an individual or corporation may bring a lawsuit against another individual or corporation, under the Liability Convention, claims must be brought at the state level only. This means that if an individual is injured by a space object and wishes to seek compensation under the Liability Convention, they must arrange for their country to make a claim against the country that launched the space object that caused the damage.

Frequently asked questions