Moore's Law And Solar Cells: A Relevant Relationship?

Moore's Law states that the number of transistors on a computer chip will double every two years. This has led to exponential growth in computing power, with the amount of computing power you can buy for a dollar doubling roughly every 18 months. This has led to speculation about whether Moore's Law can be applied to other technologies, including solar cells.

In recent years, the price of solar energy has dropped significantly, and its efficiency has increased. This has led to speculation about a Moore's Law in solar energy. However, some commentators argue that Moore's Law does not apply to solar energy, as it is based on fundamental physics, while the cost declines in solar energy are driven by manufacturing scale and vertical integration.

Solar cell prices have dropped exponentially over the last 30 years

High-level mechanisms include the economies of scale achieved through increased production and larger manufacturing plants, as well as government policies and incentives that have stimulated market growth. The relative importance of these factors has changed over time, with government policies and incentives playing a more significant role earlier on, while economies of scale have become more prominent in recent years.

Low-level mechanisms include improvements in the underlying solar cell technology, such as increased "conversion efficiency," or the amount of power generated from a given amount of sunlight. This increase in efficiency means that a bigger percentage of sunshine can now be converted into power, making solar energy ultimately less expensive per watt. Additionally, advancements in manufacturing techniques, such as improved production processes and the availability of less expensive raw materials, have also played a crucial role in driving down costs.

The combination of these high-level and low-level mechanisms has led to an annual 7% reduction in the dollars per watt of solar photovoltaic cells over the last 30 years. This has resulted in solar energy becoming increasingly accessible and affordable for people, companies, and governments worldwide.

The benefits of this exponential price drop are far-reaching. Firstly, it has led to increased demand for solar panels and installations as more households and companies find solar energy within their financial reach. This, in turn, has resulted in the expansion of the solar sector, including job creation and expanded economies of scale. Secondly, the drop in solar panel prices has contributed to reduced carbon emissions as more people switch from fossil fuel-based electricity generation to solar energy, which is a clean and renewable source of energy. Finally, the switch to solar energy has improved air quality by removing the dangerous pollutants associated with traditional power generation methods, leading to cleaner and healthier habitats for both ecosystems and human populations.

Looking forward, the future of solar energy costs holds immense potential. With technological advancements, increased production, and supportive government initiatives, solar energy is expected to become even more widely available and affordable. As solar power continues to gain traction as a clean and sustainable source of energy, it has the potential to dominate the electricity market and play a pivotal role in shaping a greener and more sustainable future.

The cost of solar energy will decline to $1 per watt by 2017

The cost of solar energy has been declining over the years. In 2011, Ramez Naam observed that the price of solar energy had been dropping exponentially over the last 30 years. The National Renewable Energy Laboratory of the U.S. Department of Energy recorded a drop in the price per Watt of solar modules from $22 in 1980 to under $3 in 2011.

Naam also noted that the price reduction was driven by two factors: the learning curve of solar cell manufacturers in reducing fabrication costs, and the continuous improvement in the efficiency of solar cells. These trends led to a projected 7% annual reduction in the dollars per watt of solar photovoltaic cells.

However, it is important to distinguish the dynamics of Moore's law from those of the solar industry. Moore's law is a consequence of fundamental physics, where the cost per unit of computing power falls as the transistor becomes smaller, lighter, and faster. In contrast, the cost reductions in the solar industry are driven by manufacturing scale and vertical integration, rather than performance improvements.

Despite these differences, the cost of solar energy has continued to decline. In 2021, the National Renewable Energy Laboratory documented a sharp decline in costs over the last decade, largely due to increased module efficiency and lowered hardware and inverter costs. The cost of residential, commercial-rooftop, and utility-scale PV systems saw reductions of 64%, 69%, and 82% respectively since 2010.

The Department of Energy (DOE) has set ambitious targets to further reduce the cost of solar energy. In 2024, the DOE announced a goal to cut solar costs by more than half by 2030. This includes accelerating the utility-scale solar 2030 cost target by five years, aiming for a cost of 2 cents/kWh by 2030.

With these efforts, it is possible that the cost of solar energy will continue to decline, and the goal of $1 per watt by 2017 may have been achieved through similar mechanisms. However, it is important to note that the cost of solar energy is influenced by various factors, and the specific trajectory of cost reduction may vary.

Solar efficiency in labs has reached 41%, double that of 30 years ago

Solar efficiency has seen impressive improvements over the years, with lab efficiencies reaching 41%—a remarkable feat compared to 30 years ago. This progress has been compared to Moore's Law, which predicts that the number of transistors on an integrated circuit will double every two years, resulting in exponential growth in computing power. While solar technology has not followed this exact trajectory, its advancements are significant.

Moore's Law has been a guiding principle in the semiconductor industry, and some have wondered if it applies to solar cells. The law states that the number of transistors on a computer chip will double every two years, leading to exponential growth in computing power. While solar technology doesn't precisely follow this curve, its progress is impressive nonetheless.

