Lemon Law And Salvage Cars: What's The Deal?

Lemon laws are designed to protect car buyers from dealership fraud and defective vehicles. In the US, lemon laws vary from state to state, but generally, they apply to new and used vehicles sold with a warranty. This means that if you buy a car with a warranty and it turns out to be a lemon – that is, it has significant defects or cannot be repaired within a reasonable number of attempts – you may be entitled to a refund, replacement, or repairs.

However, lemon laws typically do not apply to salvage vehicles, which are cars that have been damaged or destroyed to the extent that they are considered uneconomical to repair. In some states, like California, it is illegal to sell a vehicle with a salvage title without disclosing it to the buyer, but in other states, dealers may be able to sell salvage cars without this disclosure.

If you have purchased a salvage vehicle that is having issues, it is important to consult with an attorney who specializes in lemon law to understand your specific rights and options.

Lemon law and dealership fraud

Lemon laws are a combination of federal and state laws that protect car buyers from dealership fraud and purchasing defective vehicles. Dealership fraud is a common problem, especially in California, where car salesmen often fail to disclose important information about a vehicle to the buyer. This includes selling a salvage vehicle without the buyer's knowledge.

A car receives a salvage title when it has been damaged or destroyed to the extent that repair costs would be uneconomical. Cars are marked as "salvage" when the cost of making necessary repairs after an accident would be equal to or nearly equal to the total value of the vehicle. It is illegal to sell a vehicle with a salvage title without disclosing it to the buyer. However, car salesmen sometimes manage to sell salvage cars by removing the salvage title from the vehicle's NMVTIS title or altering the car's VIN number.

To qualify under lemon law, your vehicle must still be under the buyer's warranty. If it isn't, you can still seek compensation by filing a dealership fraud claim. This requires proving that the car salesman failed to disclose that the vehicle purchased was salvaged or a junked vehicle. An experienced dealership fraud attorney can gather the evidence needed to prove your case and help you get your money back.

In addition to lemon laws, other state laws can help if you have been subjected to a scam or fraud when purchasing a vehicle. These include consumer rights laws, auto fraud laws, misrepresentation laws, negligence laws, and breach of contract laws.

• Odometer fraud: Altering an odometer, failing to report that an odometer has been changed or repaired, or falsifying documentation regarding a vehicle's mileage is against the law.
• Undisclosed flood damage: Flood damage reduces a vehicle's value and can cause electrical system components and safety features to fail over time. Vehicle flood damage must be disclosed before a sale.
• Undisclosed lemon law buyback: Vehicles repurchased by a manufacturer or dealership due to defects under lemon law must be branded and disclosed as a "lemon law buyback".
• Yo-yo financing: This occurs when a buyer takes possession of a vehicle after agreeing on terms with a dealer, and the dealer later falsely claims that a lender has requested changes to the contract or that the buyer must return the vehicle.

If you suspect dealership fraud, you can take the following steps:

• Research the laws in your state, including the National Consumer Law Center, Better Business Bureau, and the state's Lemon Law.
• Keep detailed records of any problems with your vehicle and attempts to repair them.
• Report the problem to the dealer or manufacturer. The dealership or car maker has the right to try to repair the problem, and they can make up to four attempts to fix it at no charge to you.
• If the problem is not repaired within the specified limit, send a "demand letter" to the car company, detailing the issues and requesting that they take back the car and refund your money.
• If the company denies your claim or you are not satisfied with their proposed settlement, consider hiring a lawyer and filing a lawsuit.
• Contact your state's protection agency, typically the attorney general, as they are empowered to investigate swindles and frauds.

Lemon law and warranty

Lemon laws are designed to protect car buyers from dealership fraud and defective vehicles. In the case of a salvage vehicle, which has been damaged or written off to the extent that repair costs would be uneconomical, lemon laws do not typically apply.

In the US state of California, for example, a vehicle must be under warranty for it to qualify under lemon law. While this includes the dealer's warranty, it is worth noting that a dealer is not legally permitted to sell a vehicle with a salvage title without disclosing this to the buyer. If a dealer fails to disclose this information, a fraud claim can be filed.

In the state of New York, a used car lemon law exists to protect buyers. This law requires a dealer to provide a written warranty for certain parts of the car, including the engine, transmission, drive axle, brakes, and steering. If the dealer cannot repair the car after a reasonable number of attempts, the buyer can request arbitration and may be entitled to a full refund.

In both California and New York, it is possible to seek compensation for a salvage vehicle that was sold without the buyer's knowledge, even if it is not covered by lemon law. This would involve filing a dealership fraud claim or a claim for breach of contract.

