Ethical Codes: When Morality And Legality Diverge

Ethical codes are a set of principles that guide professionals in conducting business with honesty and integrity. While ethical behaviour is generally concerned with what is good for individuals and society, the law is a system of rules and guidelines that are meant to be separate from ethics and enforced through social institutions. In some cases, ethical codes are legally binding, and in others, they are voluntarily adopted. For example, specific laws regulate business conduct in industries such as banking and finance, while in other industries, ethical codes are not legally mandated. Ultimately, the decision to follow an ethical code that breaks the law depends on the specific situation and the potential consequences.

Ethical behaviour vs. legal behaviour

Ethical behaviour and legal behaviour are two distinct concepts that can sometimes overlap. Legal behaviour refers to actions that comply with the laws and regulations established by a particular jurisdiction. On the other hand, ethical behaviour is more complex and subjective, as it involves adhering to a set of moral principles and values that may vary across individuals and organisations. Ethical behaviour strives to benefit all stakeholders and create positive outcomes for all parties involved.

While legal behaviour is clearly defined and enforced by established penalties for non-compliance, ethical behaviour is more nuanced. Ethical standards are often set by professions and organisations through codes of ethics, which outline expected behaviours and consequences for violations. These codes of ethics are crucial for maintaining integrity, professionalism, and trustworthiness within an organisation. They address various issues, including employee treatment, whistleblowing, conflict of interest, and social responsibility.

In some cases, ethical behaviour may conflict with legal behaviour. For instance, whistleblowing, or disclosing illegal or corrupt activities, may be considered ethical but might violate organisational policies and be deemed illegal. Similarly, some countries do not have laws prohibiting insider trading, making it legal but highly unethical. In such scenarios, individuals must use their best judgment and consider the repercussions of their actions on all stakeholders.

Conversely, certain actions may be legal but seen as unethical. For example, discriminating against smokers during the hiring process to control costs and maintain productivity could be deemed unethical as it infringes on individual rights. Organisations must carefully navigate these complex situations, balancing legal requirements with ethical considerations to make informed decisions.

Ultimately, ethical behaviour and legal behaviour are not always aligned. While legal behaviour focuses on compliance with established laws, ethical behaviour goes beyond what is legally required and is guided by moral principles. Organisations play a crucial role in promoting ethical behaviour by adopting codes of ethics, fostering a culture of integrity, and encouraging civil engagement.

The role of ethics in law enforcement

Ethics and the law are two related but distinct concepts. While the law sets out the minimum standard of behaviour that society will accept, ethics are the moral principles that guide behaviour beyond these minimum standards. Ethical behaviour is more complex than legal behaviour, and a code of ethics sets a higher standard of behaviour than what is required by law.

In law enforcement, a code of ethics is particularly important. The International Association of Chiefs of Police (IACP) adopted the Law Enforcement Code of Ethics in 1957, and updated it in 2024 to reflect the responsibilities of contemporary policing. The code stands as a preface to the mission and commitment that law enforcement agencies make to the public they serve. It outlines the duties of a law enforcement officer, which include serving the community, safeguarding lives and property, upholding the Constitution, obeying the laws they are sworn to enforce, and respecting the privacy of the people and communities they serve.

The code of ethics is an important document for any well-established business or organisation. It is a set of principles intended to guide professionals in conducting business with honesty and integrity. It outlines the organisation's mission and values, guides on addressing problems, establishes ethical principles based on the organisation's core values, and defines the standards to which professionals are held.

In the context of law enforcement, the code of ethics serves as a framework for ethical decision-making and helps to maintain the integrity of the profession. It provides guidance for the actions of individuals within the organisation, outlines the values that serve as a form of marketing for the profession, and establishes benchmarks for personal and professional evaluation.

For law enforcement officers, ethical survival is critical for career survival. Ethical survival focuses on personal accountability, a conscious recognition of potential ethical challenges, and the development of personal ethical strengths required to overcome the adverse and unusual ethical dilemmas that officers encounter. Officers must be prepared to face ethical challenges and make ethical decisions that can have severe impacts on both their official and personal lives.

Overall, the role of ethics in law enforcement is to provide a framework for ethical decision-making, maintain the integrity of the profession, and guide officers in conducting their duties with honesty and integrity.

The benefits of a code of conduct

A code of conduct is a company manual that outlines the rules, values, goals, ethics, and vision of a business. It provides staff with clear expectations of behaviour and practices that are considered good or unacceptable by the company.

Sets Clear Expectations

A code of conduct provides a clear guideline for employees, outlining the company's vision, mission, values, principles, and expectations. It helps employees understand what is expected of them in terms of behaviour and practices in the workplace, at work-related events, or when representing the company.

Enhances Company Culture

A code of conduct helps establish a strong company culture by promoting shared values, goals, and attitudes. It improves the workplace environment and clarifies to all stakeholders, including owners, employees, investors, and the community, the company's values and expectations. According to an LRN ethics survey, 73% of employees whose organisations have a written code of conduct agree that it makes their company a better place to work.

Attracts and Retains Talent

A well-defined code of conduct can help attract and retain desirable candidates. By clearly outlining the company's values, mission, and expectations, organisations can appeal to job seekers who align with their principles. It also helps set clear standards for employee behaviour and practices, fostering a positive and inclusive work environment.

