Sharia Law And Its Application To Gay Men And Women

Sharia law, derived from the Quran and the teachings of the Prophet Muhammad, is interpreted differently across the world. In some countries, it is used to justify the persecution of LGBTQ+ individuals, with punishments ranging from imprisonment and fines to corporal punishment, flogging, and even the death penalty.

In countries such as Saudi Arabia, Iran, Yemen, Mauritania, Nigeria, and the United Arab Emirates, homosexuality is criminalised and punishable by death. In these countries, same-sex relations are often considered a violation of religious and cultural values, leading to systemic discrimination, harassment, and violence.

However, it's important to note that the interpretation of Sharia law varies, and not all Muslim-majority countries enforce capital punishment for homosexuality. Some countries, like Turkey, Jordan, and Iraq, have legalised homosexuality, while others, like Egypt, indirectly target LGBTQ+ individuals through vague morality laws.

The application of Sharia law regarding homosexuality has been a subject of debate among Islamic scholars, with some arguing for a more tolerant and inclusive interpretation.

Sharia law and the punishment of homosexuality

Sharia law is a set of religious laws that govern the behaviour of Muslims. In many Muslim-majority countries, homosexuality is illegal, and in some, it is punishable by death.

In the Quran, the story of Sodom and Gomorrah is often interpreted as a condemnation of homosexuality. The Quranic narrative describes the "people of Lot" as being destroyed due to their sexual practices. This story is referenced in several hadiths (sayings attributed to the Prophet Muhammad) that call for harsh punishments for homosexual activity, specifically anal intercourse between men.

In some Muslim-majority countries, such as Saudi Arabia, Iran, Afghanistan, Mauritania, northern Nigeria, and the United Arab Emirates, homosexuality is punishable by death. These laws are based on interpretations of Islamic teachings and Sharia law. The methods of execution vary and include stoning, beheading, and throwing people from buildings.

The Islamic State (IS) group has also targeted gay men for execution, using justifications from Islamic texts and portraying these acts as a form of moral policing. IS has been known to throw people from buildings, stone them, or shoot them as methods of execution.

While Sharia law prescribes harsh punishments for homosexuality, it is important to note that the application and enforcement of these laws vary across jurisdictions. Some countries may not have imposed or enforced these penalties in recent years, while others carry out executions regularly. Additionally, there are Muslim-majority countries, such as Turkey, Jordan, and Lebanon, where homosexuality is legal, although social attitudes may still be hostile.

Sharia law and the persecution of LGBTQ+ people

Sharia law, derived from the Quran and the teachings of the Prophet Muhammad, is interpreted differently across the Muslim world and has varied historically. While there is no explicit mention of homosexuality in the Quran, the story of Lot, his people, and the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah is often interpreted as a condemnation of homosexuality, specifically male-to-male anal intercourse.

In the modern era, the spread of Islamic fundamentalist movements, such as Salafism and Wahhabism, has contributed to increasingly negative attitudes towards LGBTQ+ people in the Muslim world. Additionally, the influence of colonial-era anti-homosexuality laws implemented by European empires has also played a role in shaping modern Muslim homophobia.

Today, many Muslim-majority countries have laws that criminalise LGBTQ+ people and relationships, with some even prescribing the death penalty for convicted offenders. These laws are often justified by religious authorities and are enforced through legal systems, vigilante groups, and non-state actors such as terrorist organisations.

The persecution of LGBTQ+ people in the Muslim world takes various forms, including violence, discrimination, intimidation, and harassment. This persecution is exacerbated by socially conservative attitudes and the rise of Islamist ideologies in some countries. While there are some LGBTQ+ inclusive mosques and organisations, many LGBTQ+ Muslims are forced to choose between their sexuality and their religion.

The Quran and Hadith on Homosexuality

The Quran contains several allusions to homosexual activity, particularly in the story of Lot and the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah. This story is interpreted as a condemnation of homosexuality, specifically male-to-male anal intercourse, by Islamic scholars and is used to justify laws criminalising LGBTQ+ people and relationships.

The Hadith, a collection of the Prophet Muhammad's teachings, also includes passages condemning homosexual acts and prescribing punishments. However, the burden of proof for administering these punishments is high, and there is debate among Muslim jurists on the appropriate punishment for homosexual acts.

