Utah's Abortion Laws: Triggering A New Wave Of Restrictions?

Utah's abortion trigger law has been the subject of intense debate and legal wrangling since the U.S. Supreme Court's Dobbs v. Jackson decision overturned Roe v. Wade, putting the question of abortion regulation in the hands of individual states. Utah's trigger law, enacted in 2020, bans abortion except in cases where the mother's life is at risk or there is a fatal fetal abnormality. In August 2023, the Utah Supreme Court heard arguments on whether to uphold a lower court's decision to block the law, with a ruling expected soon. The outcome will have significant implications for abortion access in the state, as it will determine whether abortion remains legal up to 18 weeks or is banned with limited exceptions.

Utah's trigger law banning most abortions was blocked by a district court in June 2022

In June 2022, a district court in Utah blocked the state's trigger law banning most abortions, allowing the procedure to be performed up to 18 weeks into a pregnancy. This ruling came just a few days after the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, which overturned Roe v. Wade and removed federal protection for abortion as a constitutional right.

Utah's trigger law, passed in 2020, would have prohibited abortions except in cases where the mother's life was at risk or when there was a fatal fetal abnormality. A separate law passed in 2021 permits abortions up to 18 weeks in cases of rape or incest.

The block on the trigger law was the result of legal action taken by Planned Parenthood Association of Utah, who argued that the law violated state constitutional rights to privacy, bodily integrity, and the determination of one's family composition. The Utah Supreme Court's decision to uphold the block was influenced by the state constitution's Article IV, Section 1, which states that "both male and female citizens of this State shall enjoy equally all civil, political and religious rights and privileges."

Camila Vega, a staff attorney for Planned Parenthood, emphasized that the founders of the state constitution "could not possibly have imagined a world where abortion is safe, legal, and routine." This perspective clashed with arguments from state attorneys, who asserted that the original public meaning of the state constitution, ratified in 1895, did not guarantee a right to abortion.

The ongoing legal battle over Utah's trigger law reflects the complex dynamics surrounding abortion rights in the United States, with courts, legislators, and advocacy groups actively shaping the landscape of abortion access across the nation.

The Utah Supreme Court is yet to rule on the constitutionality of the trigger law

In June 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, which had protected abortion as a constitutional right. This decision opened the door for states to ban abortion outright, and 14 states have since made abortion illegal. Utah is one of 13 states that enacted trigger laws, which are unenforceable until a specific change in circumstances occurs. In the case of Utah and the other 12 states, the trigger law would automatically ban abortion in the first and second trimesters if Roe v. Wade were overturned.

Utah's trigger law was enacted in 2020 and bans abortion with exceptions for maternal health threats or rape and incest reported to the police. Since Roe v. Wade was overturned in June 2022, abortion has been legal in Utah for up to 18 weeks of pregnancy. A separate law passed in 2023 bans abortion clinics in the state.

The Utah Supreme Court heard arguments on August 8, 2023, on whether to uphold a lower court's decision to put the 2020 state law on hold. The court is yet to rule on the constitutionality of the trigger law. The state's attorneys want the Utah Supreme Court to overrule the lower court's decision, arguing that the "original public meaning" of the state constitution drafted during the Mormon Pioneer era in 1895 didn't guarantee a right to abortion. On the other hand, Planned Parenthood, which provides the majority of abortions in the state, sued over the 2020 trigger law, arguing that the state's founders "could not possibly have imagined a world where abortion is safe, legal and routine."

The Utah Supreme Court's decision will determine whether abortion remains legal for up to 18 weeks of pregnancy or whether abortion will be banned in Utah for the foreseeable future, with limited exceptions. The court's ruling will have significant ramifications for people seeking abortion in the state, as well as for the broader debate around abortion rights and reproductive justice in the United States.

The trigger law would prohibit abortions except in cases of fatal foetal abnormality or when the mother's life is at risk

In June 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade gave states the power to restrict or prohibit abortion. Utah is one of 13 states that had trigger laws in place, which are laws that were previously unenforceable but became enforceable after the overturning of Roe v. Wade. Utah's trigger law, passed in 2020, bans abortion with exceptions for maternal health threats or cases of rape and incest reported to the police.

