Lemon Law: Dealerships And Beyond

Lemon laws are consumer protection laws that apply to the purchase of cars and other goods that fail to meet quality and performance standards. While lemon laws are often associated with motor vehicles, they can also apply to a range of consumer products that include warranties, such as computers and home appliances. In the context of vehicle purchases, lemon laws are designed to protect consumers when buying vehicles at auto dealerships, and they cover both new and used cars, as well as leased vehicles, depending on the specific state's legislation. The laws outline the criteria for a vehicle to be considered a lemon, which generally includes having a substantial defect covered by warranty and persisting after a reasonable number of repair attempts. While dealerships are not obligated to buy back a defective vehicle, the laws ensure that manufacturers are held accountable for repurchasing or replacing such vehicles.

Lemon laws apply to all consumer products with a warranty

Lemon laws are in place to protect consumers who have purchased defective products. While the term "lemon" is mostly used to describe defective motor vehicles, lemon laws may apply to all types of consumer products that include warranties. This means that cars, trucks, SUVs, motorcycles, computers, and home appliances may all be covered under lemon laws.

In the United States, each state has its own lemon law, and the specifics of each law vary. While most lemon laws cover new vehicles, some states, like California, Texas, and New York, also have used car lemon laws. Additionally, while most states' lemon laws cover leased vehicles, there are exceptions, such as in Nevada and New Mexico, where legislation does not include leases.

Lemon laws provide a remedy for purchasers of defective products by requiring the manufacturer or dealer to repair, replace, or refund the product. The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, enacted as a federal law in 1975, is often referred to as the federal lemon law as it covers most consumer products with a written warranty. This Act ensures that manufacturers honor their warranties and reduces the chance of consumers being misled about the nature and scope of a warranty.

It is important to note that lemon laws may not apply to products purchased "as is" or "with all faults" without a warranty. However, a consumer who was misled into waiving the protection of a warranty may still be protected by the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act.

Dealerships have no obligation to buy back a defective vehicle

Lemon laws are consumer protection laws that apply to the purchase of new and, in some cases, used vehicles. These laws vary by state, but they generally require that a vehicle have a "substantial defect" that is covered by warranty and occurs within a certain time after purchase. While lemon laws offer remedies for purchasers of defective vehicles, it is important to note that dealerships have no obligation to buy back a defective vehicle.

When a vehicle is found to have a defect, the dealership or manufacturer has the right to attempt to repair the problem. They can make up to four attempts to fix the issue at no charge to the buyer, and the vehicle cannot remain in their shop for longer than one month total. If the dealership or manufacturer can repair the problem within this timeframe, they have fulfilled their obligation.

If the dealership or manufacturer cannot repair the defect within the specified timeframe, the buyer may take further action. The buyer can send a "demand letter" to the car company, requesting that they take back the car and refund the purchase price. However, it is important to note that the dealership has no obligation to buy back the vehicle. The manufacturer, who provides the warranty, is responsible for addressing any issues that arise.

In some cases, the manufacturer may honor the buyer's request and offer a refund, a replacement vehicle, or a cash settlement. If the manufacturer denies the claim or the buyer is not satisfied with the proposed settlement, the buyer may need to hire a lawyer and file a lawsuit.

While dealerships have no obligation to buy back a defective vehicle, unethical dealers may use illegal means to conceal a vehicle's defects. Buyers who suspect they have been sold a lemon can take steps to protect themselves, such as keeping detailed records of any issues and repair attempts. It is important to research the specific lemon laws in your state and understand your rights as a consumer.

Lemon laws cover used vehicles in some states

Lemon laws, which exist in every state, protect consumers from being stuck with defective vehicles. While most lemons are new vehicles, some lemon laws also cover used vehicles.

In Michigan, for example, the Lemon Law applies to vehicles still "covered by a manufacturer's express warranty at the time of purchase or lease". The problem must be reported to the manufacturer or its authorised dealer within one year of the original buyer receiving the vehicle. If these criteria are met, the Lemon Law may apply to a "used" vehicle.

The federal Lemon Law, the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, also applies to used vehicles. It covers any consumer product that costs more than $10, including used vehicles that meet the Act's definition of a lemon. This means the defect must have been reported during the warranty period and must still exist after a reasonable number of repair attempts.

Some state lemon laws treat used vehicles in a similar manner, not distinguishing between new and used vehicles. Instead, these laws typically state that repair attempts must occur within a certain period after the original owner takes possession of the vehicle. However, some states specifically exclude used vehicles from protection under their Lemon Law.

So, if you buy a 10-year-old used car, your state's Lemon Law probably won't apply. But if your vehicle was still fairly new when purchased, there's a good chance it will qualify.

Lemon laws cover leased vehicles in most states

Lemon laws exist in all 50 US states, but the specifics vary from state to state. In California, for example, the lemon law is called the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, and it applies to both purchased and leased vehicles. This is also the case in most, if not all, other states.

California's lemon law is one of the most comprehensive and favourable to vehicle customers. It allows consumers to seek a replacement or reimbursement for defective vehicles that cannot be repaired within a reasonable number of attempts. The same criteria for a refund or replacement apply to both purchased and leased vehicles.

California's lemon law also covers small business leased vehicles if the vehicle has a serious defect, weighs less than 10,000 pounds, and the business leases fewer than five vehicles.

To be eligible for protection under California's lemon law, a leased vehicle must have had 3-4 repair visits for non-safety-related issues or two repair visits for safety-related issues.

If you have a leased vehicle that you believe to be a lemon, you can ask the manufacturer for a refund of your down payment, monthly lease payments, and remaining lease payments, or request a replacement vehicle. If the manufacturer refuses, you can sue for damages and keep the vehicle until they repurchase it, or request a cash settlement and keep the vehicle.

Lemon laws apply to vehicles with substantial defects

To qualify as a lemon under most state laws in the US, the vehicle must have a substantial defect covered by the warranty that occurs within a certain period of time or number of miles after purchase. Additionally, the defect must remain unfixed after a reasonable number of repair attempts. While the exact criteria vary by state, new vehicle lemon laws generally require that the manufacturer repurchase a vehicle with a significant defect that they are unable to repair within a reasonable amount of time. This typically involves allowing the dealer or manufacturer a certain number of repair attempts, usually around three to four, or having the vehicle remain in the shop for a specific number of days within a certain time frame.

It is worth noting that lemon laws do not cover all vehicle defects. Defects that are caused by owner negligence, accidents, or unauthorized repairs or alterations are generally not covered under lemon laws. Additionally, the defect must not be due to abuse or caused by the owner's use of the car.

Lemon laws are designed to protect consumers from defective vehicles and ensure that manufacturers honour their warranties. While the specific laws vary by state and country, lemon laws generally provide a remedy for purchasers of vehicles with repeated quality and performance issues.

Frequently asked questions