Provides a Framework for Decision-Making

A code of conduct offers employees a framework for making decisions and resolving conflicts. It ensures that employees have a clear understanding of acceptable behaviour and practices, reducing confusion and potential misunderstandings.

Builds Trust and Credibility

Adhering to a code of conduct helps build trust and credibility with clients, partners, and stakeholders. When organisations consistently act in accordance with their stated values and principles, they are perceived as reliable and trustworthy. Ethical behaviour enhances the company's reputation and credibility, making it more attractive to clients and partners.

Encourages Fair Practices and Transparency

A code of conduct promotes fair and unbiased treatment of employees, fostering an inclusive environment. It encourages transparency in business practices, reducing the likelihood of corruption or unfair activities.

Enhances Professionalism and Quality of Work

A code of conduct sets high standards for professional conduct, elevating the overall quality of work and fostering a culture of excellence. It helps maintain a positive reputation for the company, which is essential for long-term success and sustainability.

Risk Mitigation and Compliance

A code of conduct can help organisations reduce financial risks associated with government fines for ethical misconduct. For example, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 requires individuals serving on boards and leaders of public companies to implement codes of conduct or provide a clear explanation for their absence. By having a code of conduct and following defined steps, organisations can demonstrate a "good faith effort" to prevent illegal acts.

In summary, a code of conduct is essential for establishing clear expectations, enhancing company culture, attracting and retaining talent, guiding decision-making, building trust, promoting fair practices, enhancing professionalism, and mitigating risks. It is a valuable tool for any organisation to foster a positive, ethical, and inclusive work environment, contributing to the long-term success of the business.

The enforceability of a code of conduct

A code of conduct is an important document that outlines a company's core values and the behaviours expected from its employees. It defines what constitutes acceptable or unacceptable behaviour and helps create a safe working environment.

While a code of conduct is not a contract or a law, it can be legally binding if it explicitly states that violations will result in disciplinary action or termination. It is also important to remember that codes are not static documents—they need to be regularly reviewed and updated to remain effective and compliant with changing laws and circumstances.

To be enforceable, a code of conduct must be fair and reasonable, relating to the organisation's mission and no more stringent than necessary. It should maintain a balance between specificity and generality, providing reasonable notice of prohibited conduct while allowing for flexibility. Enforceable codes should not unreasonably restrict trade, diminish a professional's ability to practice, or violate antitrust laws.

When creating a code of conduct, it is crucial to consider both internal and external factors, such as organisational policies and local labour laws, to ensure compliance with relevant legislation while protecting workers.

• Establish Clear Guidelines and Expectations: Clearly define the organisation's values and expectations, including specific behaviours that are acceptable and unacceptable within the workplace.
• Make It Accessible: Distribute copies of the code to all employees, post it on the company's intranet site, and ensure it is easily accessible.
• Provide Regular Training: Conduct regular training sessions or discussions during onboarding processes to ensure everyone understands how their actions will be judged against the code.
• Implement Clear Procedures for Breaches: Put in place clear procedures for dealing with breaches of the code, including disciplinary actions such as warnings or dismissal depending on the severity of the breach.
• Regularly Review and Update: Periodically review and update the code to ensure compliance with changing laws and circumstances, as well as to stay up-to-date with industry best practices.

By following these steps, organisations can create an enforceable code of conduct that promotes ethical behaviour, protects employees, and fosters a positive work environment.

The relationship between law and ethics

Understanding Ethics and Law

Ethics refers to a system of morality concerned with what is good for individuals and society. It encompasses principles and values that guide our behaviour and decisions. Ethical behaviour is complex and subjective, varying across different societies and cultures. On the other hand, the law is a set of rules and guidelines enforced by social institutions like courts and law enforcement, designed to be separate from ethics and morality. The law prescribes punishment, such as fines or jail time, for rule-breakers.

Interplay Between Law and Ethics

In an ideal world, legal and ethical judgments would be wholly separate, with moral biases excluded from the legal system. However, in reality, the two often intertwine. For example, laws may be influenced by religious ethics, and judges' personal morality may factor into sentencing. This interplay can be problematic when a judge's personal feelings conflict with the clear harm and illegality of a situation.

Impact on Society and Business

A society that strives to live ethically can positively influence legal judgments. When a society aligns in its ethical and moral beliefs, most citizens are likely to obey both the legal and ethical systems. In the business realm, ethics and legality are even more intertwined. Ethical dilemmas can have legal consequences for businesses, employees, and clients. Thus, understanding the intersection of ethics and law in one's industry is essential for preventing ethical issues.

Codes of Conduct and Ethics

Codes of conduct are important documents that outline a company's core values and expected employee behaviours. They are tailored to the specific needs, culture, and industry of a business. These codes help foster a safe working environment and promote ethical practices. They are not static but should be regularly reviewed and updated to remain effective and compliant with changing laws and corporate policies.

Legality of Codes of Conduct

While codes of conduct are not inherently legally binding, they can be if they explicitly state that violations will result in disciplinary action or termination. Even when not legally binding, codes of conduct provide guidance on handling situations and protecting companies from potential legal issues. They establish clear expectations for employees and help maintain a positive work environment.

In summary, while law and ethics are distinct concepts, they often intersect in complex ways. This interplay is particularly relevant in business, where ethical dilemmas can have legal repercussions. Codes of conduct play a crucial role in navigating this relationship, providing guidance and helping to ensure ethical and legal compliance.

Frequently asked questions