Hoas And Sunshine Laws: What's The Deal In Pennsylvania?

Pennsylvania's Sunshine Act, or Open Meetings Law, applies to public agencies, including the executive branch, the General Assembly, and municipal authorities such as township boards of supervisors and local school boards. The Act also covers any organization that performs an essential government function, exercises authority, and takes official action. Homeowners' Associations (HOAs) in Pennsylvania are regulated by the Uniform Planned Community Act and the Uniform Condominium Act, which provide specific rules for the creation and management of common-interest communities. While HOAs are subject to certain state laws and regulations, it is unclear if Pennsylvania's Sunshine Act applies to them. HOAs are required to hold meetings at least annually and provide notice at least ten days but no more than 60 days in advance. However, it is not clear if these meetings are subject to the same public access and transparency requirements as government agencies under the Sunshine Act.

HOA meetings and Pennsylvania's Sunshine Act

In Pennsylvania, the Sunshine Act is a state law that guarantees the public's right to attend government agency meetings. The Act applies to public agencies, including the executive branch, the General Assembly, and municipal authorities such as township boards and local school boards. It also covers organisations that perform an essential government function, exercise authority, and take official action.

The Act requires that these agencies deliberate and take official action on agency business in open and public meetings. It mandates that meetings are announced in advance, and that the public can attend, participate, and comment before any official action is taken.

Homeowners' Associations (HOAs) in Pennsylvania are not covered by the Sunshine Act. They are, however, regulated by the Uniform Planned Community Act and the Uniform Condominium Act, which provide specific rules for the creation and management of common-interest communities. HOAs are also subject to the Pennsylvania Nonprofit Law, as they must be incorporated as nonprofits.

While not bound by the Sunshine Act, HOAs do have specific requirements for meetings. The board of directors must provide notice of all meetings at least ten days but no more than 60 days in advance. Meetings must be held at least annually, and the process for calling special meetings should be outlined in the community declaration.

Pennsylvania law does not specifically authorise or prohibit the recording of HOA meetings. However, federal and state wiretapping laws may limit the ability to record meetings, and there may be criminal and civil penalties for unauthorised recordings.

HOA meetings and public attendance

In Pennsylvania, the public's right to attend government agency meetings is based on a state law called the Sunshine Act. This Act applies to public agencies, including municipal authorities such as township boards of supervisors and local school boards. The Act also covers any organisation established by statute that performs an essential government function, exercises authority, and takes official action.

Homeowners' Associations (HOAs) in Pennsylvania are not covered by the Sunshine Act. However, they are regulated by the Uniform Planned Community Act and the Uniform Condominium Act, which provide specific rules for the creation and management of common-interest communities. HOAs are also subject to the Pennsylvania Nonprofit Law as they must be incorporated as nonprofits.

While the Sunshine Act does not apply to HOAs, there are still requirements for HOA meetings. HOA meetings must be held at least annually, and the process for calling special meetings should be outlined in the community declaration. The HOA board of directors must provide notice of all meetings at least ten days but no more than 60 days in advance.

Twice a year, HOAs hold open meetings: one for budget approval and the other for elections. These meetings are open to the HOA membership, but they are not public meetings open to anyone who wants to attend.

Pennsylvania law does not specifically authorise or prohibit the recording of HOA meetings. However, federal and state wiretapping laws may limit the ability to record meetings, and there is a risk of criminal prosecution and civil claims for money damages if consent requirements are not met.

The HOA board can make rules regarding the recording of meetings at its discretion. If the board prohibits recording and someone does so secretly, this could be considered a crime under Pennsylvania law.

HOA meetings and prior notice

HOA meetings are a crucial aspect of managing a community and making decisions that shape its future. HOA boards are required to provide prior notice of their meetings, and this notice must comply with state laws and the HOA's governing documents. In the state of Pennsylvania, the Uniform Planned Community Act and the Uniform Condominium Act provide specific rules and regulations for HOAs. While these Acts do not outline specific requirements for prior notice of HOA meetings, Pennsylvania's Sunshine Act (an open meetings law) requires that meetings of government bodies and their sub-units have prior notice and be open to the public. This would include HOA boards as they fall under the category of committees and sub-units of local government bodies.

The Sunshine Act mandates that agencies, including HOAs, provide at least three days' advance notice for regular public meetings. This notice must include the date, time, location, and agenda of the meeting. It must be printed in a paid newspaper of general circulation and posted at the meeting location(s). For special or rescheduled meetings, a 24-hour advance notice is required, with the same requirements for content and distribution.

