Toeing The Line: Is It Breaking The Law?

Breaking the law often carries a negative connotation, and for good reason. When an individual breaks the law, they are engaging in a criminal offense that warrants punishment. The severity of the punishment depends on the type of crime committed. For example, minor misdemeanors often result in community service or a fine, while more serious offenses such as burglary, assault, or drug-related charges can lead to incarceration or even life sentences. Breaking the law can also include lesser-known offenses such as prank calling, which can be considered harassment, or failing to update your driver's license when moving to a new state. While some people may be unaware that they are breaking the law, ignorance is typically not seen as a valid excuse.

Common illegal activities

While there are many different types of crimes, they can be broadly categorised into five types: crimes against a person, crimes against property, inchoate crimes, statutory crimes, and financial crimes.

Crimes Against a Person

Crimes against a person are those that result in physical or mental harm to another person. These include homicide and other violent crimes such as rape and statutory rape.

Crimes Against Property

Crimes against property involve interference with another party's property, often involving theft. Examples include burglary, larceny, robbery, auto theft, and shoplifting.

Inchoate Crimes

Inchoate crimes are those that were initiated but not completed, and also those that assist in the commission of another crime. Examples include aiding and abetting, attempt, and conspiracy.

Statutory Crimes

Statutory crimes are those specifically outlined in legislation. Alcohol-related crimes, drug crimes, traffic offences, and financial/white-collar crimes fall into this category.

Financial and Other Crimes

Financial crimes involve deception or fraud for financial gain. Examples include fraud, blackmail, embezzlement, money laundering, tax evasion, and cybercrime.

Other Common Illegal Activities

• Prank calling: In some areas, prank calling can be considered harassment or disorderly conduct.
• Using unsecured WiFi: While not illegal everywhere, it can violate internet service plans and provider policies.
• Throwing out mail: Discarding mail that is not addressed to you is a felony, even if it is junk mail.
• Failing to update your driver's license: Not updating your license when moving to a new state is illegal, regardless of whether you own a car.
• Jaywalking: Violating traffic laws by failing to use designated crosswalks or unsafely crossing busy streets.
• Copyright infringement: Downloading or sharing music, movies, games, or books without permission violates copyright laws.
• Underage drinking: The National Minimum Age Drinking Act forbids underage drinking, with some exceptions for religious activities and with parental consent.
• Marijuana possession and use: While being legalised in some states, it remains a criminal act in others.
• Traffic violations: Breaking traffic laws by speeding, not wearing a seatbelt, or using a cell phone while driving is common and can lead to traffic tickets or more severe consequences.

Penalties for breaking the law

The concept of "toeing the law" refers to the act of pushing the boundaries of what is legal, without technically breaking the law. While this may involve grey areas and ethical debates, it is important to understand the potential consequences of any legal infraction, including minor ones.

• Fines: Monetary penalties are often imposed for a variety of offences, from minor traffic violations to more serious crimes. The amount of the fine can vary significantly and is usually determined by the severity of the offence and the jurisdiction in which it occurred.
• Incarceration: For more serious crimes, imprisonment is a common penalty. The length of incarceration can range from a few days or months for minor offences to life imprisonment for the most serious crimes. The conditions of incarceration can also vary, from probation and house arrest to time spent in a correctional facility.
• Community Service: In some cases, individuals may be ordered to perform community service as a penalty for breaking the law. This can involve unpaid work for a charitable organisation or a government agency. The number of hours of community service required can vary depending on the offence and the jurisdiction.
• Probation: Probation is a period of supervision imposed by a court instead of, or in addition to, incarceration. Individuals on probation must abide by certain conditions, such as regularly reporting to a probation officer, maintaining employment, or participating in counselling or treatment programs. Probation allows individuals to avoid incarceration by demonstrating responsible behaviour and complying with court-ordered requirements.
• Restitution: Breaking the law often involves compensating the victims for any financial losses or damages incurred. Restitution can be imposed by a court or agreed upon as part of a civil settlement. The goal is to provide relief to victims and hold offenders accountable for the consequences of their actions.
• Loss of Privileges: Engaging in certain illegal activities can result in the loss of specific privileges. For example, individuals convicted of DUI may lose their driver's license, or those convicted of certain crimes may be restricted from owning firearms. These penalties aim to protect public safety and deter future violations.

It is important to remember that the specific penalties for breaking the law are dependent on various factors, including the severity of the offence, the jurisdiction, and any mitigating or aggravating circumstances. Understanding these potential consequences is crucial for making informed decisions and ensuring compliance with legal requirements.

Law-breaking in politics

In the United States, legislators and high-ranking executive officials often enjoy immunity from prosecution for their actions. This raises the question of whether other repercussions, such as political, reputational, and social risks, come into play when these individuals break the law. However, evidence suggests that violating the law does not usually result in non-legal sanctions for this group of influential Americans.