Lemon law and vehicle defects

Lemon laws are designed to protect car buyers from dealership fraud and defective vehicles. In the US, lemon laws vary from state to state, but generally, they give consumers the right to a refund, replacement, or repair if they buy a defective car.

In California, for example, a car with a salvage title has been damaged to the extent that it is considered uneconomical to repair. Cars are typically marked as "total loss" or "salvage" when the cost of repairs is equal to or nearly equal to the total value of the vehicle. It is illegal to sell a vehicle with a salvage title without disclosing it to the buyer, but some car salesmen still do so by removing the salvage title or altering the vehicle's VIN number.

To qualify for protection under California's lemon law, your vehicle must still be under warranty. If it is not under warranty, you may still be able to seek compensation by filing a dealership fraud claim. An attorney can help you gather the evidence needed to prove your case and get your money back.

In Texas, the lemon law is administered by the Texas Department of Motor Vehicles and helps consumers who buy or lease new motor vehicles that have repeated problems, as long as the vehicle is still under the manufacturer's original warranty. The law covers cars, trucks, vans, motorcycles, all-terrain vehicles, motor homes, towable recreational vehicles, and neighborhood electric vehicles. It does not cover repossessed vehicles, non-travel trailers, boats, or farm equipment, and defects must substantially impair the use or market value of the vehicle.

To make a lemon law claim in Texas, you must meet several conditions, including having a substantial manufacturing defect that is covered by the manufacturer's written warranty and giving the dealer a reasonable number of attempts to repair the defect. You must also give the manufacturer written notice of the defect and the opportunity to cure it. If you win your case, the manufacturer may be ordered to buy back the vehicle, replace it, or fix the defects.

In summary, lemon laws can provide valuable protection for consumers who purchase defective vehicles. However, it is important to understand the specific laws in your state, as they can vary significantly. If you believe you have purchased a lemon, it is important to seek legal advice to understand your rights and options.

Lemon law and vehicle age

Lemon laws vary by state, but generally, a vehicle's age is not the determining factor in whether it falls under the lemon law. Instead, it depends on two key factors: the warranty and the lemon law's statute of limitations.

In California, for example, the lemon law applies to new or used vehicles purchased with the manufacturer's express warranty. The statute of limitations for a lemon law claim is four years from when the vehicle defect was first discovered. However, the age of the car may still play a role, as the lemon law does not cover problems that result from natural wear and tear.

In Massachusetts, lemon law applies to vehicles with an unreasonable repair history under the warranty, such as three to four repair attempts for the same problem, six repairs total, or 30 days out of service for repairs. The duration of the warranty period depends on the vehicle's mileage at the time of sale.

In Virginia, the lemon law applies to new vehicles purchased in Virginia that have been unsuccessfully repaired three or more times for the same problem or have been out of service for more than 30 days in one year. Claims must be filed within 18 months of receiving the vehicle.

While I cannot provide an exhaustive list of lemon laws in every state, the information above illustrates that vehicle age is not the sole determining factor. It is important to review the specific lemon laws in your state to understand how vehicle age may impact your rights.

Lemon law and vehicle type

Lemon laws are state-specific and vary across the US. Generally, lemon laws apply to new vehicles, but some states also include used vehicles.

California

In California, lemon laws apply to both new and used vehicles, as long as they are still under warranty. The vehicle must be purchased from a dealer or retailer, not an individual, and the warranty can be either from the manufacturer or the dealer.

California's lemon law for used cars protects buyers who have purchased a defective vehicle that cannot be repaired after a reasonable number of attempts. The law requires the manufacturer or dealer to repurchase or repair the vehicle if it has a significant defect.

Texas

In Texas, lemon laws apply to new motor vehicles, including cars, trucks, vans, motorcycles, all-terrain vehicles, motor homes, towable recreational vehicles, and neighborhood electric vehicles. The law does not cover used vehicles unless they are still under the manufacturer's original warranty or if the defect was reported to the dealer while under the original warranty and continues to exist.

Other States

Some other states, such as Arizona, Connecticut, Maine, and New Mexico, have similar lemon laws that cover used vehicles. These states require statutory warranties or implied warranties of merchantability to be in effect for a minimum period after the sale.

It is important to note that lemon laws do not apply to vehicles purchased from individuals or private sellers. Additionally, vehicles must meet certain criteria, such as having a substantial manufacturing defect and the owner reporting the defect within the warranty term.

Frequently asked questions