Sharia Law and Criminalisation of LGBTQ+ People

Sharia law, or Islamic law, is derived from the Quran and the Hadith and is interpreted by religious scholars and jurists. While interpretations vary, many Muslim-majority countries have enacted laws that criminalise LGBTQ+ people and relationships, with some prescribing harsh punishments, including the death penalty.

For example, in 2019, Brunei introduced Islamic law, including the death penalty for homosexuality, sparking international condemnation. Other countries that impose the death penalty for consensual same-sex acts include Iran, Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Afghanistan, Mauritania, northern Nigeria, and the United Arab Emirates. Additionally, several other countries criminalise LGBTQ+ acts with punishments ranging from imprisonment to fines and flogging.

Persecution of LGBTQ+ People

The criminalisation of LGBTQ+ people in Muslim-majority countries has led to widespread persecution, including violence, discrimination, intimidation, and harassment. This persecution is often justified by religious authorities and is carried out through legal systems, vigilante groups, and non-state actors such as terrorist organisations.

One notable example is the Islamic State (IS), which has publicly executed gay men, often by throwing them off buildings, as part of its moral policing campaign. Other jihadist groups, such as the Taliban and al-Qaeda, have also executed homosexuals. Additionally, the breakdown of law and order in countries like Iraq has allowed Islamist militias and vigilantes to carry out illegal executions of LGBTQ+ people.

Impact on LGBTQ+ Muslims

The criminalisation and persecution of LGBTQ+ people in the Muslim world have had a significant impact on LGBTQ+ Muslims, who often face a choice between their sexuality and their religion. Many are forced to hide their sexuality or face rejection and violence from their families and communities.

While there are some LGBTQ+ inclusive mosques and organisations, such as the Ibn Ruschd-Goethe mosque in Berlin and the Muslim Alliance for Sexual and Gender Diversity (MASGD), these are mostly based in Western countries. In Muslim-majority countries, LGBTQ+ Muslims often face legal persecution, social ostracism, and violence, leading many to seek refuge in more accepting countries.

Sharia law, as interpreted by religious authorities in Muslim-majority countries, has been used to justify the criminalisation and persecution of LGBTQ+ people. This has resulted in violence, discrimination, and harassment, forcing many LGBTQ+ Muslims to hide their sexuality or seek refuge elsewhere. While there are some inclusive spaces and organisations, the overall environment in the Muslim world remains hostile towards LGBTQ+ people.

Sharia law and the acceptance of homosexuality

Homosexuality is considered a sin in Islam and is punishable under Islamic law. The four Sunni schools of jurisprudence agree that practising homosexuality is a crime that earns a harsh punishment, although the schools vary on the exact punishment. In the Hanafi school, the punishment is a harsh beating, followed by execution if the individual persists. In the Shafi'i school, the punishment is the same as for illegal intercourse (zina) – 100 lashes if unmarried and stoning to death if married.

Islamic law is derived from the Quran and Hadith (accounts of Muhammad's life). The Quran and Hadith are clear about the moral ruin of the people of Lot, and the Hadith includes many passages calling for harsh punishments of homosexual activity. However, these condemnations focus on anal penetration between men, rather than romantic feelings or other kinds of sexual acts between them. The burden of proof for administering the associated punishments is high, and it is unclear how often this prohibition has been enforced throughout history.

In pre-modern periods, there was colloquial and de facto official acceptance of at least some homosexual behaviour. Historical records suggest that laws against homosexuality were invoked infrequently, mainly in cases of rape or other "exceptionally blatant infringement on public morals" as defined by Islamic law. This allowed themes of homoeroticism and pederasty to be cultivated in Islamic poetry and other literary genres.

In the modern era, Muslim public attitudes towards homosexuality have become more hostile, largely due to the global spread of Islamic fundamentalist movements, such as Salafism and Wahhabism. Most Muslim-majority countries have opposed moves to advance LGBTQ rights and recognition at the United Nations. There are laws against homosexual activities in a larger number of Muslim-majority countries, with some prescribing the death penalty for convicted offenders.

In some Muslim-majority countries, current anti-LGBTQ+ laws were enacted by the United Kingdom or Soviet organs and retained following independence. However, Jordan, Bahrain, and India have abolished the criminal penalties for consensual homosexual acts introduced under colonial rule.

