Abortion Laws: Stricter Regulations, Lower Abortion Rates?

The question of whether stricter abortion laws lower abortion rates is a highly contested issue, with proponents and critics of abortion rights holding differing views. Since the 1973 Roe v. Wade ruling, states have enacted numerous restrictions on abortion access, with varying impacts on abortion rates. While some claim that stricter laws effectively reduce abortion rates, others argue that the decline is due to improved access to contraception and a drop in unintended pregnancies. Research on the impact of gestational limits and partial-birth abortion bans is inconclusive, as it is challenging to determine if these restrictions prevent abortions or merely shift them earlier in pregnancy. Similarly, the impact of increased access to contraceptives is uncertain, as the rate of unintended pregnancies rose concurrently with contraceptive use from 1994 to 2008. Parental involvement laws enacted before the mid-1990s have been associated with a reduction in abortions among minors, while informed consent laws in certain states have yielded mixed results. While abortion rates have decreased, the causal link to stricter laws is difficult to establish conclusively.

Gestational age limits

In Europe, almost all countries (46 out of 50) restrict abortion on demand after 15 weeks of gestation. In most European countries, abortions are only permitted after 10-14 weeks if there are specific circumstances, such as a serious danger to the life or health of the woman, or when a serious malformation or anomaly of the fetus is diagnosed.

In the United States, the point at which an abortion becomes late-term is often related to fetal viability (the ability of the fetus to survive outside the uterus). There is no sharp limit of development, age, or weight at which a fetus becomes viable. A 2015 study found that no infants born at less than 22 weeks survived, but an infant born at 21 weeks and one day in April 2021 did survive. At 23 weeks, survival without severe impairment is less than 2%, and at 25 weeks, up to 30% might survive without severe impairment.

In the United States, 18 states prohibit abortion after a certain number of weeks' gestation (usually 22 weeks from the last menstrual period). The U.S. Supreme Court held in Webster v. Reproductive Health Services that a statute may create "a presumption of viability" after a certain number of weeks, and in such cases, the physician must be given the opportunity to rebut the presumption by performing tests.

In terms of international gestational limits on abortion on demand, of the 193 U.N. countries, 7 countries limit abortion on demand before the 12th week of gestation, 38 countries limit it at 12 weeks, 10 countries limit it between 12 and 15 weeks, and 15 countries permit it past 15 weeks or have no gestational limit.

Parental involvement laws

Parental Notification Laws

Parental notification laws require written notification to parents, typically 24 to 48 hours prior, by a medical provider, before a young person can receive abortion services. These laws do not guarantee that a minor will talk to their parents before they have an abortion. Research shows that parental notification laws have almost no effect on a young person's decision to talk with their parent or guardian about their decision prior to an abortion.

Parental Consent Laws

Parental consent laws require that a young person obtain consent from one or both parents before an abortion can be performed. Eight states require that the consent document be notarized.

Impact of Parental Involvement Laws

Medical experts, including the American Medical Association, the Society for Adolescent Medicine, and the American Public Health Association, oppose mandatory parental involvement in abortion decision-making. They argue that minors should be able to independently consent to a range of sensitive health care services, including access to contraceptives, prenatal care, and STI care.

Informed consent laws

In the United States, informed consent laws vary across states. For example, in Michigan, the law requires that certain information be made available to a woman seeking an abortion at least 24 hours before the procedure. This includes information about the abortion method, risks, and alternatives, as well as possible physical and psychological consequences. Other states, such as Delaware, also have informed consent laws in place, which were implemented by 2007. These laws aim to ensure that individuals can make voluntary and well-considered decisions about their reproductive health.

However, it is important to note that informed consent does not include biased or directive counselling. Forcing individuals to view ultrasound images or providing misinformation is not considered informed consent. The World Health Organization (WHO) emphasizes that counselling should be voluntary and that individuals have the right to forgo it if they choose. Additionally, the WHO states that coercion, such as using stigma or discrimination associated with disabilities or health status to pressure women into abortions, violates their rights to informed consent and dignity.