In the context of solar cells, efficiency refers to the portion of sunlight energy that can be converted into electricity by a solar cell. This is a critical factor in determining the annual energy output of a photovoltaic system, along with factors like latitude and climate. The efficiency of solar cells has seen a notable increase over the years, with lab efficiencies reaching as high as 41%, according to Ramez Naam in a 2011 article for Scientific American. This is a substantial improvement compared to 30 years ago.

The advancements in solar efficiency have been compared to Moore's Law, but it's important to note that the dynamics are different. In solar energy, the price of capturing solar energy has dropped exponentially, and there is frequent talk of a "Moore's law" in this field. However, the specifics vary from the original Moore's Law.

The price per watt of solar modules has decreased significantly, and this trend is expected to continue. The National Renewable Energy Laboratory of the U.S. Department of Energy has observed a 7% annual reduction in the dollars per watt of solar photovoltaic cells over a 30-year period. This means that solar energy is becoming increasingly affordable and accessible.

The improvements in solar efficiency are driven by two main factors. Firstly, solar cell manufacturers are learning how to reduce fabrication costs, similar to the advancements in computer chip manufacturing. Secondly, the efficiency of solar cells is continually improving. While lab efficiencies have reached 41%, inexpensive thin-film methods have also achieved efficiencies of up to 20%, which is still twice as high as most deployed solar systems today.

The implications of these trends are promising for the future of solar energy. With continued advancements in efficiency and cost reductions, solar electricity is projected to become highly competitive with traditional energy sources. This progress aligns with the goal of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and transitioning to cleaner energy alternatives.

Swanson's Law: solar photovoltaic module prices drop 20% for each doubling of manufacturing volume

The price of solar energy has been dropping exponentially over the last 30 years. This has led to talk of a "Moore's law" in solar energy. In computing, Moore's law states that the number of transistors on a chip doubles every 18 months, leading to a doubling of the amount of computing power one can buy for a dollar every year and a half.

While Moore's law does not apply to solar energy, there is a similar concept known as Swanson's law, which states that solar photovoltaic module prices drop by 20% for each doubling of manufacturing volume. Swanson's law is named after Richard Swanson, the founder of SunPower, an American solar manufacturer. It is a solar industry-specific application of the more general Wright's law, which states that there will be a fixed cost reduction for each doubling of manufacturing volume.

The method used by Swanson is more commonly referred to as a learning curve or experience curve analysis. It was first developed and applied to the aeronautics industry in 1936 by Theodore Paul Wright and was first applied to the photovoltaics industry in 1975. Since then, the price of solar modules has dropped significantly. For example, crystalline silicon photovoltaic cell prices fell from $76.67 per watt in 1977 to $0.36 per watt in 2014, and the National Renewable Energy Laboratory of the U.S. Department of Energy has observed a drop in the price per watt of solar modules (not including installation) from $22 in 1980 to under $3 today.

The price drops observed in the solar industry are driven by two main factors. First, solar cell manufacturers are learning how to reduce fabrication costs, similar to computer chip manufacturers. Second, the efficiency of solar cells is continually improving. These trends suggest that solar energy will become an increasingly competitive source of energy in the future.

The experience curve: solar cost declines are due to experience and scale

The experience curve, or "learning curve", is a key factor in the decline of solar power costs. This curve illustrates the relationship between the decreasing cost of solar power and the increasing number of installations. As the price of solar drops, installations increase, and this in turn drives further price declines. This is due to a combination of experience and scale.

Experience plays a significant role in driving down costs. The more solar panels are manufactured, the more companies learn and develop improvements in industrial operations, installation procedures, and sales and financing processes. This is known as "learning by doing". Additionally, as companies or industries expand, they benefit from economies of scale, spreading fixed costs over a larger volume of product sales. Greater specialization within the industry can also contribute to cost reductions.

The learning factor is a measure of how quickly these changes take place. For example, a learning factor of 20% means that for each doubling of sales or installations, the price falls by approximately 20%. From 1976 to 2015, the learning factor for solar power was 21.5%, resulting in significant price declines over time.

The experience curve is further influenced by "learning by waiting", which involves harnessing spillover effects from other industries, technologies, or countries. For instance, improvements in lithium-ion batteries for laptops, tablets, and phones have benefited the development of electric vehicles.

While Moore's Law is not directly applicable to solar cells, the dynamics of exponential improvement are evident in the solar industry. Over the last 30 years, the price of solar energy has dropped exponentially, with a 7% average annual reduction in the dollars per watt of solar photovoltaic cells. This has been driven by advancements in fabrication techniques and improvements in cell efficiency.

The combination of experience, scale, and technological advancements in the solar industry has resulted in a downward trend in costs, making solar energy an increasingly attractive and viable option for energy generation.

Frequently asked questions