Emdrive: Physics Defying Space Travel?

The EmDrive is a hypothetical type of engine that could propel a spacecraft without the need for any fuel. The engine uses electricity to generate microwaves, which then bounce around in a closed space and generate thrust. The EmDrive's inventor, Roger Shawyer, claims that his device works and that anyone can build one and verify it for themselves. If the EmDrive works as Shawyer describes, it would break Newton's Third Law of Physics – the law of conservation of momentum. This has led to a heated debate among scientists, with some believing in the machine, and others claiming it doesn't work because it would break the laws of physics.

The EmDrive and the law of conservation of momentum

The EmDrive is a hypothetical type of engine that could propel a spacecraft without the need for any fuel. The engine uses electricity to generate microwaves, which then bounce around in a closed space and generate thrust. The EmDrive, therefore, does not require a propellant, which is an important part of current space travel mechanics.

The EmDrive appears to break the law of conservation of momentum, which states that momentum cannot be created or destroyed. The momentum of two objects that collide is equal before and after the impact. Current space travel relies on this principle, with rocket engines or thrusters using propellant that is blasted out to create an opposing force.

The EmDrive, however, creates an unbalanced equation of momentum. It transforms the momentum of electromagnetic waves into thrust. The basic idea is that microwaves are shot into a metal drum, known as the "copper bucket", which is open on one end. The microwaves bounce back and forth, creating pressure on the inside. Since the drum is open and tapered, the pressure pushes in one particular direction, making the device move.

The EmDrive generates a small force, but over long periods, even that small pressure can accelerate a spacecraft to incredible speeds. The device runs solely on electricity, meaning ships built with this technology would not need to carry fuel, reducing weight.

The EmDrive as a propellant-less thruster

The EmDrive is a hypothetical type of engine that could propel a spacecraft without the need for any fuel. The engine uses electricity to generate microwaves, which then bounce around in a closed space and generate thrust. The EmDrive was invented by British scientist Roger Shawyer, who proposed the idea of generating thrust by pumping microwaves into a conical chamber.

The EmDrive is a controversial concept because it appears to break the law of conservation of momentum, one of the foundational laws of physics. This law states that momentum cannot be created or destroyed, and it is essential for current space-travel mechanics. Typically, a rocket engine or thruster uses propellant that it blasts out to create an opposing force. However, the EmDrive does not require propellant, as it transforms the momentum of electromagnetic waves into thrust.

Multiple independent experiments have replicated the EmDrive's ability to generate thrust, although the amount of force generated is not particularly strong. The results are still for very small thrusts of under 100 microNewtons, with large input powers of dozens to hundreds of Watts. The EmDrive generates a small force of 1.2 ± 0.1 millinewtons per kilowatt, which is about 100 times stronger than a solar sail. However, over long periods of time, even this small pressure can accelerate a spacecraft to incredible speeds.

The EmDrive has the potential to revolutionize space travel if it is proven to work. It could be used to replace propellant thrusters on satellites, reducing the cost and difficulty of operating them. It could also provide sustainable thrust on deep space missions, significantly reducing the time it takes to travel to Mars or other star systems. For example, a trip to Mars could be reduced from six months to just ten weeks, and a journey to Alpha Centauri could be completed in 92 years instead of thousands of years.

While the EmDrive has passed peer review, there is still ongoing debate and uncertainty about how it works and whether it truly breaks the laws of physics. Some possible explanations for the observed thrust include undetected exhaust, an electromagnetic field generated as part of the setup, or errors in the experimental setup. More research and experimentation are needed to fully understand the EmDrive's potential and its implications for physics and space travel.

The EmDrive's potential for space travel

The EmDrive is a hypothetical type of engine that could propel a spacecraft without the need for any fuel. The engine uses electricity to generate microwaves, which then bounce around in a closed space and generate thrust. The drive does not need propellant, an important part of current space travel mechanics. The force generated by the drive is not particularly strong, but the implications are big.

Multiple independent experiments have now replicated the drive's ability to generate thrust, albeit with varying success. Using panels to convert solar energy into electricity and then into thrust, opens the door to perpetual space travel fuelled by the stars. The EmDrive could bring about a new era of space travel.

