Abortion Law: Ethical, Legal, And Social Issues

Abortion laws are a highly divisive topic, with strong opinions on both sides of the debate. The issue of abortion laws concerns the right to life, which is considered the most important human right. While some believe that every mother has a universal right to abortion, others argue that abortion is equivalent to murder. In 1973, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that a person has a constitutional right to abortion until a fetus becomes viable, but this was overturned in 2022, giving individual states the power to make their own abortion laws. Since then, over a dozen states have banned abortion, with varying penalties for those who perform or assist with the procedure. These laws have faced legal challenges, with some being blocked, and have sparked protests from those who believe that abortion should be legal. The debate around abortion laws is an ongoing and deeply personal issue that continues to divide opinion.

The Hyde Amendment and federal abortion bans

The Hyde Amendment is a legislative provision in the United States that bars the use of federal funds to pay for abortions. It was first passed by Congress in 1977, four years after the Roe v. Wade Supreme Court decision, and has been re-enacted annually since 1976 with varying exceptions. The amendment prohibits federal funds from covering abortion services for individuals enrolled in Medicaid, Medicare, and the Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP). It is considered a discriminatory policy that has been included in annual spending bills, disproportionately affecting people of colour and those with low incomes.

The original Hyde Amendment, passed by the House of Representatives in 1976, was named for its chief sponsor, Republican Congressman Henry Hyde of Illinois. It represented a significant legislative victory for the anti-abortion movement in the US. The amendment blocks federal Medicaid funding for abortion services, with a few narrow exceptions: when the patient's life is endangered, or when the pregnancy is a result of rape or incest. This restriction applies even when a patient's health is at risk, and their doctor recommends an abortion.

The impact of the Hyde Amendment is far-reaching. It currently affects people in 34 states and the District of Columbia, leaving 7.8 million women aged 15-49 with Medicaid coverage but without abortion coverage. Half of those impacted are women of colour. The amendment has also led to related bans that withhold abortion coverage from individuals who obtain their health care through other federal programs, such as federal employees, military personnel, veterans, Native Americans, and people with low incomes in Washington, D.C.

The consequences of the Hyde Amendment are severe. On average, an abortion at 10 weeks costs around $550, which can be a significant financial burden for those with low incomes. Many individuals experience delays in obtaining abortion care due to the time and effort required to gather the necessary funds. As a result, people seeking abortions can find themselves in a cruel cycle, where delays lead to additional costs and further delays. The amendment has been criticised for disproportionately affecting low-income women, women of colour, younger women, and immigrants. Since its passage, more than one million women have been unable to afford abortions, and 18-33% of Medicaid-eligible women who desire abortions have given birth because they live in states that do not provide funding.

State-level abortion laws

Following the Supreme Court's overturning of Roe v. Wade in 2022, states have been given the power to impose any regulation on abortion, provided it does not conflict with federal law. This has resulted in a patchwork of abortion laws across the country, with some states banning abortion outright, while others have taken steps to protect abortion rights. As of August 31, 2023, 14 states had made abortion illegal, while 21 states and the District of Columbia protected the right to abortion.

The legality of abortion continues to be a highly contested issue, with citizen groups campaigning to get abortion measures on state ballots. As of October 2024, 10 states, including Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Maryland, Nevada, New York, South Dakota, Missouri, Montana, and Nebraska, will have measures to amend their constitutions to protect abortion rights. The specifics of these measures vary, with some states seeking to enshrine current abortion bans into their constitutions, while others aim to increase abortion access until fetal viability.

The state-level abortion laws are not uniform, and the legal status of abortion differs considerably from state to state. This lack of uniformity has resulted in a complex landscape of abortion rights and restrictions across the country, with citizens in different states having varying levels of access to abortion services.

Religious groups and anti-abortion activism

The anti-abortion movement in the United States is largely driven by religious groups, with the Catholic Church and Evangelical churches being the most prominent. The movement also includes secular organizations and non-mainstream anti-abortion feminists, but its association with religious groups is particularly notable. This influence extends to political parties, with the anti-abortion movement frequently, though not exclusively, allied with the Republican Party.

The Catholic Church, as the nation's largest denomination, staunchly opposes abortion in all circumstances. This position is shared by other significant religious groups, including the Southern Baptist Convention, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (Mormons), and the Assemblies of God, the largest Pentecostal denomination in the US. Hindu teaching also generally opposes abortion. These groups provide a substantial base of support for anti-abortion activism, often motivated by the belief that life begins at conception and that abortion is the taking of a human life.

