Foreign Laws In Embassies: Whose Rules Apply?

Foreign embassies are considered foreign soil, and while they remain the territory of the host nation, they are governed by diplomatic law, a branch of international law. This means that foreign laws do not apply within embassies. A fundamental concept of diplomatic law is diplomatic immunity, which means that diplomats cannot be detained or arrested and are immune from criminal prosecution in the host country. However, they are still subject to the laws of the country that sent them.

Diplomatic immunity

The modern concept of diplomatic immunity largely conforms to the 1961 Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, which has been ratified by almost every country in the world. The convention formally codified the legal and political status of diplomats, stating that diplomats may not be detained or arrested and enjoy complete immunity from criminal prosecution in the receiving state. However, there is no immunity from the jurisdiction of the sending state.

While diplomatic immunity provides almost total protection, there are some exceptions. According to Article 31 of the Vienna Convention, there are three scenarios in which diplomatic immunity does not apply:

• A real action relating to private immovable/tangible property.
• An action relating to succession.
• An action relating to any professional or commercial activity exercised by the diplomatic agent in the receiving state outside their official functions.

Additionally, in exceptional cases, a diplomat may be arrested or detained on the basis of self-defence or to protect human life. The sending state may also expressly waive immunity from jurisdiction, typically in the event of a serious crime unrelated to the diplomat's role.

Inviolability of diplomatic missions

The concept of diplomatic law is deeply rooted in international law and governs permanent and temporary diplomatic missions. A key principle of diplomatic law is the inviolability of diplomatic missions, which includes the immunity of diplomatic staff, the security of diplomatic correspondence, and the physical integrity of the diplomatic mission and its grounds.

The Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, signed in 1961, is an important treaty that outlines the rights and protections afforded to diplomatic missions. Article 22 of the Convention specifically addresses the inviolability of diplomatic missions, stating that agents of the receiving state may not enter the mission premises without the consent of the head of the mission. This article also places a special duty on the receiving state to protect the mission premises from intrusion, damage, or any action that may impair its dignity. The premises, furnishings, property, and means of transport of the mission are immune from search, requisition, attachment, or execution.

The concept of inviolability also extends to the archives and documents of diplomatic missions. Article 24 of the Vienna Convention states that these archives and documents shall be inviolable at all times and in all places, protecting the confidential information of the mission. This inviolability persists even in cases of broken diplomatic relations or armed conflict.

The principle of inviolability is based on the idea of reciprocity, where states adhere to diplomatic law out of mutual respect and understanding. However, in exceptional cases, a diplomat may be subject to arrest or detention if it is necessary for self-defence or to protect human life.

Security of diplomatic correspondence

Diplomatic correspondence is formal communication between two states, typically between heads of state. It is usually categorised into letters and notes. Letters are used for the appointment and recall of ambassadors, the announcement of the death of a sovereign or an accession to the throne, or for expressions of congratulations or condolence. Notes are less formal and include notes verbales, démarches, and aides-mémoire.

The security of diplomatic correspondence is a key element of diplomatic law, which governs permanent and temporary diplomatic missions. Diplomatic correspondence and diplomatic bags are considered inviolable, meaning they cannot be opened or detained. This is in accordance with Article 27.3 of the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations (VCDR). The United States, for example, does not search properly designated diplomatic pouches, and considers it a serious breach of the VCDR if another country does so.

Diplomatic pouches are properly identified and sealed packages, pouches, envelopes, bags, or other containers used to transport official correspondence, documents, and other articles intended for official use between embassies, legations, consular posts, and foreign offices of governments. Diplomatic pouches must bear visible external marks, such as a seal or markings in English that identify them as "Diplomatic Pouch".

The receiving state is required to permit and protect free communication on behalf of the mission for all official purposes. This includes the use of diplomatic couriers, codes, and ciphers, although the consent of the receiving state is required for a wireless transmitter. Diplomatic couriers enjoy personal inviolability and are not liable to any form of arrest or detention, although they are subject to normal security screening and customs procedures.

Human rights law

The protection and promotion of human rights is a core foreign policy priority for the United States. US embassies worldwide regularly engage with stakeholders to share information, strengthen collaboration, and support overall efforts to advance human rights. Each US embassy has an officer covering human rights, and they can encourage host governments to engage with civil society constructively. Embassies can also help connect human rights defenders with emergency resources and provide diplomatic support.

International human rights law lays down obligations that states are bound to respect. By becoming parties to international treaties, states assume the duties and obligations to respect, protect, and fulfil human rights. The obligation to respect means that states must refrain from interfering with or curtailing the enjoyment of human rights. The obligation to protect requires states to protect individuals and groups against human rights abuses. Finally, the obligation to fulfil means that states must take positive action to facilitate the enjoyment of basic human rights.

The 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) was a significant step in the international human rights movement. It was the first time in history that basic civil, political, economic, social, and cultural rights that all human beings should enjoy were spelled out. The UDHR, along with other international treaties and customary law, forms the backbone of international human rights law.

Local laws

The laws that apply to embassies are complex and depend on various factors, including international treaties and local regulations. While embassies are considered the territory of the host nation, they are also subject to the principle of "inviolability". This means that local police and security forces cannot enter embassy premises without the express permission of the ambassador. This rule is codified in the 1961 Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, which serves as a basic prerequisite for diplomatic relations.

The concept of diplomatic immunity further complicates the application of local laws within embassies. Diplomatic immunity is a fundamental aspect of diplomatic law, deriving from state immunity. It grants diplomats immunity from criminal prosecution in the receiving state, though there is no immunity from the jurisdiction of the sending state. Diplomats are, however, expected to comply with local laws, even with their immunity status.

The private residence, papers, correspondence, and property of diplomats are considered inviolable and are generally immune from the civil and administrative jurisdiction of the receiving state. However, the sending state may waive immunity from jurisdiction in exceptional cases.

The receiving state, or the host nation, has specific responsibilities regarding the embassy premises. It must protect the mission from intrusion, damage, or any disturbance that impairs its dignity. Additionally, the receiving state must facilitate the acquisition of necessary premises for the embassy and assist in obtaining suitable accommodations for its members.

In summary, while embassies operate within the territory of the host nation, they are subject to a unique set of regulations governed by diplomatic law and international treaties like the Vienna Convention. Local laws may apply to certain aspects, such as the expectation that diplomats comply with local regulations, but the concept of diplomatic immunity and inviolability limits the enforcement of these laws within embassy premises.

Frequently asked questions