Texas Abortion Law: Exemption For Rape Victims?

The Texas abortion law, also known as the Texas Heartbeat Bill, prohibits physicians from performing abortions once a fetal heartbeat is detected, which is usually around six weeks into a pregnancy. This law does not include an exception for rape or incest. Instead, the only exception is if the pregnant patient faces a life-threatening physical condition aggravated by, caused by, or arising from a pregnancy. This means that in Texas, abortions are not legally accessible to survivors of rape or incest, even if they report the crime to law enforcement.

Texas abortion law: no exception for rape

The Texas abortion law, also known as the Texas Heartbeat Bill, prohibits physicians from performing abortions once a fetal heartbeat is detected, which is usually around six weeks into a pregnancy. This law took effect on September 1, 2021, and sparked heated debates and legal challenges across the nation. While there are a few exceptions to the law, such as in the case of a life-threatening physical condition or a serious risk of substantial impairment of a major bodily function, there is no exception for rape or incest.

The lack of an exception for rape in the Texas abortion law has been a highly controversial issue. Studies have shown that Texas leads the country in rape-related pregnancies among the states with total abortion bans. In the 16 months after the state legislature banned abortion, there were an estimated 26,313 rape-related pregnancies in Texas, comprising nearly 45% of all such pregnancies in the nine ban states that did not make a legal exception for rape. This has had a disproportionate impact on Black and Hispanic women, who already faced limited access to abortion and reproductive health care in the state.

The absence of a rape exception in the Texas abortion law has been criticized by many, including medical professionals and advocates for rape survivors. They argue that the law fails to provide reasonable access to abortion for survivors, who often face additional barriers such as the requirement to report the crime to law enforcement and the lack of providers willing to take the legal risk of performing an abortion. As a result, rape survivors in Texas may have to travel to another state to obtain an abortion, which can be challenging and costly.

The Texas abortion law has been challenged in the courts, with lawsuits arguing that the vague language of the law endangers women's lives and that the lack of exceptions for rape and incest is unconstitutional. However, the Texas Supreme Court has upheld the law, stating that it is not within their jurisdiction to determine what the law should be but to elaborate on how physicians can provide care within the current legal framework.

The issue of abortion and the lack of exceptions for rape in states like Texas have become a focus of the reelection campaign of President Joe Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris. They have criticized the extreme agenda of Republican elected officials and vowed to continue fighting for the right to choose and restore the protections of Roe v. Wade in federal law.

Rape reporting: a barrier to abortion access

In the wake of the Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, several states have implemented abortion bans with varying exceptions. While some states have included exceptions for rape, these exceptions are often meaningless in practice. Texas, for example, has one of the most restrictive abortion laws in the country, with no exceptions for rape or incest. This means that even if a woman becomes pregnant as a result of rape, she is unable to obtain a legal abortion in Texas.

The issue of rape reporting as a barrier to abortion access is a complex one. On the one hand, reporting rape to law enforcement can provide survivors with a path to justice and help hold perpetrators accountable. On the other hand, it can also create significant barriers to accessing abortion services, especially in states with restrictive abortion laws.

One of the main issues with rape reporting requirements is that they can retraumatize survivors and make them feel like "potential criminals." Many victims are not emotionally or physically capable of immediately reporting their rapes, as they are dealing with shock, stigma, and shame. Additionally, reporting rape can put survivors at greater risk of violence from their abusers, especially if they are experiencing domestic violence. As a result, it is estimated that only a small percentage of rapes are reported to law enforcement.

Even if a survivor does report the rape and cooperates with investigators, they may still face barriers to accessing abortion services. In states with restrictive abortion laws, there may be few or no providers willing to take on the legal risk of performing an abortion. This means that survivors may have to travel long distances to other states to obtain an abortion, which can be costly and logistically challenging, especially for those with limited financial resources.

The impact of these barriers falls disproportionately on marginalized communities, including Black, Hispanic, and low-income women. These communities often have limited access to reproductive health care and may face additional barriers to reporting rape and accessing abortion services.

The inaccessibility of abortion services for rape survivors has led to an increase in pregnancies resulting from rape. A study published in JAMA Internal Medicine found that Texas had the highest number of rape-related pregnancies among the 14 states with total abortion bans. Between July 2022 and June 2023, an average of nine abortions per month occurred in Texas, despite the state's restrictive abortion laws. This suggests that even in states with exceptions for rape, survivors are not always able to access abortion services.

The issue of rape reporting as a barrier to abortion access highlights the complex and interrelated issues surrounding reproductive rights and violence against women. It is important for policymakers and advocates to recognize the potential harms of requiring rape reporting as a condition of accessing abortion services. Efforts should be made to support and protect survivors of rape, rather than further traumatizing them and restricting their access to essential health care.

Rape survivors: forced to leave the state

The Texas abortion law does not include exceptions for rape or incest. This means that rape survivors in Texas cannot legally obtain an abortion in the state, even if they report the crime to law enforcement. As a result, many rape survivors are forced to leave the state to seek an abortion, travelling hundreds of miles to a state where abortion is legal. This presents a significant financial and logistical burden, particularly for those who do not have control over their financial resources.