The Utah Supreme Court heard arguments on August 8, 2023, on whether to uphold a lower court's decision to block the state's trigger law. The lower court's hold on the law has allowed abortion to remain legal in Utah for up to 18 weeks of pregnancy. The trigger law, if allowed to take effect, would prohibit abortions except in cases where the mother's life is at risk or there is a fatal foetal abnormality.

The Utah Supreme Court's majority-women panel questioned the state's attorneys on the original meaning of the state's constitution and the extent of a person's right to make medical decisions. Attorneys for the state argued that abortion was restricted when the constitution was ratified in 1895, and thus, the court should not interpret the clause to include abortion rights. On the other hand, Planned Parenthood's staff attorney, Camila Vega, countered that the state's founders could not have foreseen a world where abortion is safe and legal.

The Utah Supreme Court is expected to decide whether to maintain the lower court's hold on the trigger law or allow it to take effect, making abortion illegal in the state except in limited circumstances. This decision will have significant implications for reproductive rights and access to abortion in Utah.

The trigger law was challenged by Planned Parenthood, which provides the majority of abortions in the state

The trigger law was challenged by Planned Parenthood Association of Utah, which provides the majority of abortions in the state. The lawsuit was filed in June 2022, shortly after the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization overturned Roe v. Wade.

Planned Parenthood argued that the trigger law violates the Utah Constitution, which protects pregnant Utahns' rights to determine when and whether to have a family, as well as what happens to their bodies, lives, and personal medical decisions. They also highlighted the narrow exceptions in the law, including the requirement for sexual assault survivors to disclose personal information to law enforcement to receive care.

The lawsuit aimed to prevent thousands of Utahns from being forced to carry unwanted or dangerous pregnancies to term or travel out of state for abortion care. It also sought to protect healthcare providers from criminalization and the threat of arrest and fines for providing abortion care.

Camila Vega, a staff attorney for Planned Parenthood, emphasized that the state's founders could not have foreseen a world where abortion is safe, legal, and routine. The legal challenge resulted in a district court blocking the trigger law in June 2022, allowing abortion to remain legal up to 18 weeks in Utah.

The Utah Supreme Court heard arguments in August 2023 on whether to uphold the lower court's decision. The court's majority-women panel expressed skepticism towards the state's claims that the lower court abused its power. They probed Utah's attorneys about the seriousness of Planned Parenthood's arguments and the interpretation of the state's constitution regarding abortion rights.

The outcome of the Utah Supreme Court's decision will have significant implications for abortion access in the state, with the potential for a near-total ban if the trigger law is upheld.

The trigger law is supported by anti-abortion advocates and Utah's Republican-controlled legislature

Utah's trigger law, which bans most abortions, is supported by anti-abortion advocates and Utah's Republican-controlled legislature. The law, which was passed in 2020, prohibits abortions except in cases where the mother's life is at risk or there is a fatal fetal abnormality. In cases of rape or incest, a separate law passed in 2023 allows abortions up to 17.6 weeks.

The trigger law is supported by anti-abortion advocates, who argue that it protects the rights of unborn children and aligns with the state's policy preference to ban abortion to the fullest extent of the law. They also argue that the original public meaning of the state constitution, drafted in 1895 during the Mormon Pioneer era, did not guarantee a right to abortion. Utah Eagle Forum President Gayle Ruzicka, an anti-abortion supporter, expressed confidence in the court's ability to rule fairly on the law, stating, "Babies will win. Babies always win. They overturned Roe, we can certainly win this."

The Republican-controlled legislature in Utah has also actively worked to implement the trigger law and make abortion harder to access. For example, a few months after an injunction was placed on the ban, GOP lawmakers sent cease-and-desist letters to abortion providers, threatening prosecution if they continued offering abortion care. Lawmakers also voted to submit an amicus brief opposing the injunction on the law and changed court rules to target the language used by the district court judge in stopping the trigger ban. Additionally, the legislature voted to ban abortion clinics in the state, which was later repealed to speed up a ruling in the overarching abortion ban lawsuit.

Utah's trigger law is currently being challenged in court by Planned Parenthood Association of Utah, which provides the majority of abortions in the state. They argue that access to abortion is essential for equal access to other rights, such as bodily autonomy and the right to determine the makeup of one's family. The Utah Supreme Court is currently weighing the lower court's decision to put the law on hold, and a ruling is expected soon.

Frequently asked questions