The electorate, the media, and other potential sources of social and political sanctions typically reward or punish officials based on the quality of their policy choices rather than their legality. While illegality can increase the sanctions for poor policy decisions, it appears to play a minor role in influencing the choices of these public officials.

Appointed officials can be fired, disciplined, or denied promotions, while elected officials can be voted out of office for law-breaking. Additionally, officials may be concerned about their reputations and their place in history, which could influence their actions. However, the presence and application of these less formal sanctions are uncertain, and their effectiveness as a deterrent is questionable.

The complex relationship between law-breaking and political consequences is further illustrated by the hypothesis that illegal policies that succeed on political and policy grounds rarely face negative repercussions. On the other hand, illegal policies that fail to achieve their objectives tend to increase the political and reputational penalties for the responsible officials.

In conclusion, while law-breaking by public officials may have political ramifications, the success or failure of their policies appears to be a more critical factor in determining the severity of those consequences.

Different types of crimes

While there are countless laws that can be broken, criminal acts can be grouped into five primary categories: crimes against a person, crimes against property, inchoate crimes, statutory crimes, and financial crimes.

Crimes Against a Person

Crimes against a person are those that result in physical or mental harm to another person. They can be divided into two main categories: homicide and other violent crimes. Homicide involves physical harm to another individual that is so severe it causes death. Types of homicide include first-degree murder, voluntary manslaughter, and vehicular homicide. Violent crimes include rape and statutory rape, assault, and child abuse.

Crimes Against Property

Crimes against property involve interference with another party's property, often resulting in the deprivation of the use or enjoyment of that property. Many property crimes are theft crimes, including burglary, larceny, robbery, auto theft, and shoplifting. Arson, or the act of causing criminal damage by setting fire to a person's property, also falls under this category.

Inchoate Crimes

Inchoate crimes are those that were initiated but not completed, as well as acts that assist in the commission of another crime. To be found guilty of an inchoate crime, an individual must take a "substantial step" towards the completion of the crime. Inchoate crimes include aiding and abetting, attempt, and conspiracy.

Statutory Crimes

Statutory crimes are those that are specifically prohibited by statute because society hopes to deter individuals from engaging in them. They include alcohol-related crimes, drug crimes, traffic offenses, and financial/white-collar crimes. Alcohol-related crimes involve the consumption of alcohol, such as driving under the influence, open container violations, and selling and supplying alcohol to minors. Drug crimes concern the creation or distribution of drugs, including drug possession, manufacturing, and trafficking. Traffic offenses include driving on a suspended or revoked license, hit-and-run accidents, and reckless driving.

Financial and Other Crimes

Financial crimes often involve deception or fraud for financial gain. White-collar crimes, which can be committed by anyone in any industry, include fraud, blackmail, embezzlement, money laundering, tax evasion, and cybercrime.

What constitutes a crime

In ordinary language, a crime is an unlawful act punishable by a state or other authority. However, there is no simple, universally accepted definition of what constitutes a crime. The most popular view is that a crime is a category created by law, meaning that something is a crime if it is declared as such by the relevant and applicable law.

In the US, for example, three primary classifications of criminal offences exist: felonies, misdemeanours, and infractions. Federal, state, and local government officials pass laws defining what constitutes a crime, so the definition of a crime can vary from state to state and even city to city.

A crime can be committed by an act, omission, or neglect that can result in punishment. While most crimes require the element of intent, certain minor crimes may be committed based on strict liability even if the defendant had no specific mindset with regard to the criminal action. For example, parking violations are crimes that usually do not require prosecutors to establish intent.

Some crimes are considered mala prohibita (bad because they are prohibited); these are prohibited by statute but are not inherently evil. Other crimes are considered mala in se (bad in themselves); these are considered inherently evil under general community standards.

There are two main categories of crime: property crime and violent crime. Property crime involves damaging, destroying, or stealing someone else's property, while violent crime involves harming, attempting to harm, threatening to harm, or conspiring to harm someone else. Some crimes can be both property crimes and violent crimes, such as carjacking someone's vehicle at gunpoint.

In addition to these two main categories, there are also white-collar crimes, which are financially motivated, non-violent, or non-directly violent crimes committed by individuals, businesses, and government professionals. There are also blue-collar crimes, which are committed by individuals from a lower social class and are typically small-scale and for immediate beneficial gain.

The study of crime is called criminology, a subfield of sociology that addresses issues of social norms, social order, deviance, and violence. Due to the wide range of concepts associated with crime and the lack of a precise definition, the focus of criminology can vary considerably.

Frequently asked questions