In recent decades, the rise of Islamic fundamentalism and the emergence of the gay rights movement in the West have exacerbated the persecution of homosexuals. Islamists have painted homosexuality as a noxious Western import.

The history of Sharia law and its views on homosexuality

Sharia law, or Islamic law, is based on the Quran, the hadith (sayings and actions attributed to the Prophet Muhammad), and the decisions made by early Islamic rulers. It is a legal system that guides Muslims in many areas of life. However, it is not static and has evolved over time.

Historically, Sharia law has been interpreted to criminalise homosexuality. This interpretation is based on the story of Lot in the Quran, where the people of Sodom were destroyed for their sexual misconduct. The Quran also mentions "men who are not in need of women", which may refer to gay or asexual men. While the Quran does not explicitly mention homosexuality or the word itself, later Islamic scholars and jurists formulated punishments for homosexual acts, such as stoning, flagellation, or death by sword. These interpretations have been challenged, with some arguing that the story of Lot condemns rape and sexual violence rather than consensual same-sex relationships.

In the pre-modern era, there was colloquial and de facto acceptance of homosexual behaviour in Islamic societies. Historical records suggest that laws against homosexuality were rarely invoked and that homosexual relationships were tolerated, if not celebrated. Homosexuality was a theme in Islamic poetry and literature, with older men expressing love and desire for adolescent boys. However, in the 19th century, Islamic views on homosexuality became more negative due to the influence of Islamic fundamentalist movements and restrictive sexual norms from Christian Europe. As a result, many Muslim-majority countries today have laws that criminalise homosexuality, with some even imposing the death penalty.

In recent times, there have been efforts to reinterpret Sharia law regarding homosexuality. Some Muslim scholars and activists argue that the Quran does not explicitly prohibit homosexuality and that historical Islamic societies were "homosexual-friendly". They advocate for LGBTQ rights and inclusion within Islam, challenging the prevailing conservative attitudes and laws in many Muslim-majority countries.

The future of Sharia law and its views on homosexuality

Sharia law is a legal system based on the Quran, the hadith (sayings and actions attributed to the Prophet Muhammad), and the decisions made by early Islamic rulers. It is a complex system that is not set in stone and has evolved over time.

• Interpretations and Enforcement: Sharia law is interpreted and enforced differently across Muslim-majority countries. While some countries impose harsh punishments, including the death penalty, for homosexuality, others have a more lenient approach or do not explicitly criminalize it. The future may see a continued divergence in how Sharia law is interpreted and enforced regarding homosexuality, with some countries becoming more conservative while others move towards liberalization.
• Influence of Fundamentalist Movements: Islamic fundamentalist movements, such as Salafism and Wahhabism, have contributed to the negative views towards homosexuality in some Muslim-majority countries. These movements promote a strict adherence to their interpretations of Islamic teachings, which often include condemnation of homosexuality. The influence of these movements may shape the future of Sharia law by encouraging more conservative interpretations and enforcement.
• Progressive Voices and Reform: There are progressive Muslims and Islamic scholars who challenge the traditional interpretations of Sharia law regarding homosexuality. They argue that Islam is compatible with homosexuality and that Sharia law should be reinterpreted to reflect this. Additionally, some countries are re-examining and reforming colonial-era laws that criminalize homosexuality, which could lead to a more inclusive future for Sharia law in those contexts.
• Globalization and Cultural Exchange: The exchange of ideas and influences between Muslim-majority countries and the wider world may impact the future of Sharia law. Exposure to different cultural perspectives on homosexuality could lead to a shift in societal attitudes and, consequently, influence the interpretation and application of Sharia law.
• Human Rights and International Pressure: The recognition of LGBTQ+ rights as human rights by international organizations and the pressure exerted on countries to uphold these rights may also shape the future of Sharia law. While some Muslim-majority countries resist this pressure, others may be compelled to re-evaluate their legal approaches to homosexuality, including those based on Sharia law.

In conclusion, the future of Sharia law and its views on homosexuality is multifaceted and subject to various influences. While there may be a continued divergence in interpretations and enforcement across Muslim-majority countries, the interplay between conservative and progressive forces, global cultural exchange, and international pressure for LGBTQ+ rights will likely play a significant role in shaping the future landscape of Sharia law regarding homosexuality.

Frequently asked questions