The EmDrive was first proposed in 2001 by British scientist Roger Shawyer. The idea of generating thrust by pumping microwaves into a conical chamber was controversial as it would essentially be creating force out of nothing, which isn't possible according to the law of conservation of momentum. This law states that you can't create or destroy momentum. The momentum of two objects that collide is equal before and after the impact. Space travel relies on this principle.

Despite the controversy, a handful of researchers claim they've managed to generate some thrust in their EmDrive experiments. The results are still for very small thrusts of under 100 microNewtons, with large input powers of dozens to hundreds of Watts. The EmDrive generates a small force of 1.2 ± 0.1 millinewtons per kilowatt, but it's still 100 times stronger than a solar sail. And over long periods, even that small pressure can accelerate a spacecraft to an incredible speed.

If the EmDrive becomes our new thruster of choice, space travel will get a whole lot faster. It could bring us to Mars in only 10 weeks, compared to the 6 months with current rockets. We could go to Alpha Centauri in only 92 years, compared to thousands of years.

The EmDrive's inventor, Roger Shawyer

The EmDrive is a hypothetical type of engine that could propel a spacecraft without the need for any fuel. The engine is based on the concept of generating thrust by reflecting microwaves inside a conical chamber, which would violate the law of conservation of momentum. The idea for the engine was first proposed in 2001 by British scientist Roger Shawyer, who founded Satellite Propulsion Research Ltd (SPR Ltd) in the same year to work on the EmDrive.

Shawyer's science has been criticised by many, including physicists and former employers, who claim that it is fundamentally flawed and as impossible as perpetual motion. However, Shawyer has continued to defend his work, pointing out what he calls critical errors in research that disproves the EmDrive's viability. He has also suggested that the recent failed tests of the engine are due to competing researchers getting the design wrong.

Despite the controversy, the EmDrive has gained acceptance among some scientists and research organisations, including NASA and DARPA, due to its tantalising possibilities. If proven to work, the EmDrive could introduce a new era of space travel, providing sustainable thrust for deep space missions and reducing the cost and difficulty of operating satellites.

Shawyer and SPR Ltd have been working on the EmDrive for over a decade, and the inventor has suggested using it not only for interstellar travel but also for lifting vehicles into orbit. He has also been working on a third-generation EmDrive design, which he says will provide much higher acceleration while maintaining high levels of thrust.

The EmDrive's controversial concept and debate

The EmDrive is a highly controversial concept that has sparked intense debates in the scientific community. The idea was first proposed by British scientist Roger Shawyer in 2001. Shawyer suggested that it is possible to generate thrust by pumping microwaves into a conical chamber, which would then bounce off the cone's walls, creating enough force to power spacecraft. This concept is intriguing because it eliminates the need for propellant, which is a crucial component of current space travel mechanics.

However, the EmDrive's claim to fame is that it potentially breaks the laws of physics. The device appears to create force out of nothing, challenging the law of conservation of momentum, which states that momentum cannot be created or destroyed. This law is fundamental to space travel, as it ensures the balance of forces during propulsion. The EmDrive, on the other hand, creates an unbalanced equation of momentum, which seems to defy the principles of physics.

Despite the skepticism, multiple independent experiments have replicated the EmDrive's ability to generate thrust, albeit with varying degrees of success. The results are often very small thrusts, and it is challenging to determine if the device itself generates the thrust or if there are external factors at play, such as the Earth's magnetism or seismic vibrations. The debate surrounding the EmDrive has led to a range of opinions, with some believing in the machine, while others claim it breaks the laws of physics and cannot work.

To address the controversy, a team of German physicists from Technische Universität Dresden conducted a new experiment. They built a super-sensitive instrument for measuring thrust, aiming to eliminate external interference that might have affected previous studies. Their results are expected to provide significant insights into the EmDrive debate and determine whether it truly breaks the laws of physics or if there are other factors at play.

The implications of the EmDrive are far-reaching. If proven effective, it could revolutionize space travel by eliminating the need for propellant, reducing the cost and complexity of space missions, and significantly reducing travel times to Mars and beyond. However, the scientific community remains cautious, and further tests and peer-reviewed studies are necessary to validate the technology fully.

Frequently asked questions