The lack of an exception for rape in the Texas abortion law has been criticised by many, including the White House, which has stated:

> It is unconscionable that this is happening in America. The overturning of Roe v. Wade has already led to 21 dangerous abortion bans in effect in states across the country, many of which have no exceptions for rape or incest...President Biden and Vice President Harris will continue to fight for the right to choose and call on Congress to restore the protections of Roe v. Wade in federal law.

The impact of the lack of an exception for rape is particularly devastating for Black and Hispanic women, who already faced limited access to abortion and healthcare in Texas. Qiana Lewis-Arnold, a birth justice advocate with the Dallas-based non-profit The Afiya Centre, has stated that the situation for Texans is "taxing" and "terrifying", and that the impact of the abortion ban will be felt most strongly by the most marginalised communities.

The Texas abortion law also creates a criminal cause of action against doctors who perform abortions, opening them up to criminal prosecution and allowing for civil lawsuits. As a result, many doctors in Texas are scared to perform abortions, even in cases of rape, for fear of prosecution and losing their medical licence. This means that even if a rape survivor is able to travel to Texas to seek an abortion, they may struggle to find a doctor who is willing to perform the procedure.

The Texas abortion law, therefore, creates a situation where rape survivors are forced to leave the state to seek an abortion, facing significant financial and logistical hurdles, and even if they are able to make the journey, they may struggle to find a doctor who is willing to perform the procedure.

Rape-related pregnancies: the Texas numbers

A study published in the medical journal JAMA Internal Medicine in January 2024 found that Texas had the highest number of rape-related pregnancies among the 14 US states with total abortion bans. The study, which examined data from the FBI, CDC, and Bureau of Justice Statistics, estimated that 26,313 rape-related pregnancies occurred in Texas during the 16 months after the state legislature banned abortion. This figure comprises nearly 45% of all such pregnancies estimated to occur in the nine ban states that did not make a legal exception for rape.

The study also estimated that there were 519,981 vaginal rapes of women aged 15-45 in these 14 states, resulting in 64,565 pregnancies. Texas accounted for 211,919 of the rapes and about 45% of the resulting pregnancies. The authors of the study noted that the true numbers may be higher, as rape and rape-related pregnancies are highly stigmatized and often underreported.

The impact of these total abortion bans falls disproportionately on Black and Hispanic women, who already faced limited access to abortion and healthcare in Texas. Qiana Lewis-Arnold, a birth justice advocate with the Dallas-based non-profit The Afiya Center, described the situation for Texans as "taxing" and "terrifying". She highlighted the risk of criminalization and death that these communities now face.

The study also showed a rise in teenage pregnancies in Texas, marking the potential reversal of a nationwide, decades-long decline. Hispanic teens saw the highest increase, with a 1.3% rise, while non-Hispanic Black teens saw a 0.5% increase, and non-Hispanic white teens saw a 5% decline.

While Texas law does not criminalize the woman who had the abortion, it does create a criminal cause of action against doctors and anyone who provided aid or assistance. This has led to a climate of fear and confusion, with many doctors unsure of when they can legally perform an abortion and feeling intimidated by the risk of prosecution.

The impact on marginalised communities

Marginalised communities are disproportionately impacted by the Texas abortion law. The law does not include exceptions for rape or incest, and this has a significant impact on the most vulnerable members of society.

Firstly, the law fails to protect survivors of sexual violence, who are often unable to access abortion services due to various barriers. In Texas, abortion is only permitted when the life of the mother is at risk, which excludes a large number of rape survivors who may not face life-threatening physical conditions but still wish to terminate their pregnancies. This is exacerbated by the requirement in some states to report the crime to law enforcement, which many survivors are reluctant to do due to fear of retaliation, stigma, or shame. The involvement of law enforcement further intimidates and re-traumatises survivors, making it less likely for them to seek help.

Additionally, the lack of rape exceptions disproportionately affects people of colour, particularly Black and Hispanic women, who already face limited access to abortion and reproductive healthcare. Qiana Lewis-Arnold, a birth justice advocate, highlights the "disproportionate impact" of abortion bans on Black, Hispanic, and other marginalised communities. She points out that the majority of the country's Black population resides in southern states, many of which have enacted total abortion bans. This restricts the mobility and healthcare options available to these communities, further marginalising them.

The absence of rape exceptions also affects teenagers and young adults, especially those from marginalised backgrounds. The University of Houston's Institute for Research on Women, Gender & Sexuality reported a rise in teenage pregnancies in Texas, with a disproportionate increase among Hispanic and Black youth. This reversal of the previous declining trend underscores the negative impact of the abortion law on vulnerable youth, who may lack the necessary resources and support to continue a pregnancy or access alternative options.

Furthermore, the law's failure to account for rape exceptions has led to an increase in self-managed abortions or attempts to travel to states where abortion is legal. This can be dangerous and further traumatising for survivors, as they may resort to unsafe methods or face additional financial and logistical challenges.

The impact of the Texas abortion law on marginalised communities is profound and far-reaching. The lack of rape exceptions disproportionately affects survivors of sexual violence, people of colour, and youth from vulnerable backgrounds. It limits their access to reproductive healthcare, increases their risk of trauma, and exacerbates existing inequalities.

Frequently asked questions