The first major anti-abortion organization in the US, the National Right to Life Committee, was formed out of the Catholic Church in 1967. Since then, the movement has grown and diversified, with numerous other religious and secular organizations joining the cause. These include the American Life League, the Susan B. Anthony List, Americans United for Life, and Live Action, among many others. The movement is not centralized, with diverse arguments and rationales presented for the anti-abortion stance.

Some religious groups allow for certain exceptions to their opposition to abortion. For example, the Southern Baptist Convention permits abortion if the mother's life is in danger. Similarly, the National Association of Evangelicals recognizes that there may be situations where terminating a pregnancy is warranted, such as protecting the mother's life or in cases of rape or incest.

The influence of religious groups on anti-abortion activism extends beyond the US. In Antigua and Barbuda, religious groups, particularly the Evangelical Alliance, have opposed efforts to challenge colonial-era abortion laws that largely ban abortions. The Evangelical Alliance, representing 66 congregations from seven religious denominations, was granted the opportunity to be heard during a court case on the issue. This demonstrates the significant role that religious groups play in shaping abortion laws and activism globally.

The right to life and abortion

The issue of abortion laws has been a contentious topic for decades, with strong arguments on both sides of the debate. The right to life is a fundamental principle in the discussion surrounding abortion, and it can be approached from two distinct perspectives.

The Embryo's Right to Life

One viewpoint asserts that the embryo or foetus possesses the right to life from the moment of conception. This argument, often put forward by the anti-abortion movement, maintains that the embryo is a 'potential human being' with the same rights as an actual human being. It grants the unborn the right to life from the earliest stage of development, disregarding the concerns about the nature of the foetus during its developmental stages.

The Woman's Right to Life

On the other hand, the pro-choice movement emphasizes the woman's right to life and bodily autonomy. This perspective is particularly relevant in contexts where unsafe abortion practices pose a significant threat to women's lives, such as in certain parts of Africa. International human rights law offers two possible approaches to address unsafe abortion: advocating for the right to privacy, allowing women to make abortion decisions without state interference; or promoting the right to life of women, emphasizing the state's duty to minimize the consequences of unsafe abortions.

In Africa, the communal nature of societies emphasizes duty over individual privacy. The African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights reflects these values by underscoring the duty of individuals to support their communities. Advocates for women's rights argue that states have a responsibility to ensure women's right to life by addressing the legal, economic, and social causes of unsafe abortions. This includes providing access to safe and affordable abortion services, removing restrictive abortion laws, and educating the public about the consequences of unsafe abortion practices.

Global Abortion Laws

Abortion laws vary significantly across the globe. In the United States, the Supreme Court's Roe v. Wade decision in 1973 legalized abortion based on the right to privacy, but this was overturned in 2022, returning the decision to individual states. In Antigua and Barbuda, a colonial-era law largely bans abortions, and women who terminate their pregnancies can face up to 10 years in prison. In contrast, other countries like France have amended their laws to permit abortion on request during the first trimester of pregnancy.

The impact of abortion laws on low-income people

Abortion laws have a significant impact on low-income individuals, who are often disproportionately affected by restrictions and bans. According to a 2014 study by the Guttmacher Institute, 75% of women who seek abortions are considered low-income, with family incomes below or up to double the federal poverty level. This group of people often faces financial struggles when it comes to accessing abortion services.

The cost of an abortion procedure can be a significant burden for low-income individuals. The average cost of a first-trimester aspiration abortion is $508, while a medication abortion averages $535. A second-trimester abortion can cost more than $2,000. With the Supreme Court's reversal of Roe v. Wade, the cost of abortion is expected to increase further, especially for those living in states with strict abortion laws. The National Abortion Federation (NAF) notes that the cost of an abortion procedure can be influenced by factors such as travel expenses, childcare, transportation, and accommodations.

For example, in Alabama, where a total abortion ban is in place, the closest state offering legal abortions is Florida, which has a restrictive 15-week abortion law. The nearest state after that is Illinois, which is over 700 miles away. Travelling to Illinois for an abortion would require significant expenses for time off work, childcare, transportation, and accommodation, placing a heavy financial burden on low-income individuals and families.

The restrictions and bans on abortion disproportionately affect low-income individuals, pushing them further into financial instability and hardship. This vulnerable group often faces difficult decisions and struggles to access abortion services, highlighting the intersection of economic inequality and reproductive rights.

Frequently asked questions