In conclusion, informed consent laws play a crucial role in abortion legislation by empowering individuals with the information they need to make informed decisions about their reproductive health. These laws aim to protect the rights of women and girls by ensuring they have the necessary knowledge to make voluntary choices. However, it is essential to ensure that informed consent is provided in an unbiased and non-coercive manner.

Increased access to contraceptives

Providing women with increased access to contraceptives is a highly effective way to lower abortion rates. A study by Washington University School of Medicine found that offering free birth control to women significantly reduces the number of unintended pregnancies and abortions. The study, called the Contraceptive CHOICE Project, enrolled 9,256 women and adolescents in the St. Louis area between 2007 and 2011. The participants were given their choice of birth control methods, including longer-acting options like intrauterine devices (IUDs) and implants, as well as shorter-acting methods like birth control pills, patches, and rings.

The results showed that from 2008 to 2010, annual abortion rates among study participants ranged from 4.4 to 7.5 per 1,000 women, which is a substantial drop of 62 to 78% compared to the national rate of 19.6 abortions per 1,000 women in 2008. This drop in abortion rates was even more pronounced among girls aged 15 to 19, with an annual birth rate of 6.3 per 1,000, far below the national rate of 34.3 per 1,000 for the same age group.

The effectiveness of increasing access to contraceptives in lowering abortion rates can also be seen in the broader context of national trends. Between 2008 and 2014, there was an unprecedented 25% decrease in abortion rates in the United States, particularly among young women, women with higher household incomes, and women of color. This decrease has been attributed to a combination of factors, including increased use of long-acting reversible contraceptives (LARCs) and improved access to a consistent supply of contraception.

The evidence suggests that supporting and expanding women's access to family planning services and contraceptive methods is a key factor in reducing abortion rates. By providing women with the means to prevent unintended pregnancies, we can not only protect their health and rights but also lower the incidence of abortions.

Physician, hospital and abortion provider requirements

Physician, hospital, and abortion provider requirements for abortion vary across different states in America. The majority of states require that a licensed physician be the provider performing an abortion procedure. However, a few states, such as Alaska, allow other advanced practice clinicians, such as nurse practitioners and physician assistants, to perform abortions.

Some states may also require additional qualifications for all abortion providers, including advanced training and experience, hospital admitting privileges, and OB/GYN certification. These requirements are often part of Targeted Regulation of Abortion Providers (TRAP) laws, which impose burdensome legal requirements on physicians providing abortion care. Compliance with these laws can be costly and may require unnecessary facility modifications.

The legal landscape surrounding abortion has been particularly uncertain since the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in June 2022, with states now having broad discretion to prohibit or regulate abortion. This uncertainty has caused confusion among physicians and hospital systems, who are unsure about the legality of performing abortions, especially in emergency situations. While every state has an exception that allows abortion to save the life of the pregnant person, some physicians fear repercussions, including loss of their medical license, lawsuits, or criminal charges, if they provide a medically indicated abortion. This has led to some doctors leaving states with abortion restrictions or even the field of OB-GYN altogether.

The lack of clarity and variation in state laws have resulted in differing interpretations and applications, with some states prosecuting physicians and others not. For example, Alabama law allows the state to prosecute those who help organize or finance trips for Alabamians to receive abortions in other states, while other states, like Tennessee, have clarified exceptions to their abortion bans, allowing physicians to use their "reasonable medical judgment" to determine when an abortion is necessary.

The legal confusion has also led to situations where women experiencing pregnancy complications have been turned away at hospitals, putting their lives and health at risk. This has resulted in some women having to travel out of state for procedures or wait until their condition deteriorates to receive an abortion.

While no physician has been criminally prosecuted for providing an abortion due to a medical emergency, the fear of repercussions remains, highlighting the need for better education and guidance on the application of abortion laws.

Frequently asked questions