Usury Laws And Personal Loans: What's The Verdict?

Usury laws are interest rate laws that prevent lenders from charging excessively high rates on loans. These laws vary by state in the US, with some states having more restrictive rate laws than others. While usury laws generally apply to all types of loans, including personal loans, there are some exceptions. For example, loans made by banks and other financial institutions are often exempt from state usury laws, and payday lenders are typically governed by separate laws. Understanding usury laws is crucial for both lenders and borrowers to ensure compliance with legal requirements and to avoid overcharging for loans.

Usury laws and personal loans to friends and family

Usury laws are interest rate laws designed to prevent lenders from charging unreasonably high rates on loans. These laws are enforced by individual states in the US rather than at the federal level, meaning that interest rate limitations can vary from one state to another. Usury laws apply to various types of loans, including payday loans, personal loans, and credit cards.

Personal loans made to friends or relatives must comply with usury laws in your state. For example, if you provide a written loan to your friend with interest that is above the legal limit, the loan could be considered usurious. This applies as long as you can prove the three main elements of usury: there must be a loan, there must be an agreement to repay the money, and the agreement includes interest that is higher than the legal allowance.

To ensure that the loan is not usurious, it is important to put it in writing. Include the amount of the loan as well as the amount of interest that will be paid. Additionally, creating and signing a promissory note can help detail and record the loan agreement terms and protect you in case your friend or family member stops paying or disagrees with you about the amount owed.

While usury laws apply to most commercial, agricultural, and business loans, there are some exemptions. Institutions that provide consumer loans, such as banks, savings and loans, credit unions, licensed pawnbrokers, licensed finance lenders, and personal property brokers, are typically exempt from usury laws.

Interest rates and usury laws

Usury laws are interest rate laws designed to prevent lenders from charging excessively high rates on loans. These laws vary from state to state in the US, with some states having more restrictive rate laws than others. The laws are in place to protect consumers from being overcharged for loans and to prevent fraudulent loan-sharking activities.

Usury laws generally apply to all types of loans, including personal loans, payday loans, and credit cards. However, there are some exemptions. For example, licensed real estate brokers and most lending institutions, such as banks, credit unions, and pawnshops, are typically exempt from usury laws. Additionally, usury laws usually apply to consumer loans rather than commercial loans, and loans over a certain amount may also be exempt.

The definition of "too much interest" has been a matter of debate and litigation, and it is now enshrined in law in California. In California, the maximum allowable interest rate for consumer loans is 10% per year, with some exemptions. Non-consumer loans can bear the maximum interest rate of either 10% per year or the "federal discount rate" plus 5%, whichever is greater.

Usury laws are essential because they protect borrowers from being subjected to excessive borrowing costs. Without these laws, lenders could charge extremely high-interest rates, making it difficult for borrowers to repay their loans and potentially leading to long-term financial damage.

Lenders who violate usury laws may face penalties, including criminal prosecution and forfeiture of all interest on the loan. Borrowers who believe they are paying excessive interest can seek legal advice and take action to recover penalties.

Usury laws and payday lenders

Usury laws are interest rate laws designed to prevent lenders from charging excessively high rates on loans. Payday lenders are often exempt from these laws and governed by other regulations, such as deferred deposit transaction laws. Payday loans are typically short-term, high-interest loans that are usually repaid in full on the borrower's next payday. While usury laws vary by state, payday lenders fall under exemptions that allow them to charge multiple times the maximum interest rate allowed in certain states.

In states with usury laws, interest rates for loans are usually restricted to between 5% and 30%. However, payday lenders can charge much higher rates by exploiting loopholes or operating under different regulations. For example, in California, a payday lender can charge a fee of up to 15% of the loan amount, resulting in an effective APR of 460% for a two-week loan.

The absence of a federal law setting maximum interest rates on consumer loans has led to a patchwork of state-level usury laws. While some states have enacted usury laws to protect consumers, others have deregulated small loan interest rate caps or exempted payday loans from usury laws. As a result, payday lending is legal in 29 states, while 18 states and Washington, D.C., effectively prohibit it through usury rate caps.

Consumer advocacy groups argue for a federal 36% rate cap on all consumer loans, which would effectively eliminate payday lending. In the absence of such a cap, payday lenders continue to offer high-interest loans to borrowers, who often find themselves trapped in a cycle of debt.

Usury laws and credit cards

Usury laws are interest rate laws that prevent lenders from charging borrowers excessively high rates on loans. These laws vary by state, and more than half of US states have them in place. While they do apply to some loan types, they have no effect on most credit cards due to deregulation that began in the 1970s. This means that there is no interest rate cap applicable to credit cards, and competition is the only factor keeping interest rates at their current levels.

The maximum credit card interest rate that a bank can charge is determined by the law of the state where the bank is headquartered. This is generally the case even if the borrower resides in another state. However, under certain circumstances, a bank may charge rates permitted by the law of a state where it has branches, regardless of where its headquarters are located.

The Marquette National Bank v. First of Omaha Service Corporation case in 1978 was pivotal in credit card interest rate deregulation. The Supreme Court ruled that nationally chartered banks could charge the interest rates permitted in their home state and "export" these rates to out-of-state customers. This interpretation of the National Bank Act held that state usury laws did not apply to nationally chartered banks.

Subsequently, the Depository Institutions Deregulation and Monetary Control Act (DIDMCA) in 1980 granted state-chartered banks the same right to "export" their interest rates. This allowed all FDIC-insured banks to charge the highest permissible interest rate in their home state to customers across the country.

While usury laws aim to protect borrowers from unreasonably high-interest rates, they have faced criticism for limiting access to credit. The absence of these laws can increase access to credit for more people, although it may also lead to higher overall debt levels.

It is important to note that there are federal laws that set rate caps for active-duty servicemembers and their dependents, such as the Military Lending Act and the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SCRA). These laws protect servicemembers and their dependents from excessive interest rates and provide specific caps for consumer credit and credit card balances.

Usury law exemptions

Usury laws in California are complicated and contain many exceptions. Here is a list of some of the exemptions:

• National banks and federal credit unions are exempt from California's usury laws due to federal preemption. They can charge interest rates that are legal in the state where they are based.
• Licensed lenders, including banks, credit unions, finance lenders, and payday lenders, are exempt from usury laws in California. However, they must be licensed and regulated by the Department of Business Oversight.
• Small loans of $2,500 or less may be subject to different usury laws, with interest rates depending on the loan size.
• Loans "made or arranged" by a licensed real estate broker, secured by real property, are exempt from usury laws. The broker must be compensated or expecting compensation for soliciting, negotiating, or arranging the loan.
• Loans made by specified institutions authorised to act as trustees in a fiduciary capacity are exempt.
• Licensed finance lenders are exempt from usury laws, but there may be caps on the interest rates they can charge.
• Banks and similar institutions, as well as persons making five or fewer commercial loans in a year, are exempt under the California Finance Lenders Law.
• Loans to borrowers with total assets of at least $2 million are exempt from usury laws.
• Loans with evidence of indebtedness of $300,000 or more issued under a Corporate Securities Law qualification are exempt.
• Loans made by certain institutions, such as banks, credit unions, and California Finance Lenders, are generally exempt from usury laws.
• Joint venture loans or investments are exempt from usury laws, as they are considered investments rather than loans.

Frequently asked questions