Additionally, HOA boards should refer to their specific HOA guidelines and state laws to determine the required timeframe for providing prior notice. In California, for example, the Civil Code requires at least four days' notice for regular board meetings, while non-emergency executive sessions require two days' notice.

The prior notice for HOA meetings is essential to ensure compliance with state laws and to allow HOA members to prepare for discussions and decision-making. It promotes transparency and encourages member participation, fostering a sense of community and leading to better decision-making.

HOA meetings and the right to record

Pennsylvania's Sunshine Act, 65 Pa.C.S. §§ 701-716, requires state or local government bodies and their appointed sub-units to hold open and public meetings. This includes boards, councils, authorities, commissions, and committees. The Act defines an "agency" as an "authorised body and all committees thereof that are authorised to render advice or take official action" on behalf of the governing body.

The Act applies to any prearranged gathering of an agency, attended by a quorum of members, held for the purpose of deliberating agency business or taking official action. The public must be given prior notice of at least three days for regular meetings and 24 hours for special or rescheduled meetings. The notice must include the date, time, and location of the meeting and be published in a paid newspaper of general circulation, as well as posted at the meeting location.

The Sunshine Act allows members of the public to attend, participate, and comment at these meetings before an agency takes official action. It also permits the recording of meetings with audio or video devices, as long as it is done without causing disruptions. However, the law does not require the recording to be announced in advance, although it may be helpful for the chairperson to mention it.

While the Sunshine Act promotes transparency in government agency meetings, it is important to note that it may not directly apply to HOA meetings. HOAs are typically considered private organizations, and their meetings may not fall under the definition of "agency business" as defined by the Act.

However, this does not mean that HOA meetings cannot or should not be recorded. The decision to record HOA board meetings depends on various factors, including state laws, the HOA's governing documents, and the preferences of the HOA board and its members.

In Pennsylvania, which has a two-party consent law, all parties involved must consent to the recording. If there is no consent, it is illegal. On the other hand, some states have one-party consent laws, where recording is permitted as long as the recorder is part of the meeting.

There are advantages and disadvantages to recording HOA board meetings. Recording can result in more accurate meeting minutes, provide an official record, and increase transparency for homeowners who cannot attend. However, it may also lead to decreased meeting attendance, a lack of openness from participants, potential breaches of confidential information, and conflicts with homeowners.

Ultimately, the decision to record HOA meetings rests with the HOA board, and they should carefully consider the benefits and drawbacks before making a decision. If they choose to restrict recordings, they should amend their governing documents and clearly communicate this rule to all homeowners.

HOA meetings and the right to comment

HOA meetings are an important aspect of community living and provide a platform for members to voice their concerns and have a say in the decision-making process. In Pennsylvania, the Sunshine Act or Open Meetings Law requires agencies, including HOAs, to conduct their meetings openly and with public participation. This means that HOA meetings must be properly noticed and allow for public attendance, participation, and comment before any official action is taken.

The right to comment during HOA meetings is a crucial aspect of ensuring member engagement and transparency in the decision-making process. During the "Open Forum" or "Member Comment Period," HOA members have the opportunity to address the board and share their thoughts, questions, or concerns. This fosters a sense of fellowship and trust within the community. However, it is important to note that the Open Meeting Act does not apply to executive session board meetings, which are held in private to discuss confidential topics.

To ensure a productive and efficient open forum, it is recommended that HOA boards set clear guidelines and expectations for members. This includes establishing a reasonable time limit for comments, typically ranging from 2 to 5 minutes per member, and sticking to the meeting agenda. While members are allowed to speak on issues not listed on the agenda, board members should refrain from taking immediate action on these issues and instead collect them for discussion at a later meeting.

Additionally, HOA boards should choose an appropriate time for the open forum, considering the potential advantages and disadvantages of holding it at the beginning or end of the meeting. Experimenting with different times can help determine what works best for a particular HOA. During the open forum, board members should acknowledge members' concerns, thank them for their input, and assure them that their comments will be considered and discussed at a later date.

It is also important for HOA boards to follow their governing documents, establish a quorum, and organize a well-structured agenda. By preparing in advance and allocating time efficiently, HOA boards can ensure that all members have an opportunity to voice their opinions while maintaining a focused and productive meeting.

In conclusion, HOA meetings play a vital role in community management, and the right to comment is an essential aspect of ensuring member engagement and transparency. By following the appropriate protocols and guidelines, HOA boards can create a positive and inclusive environment that encourages member participation and contributes to the overall success of the association.

Frequently asked questions