Alcohol Laws: Post-Temperance Movement Stricter Regulations?

The temperance movement, which sought to curb alcohol consumption, had a significant influence on American politics and society in the 19th and 20th centuries. The movement was born with Benjamin Rush's 1784 tract, 'An Inquiry into the Effects of Ardent Spirits Upon the Human Body and Mind', which argued that excessive alcohol use was harmful to physical and psychological health. The temperance movement combined a concern for general social ills with religious sentiment and practical health considerations in a way that appealed to many middle-class reformers.

The movement split along two lines in the late 1830s: between moderates allowing some drinking and radicals demanding total abstinence, and between voluntarists relying on moral suasion alone and prohibitionists promoting laws to restrict or ban alcohol. Temperance eventually became synonymous with prohibition. In the 1850s, 13 states and territories passed statewide prohibitory laws.

The American Civil War dealt a blow to the movement, which petered out until it found new life in the 1870s. The second wave of the movement saw the rise of the prohibitionist Woman's Christian Temperance Union and the voluntarist Catholic Total Abstinence Union of America. The movement enlisted more religious support, especially from evangelicals.

The third wave of the movement saw the rise of the Anti-Saloon League, which successfully pushed for National Prohibition from its enactment in 1920 to its repeal in 1933. This wave attracted a diverse coalition, including doctors, pastors, eugenicists, Klansmen, liberal internationalists, business leaders, labour radicals, conservative evangelicals, and liberal theologians.

The Anti-Saloon League stressed political results and perfected the art of pressure politics. It did not demand that politicians change their drinking habits, only their votes in the legislature. The League's motto was the Church in action against the saloon.

The movement became more political, advocating the legal prohibition of all alcohol rather than calling for moderation. Proponents of temperance, teetotalism, and prohibition became known as the drys.

Today, there are organisations that continue to promote the cause of temperance, including the Woman's Christian Temperance Union, the Anti-Saloon League, and the Prohibition Party.

The Temperance Movement's roots in the 19th century

The Temperance Movement, which began in the early 1800s, was a social movement promoting abstinence from alcohol consumption. It was particularly prominent in English-speaking, Scandinavian, and majority Protestant countries, and it eventually led to national prohibitions in several countries.

Roots in the 19th Century

In the early 19th century, alcohol was a significant part of American culture and was consumed for various reasons. People drank alcohol due to contaminated water supplies, the belief that it was healthier than water, and its use as a form of payment for workers. Alcohol was also an integral part of social functions, from marriage ceremonies to elections.

During this period, drunkenness was not tolerated, and the Temperance Movement aimed to address the growing problem of excessive drinking. The movement initially advocated for moderation, but by the 1820s, it shifted towards promoting total abstinence from alcohol. This shift was influenced by the Second Great Awakening, a religious revival that emphasised individual choice and responsibility.

The movement was also driven by the belief that alcohol consumption had negative effects on people's health, personalities, and family lives. Leaders of the movement, such as Lyman Beecher, a Connecticut-born minister, described drunkenness as a "national sin" and suggested legislation to prohibit alcohol sales.

The early temperance societies were often associated with churches and had little influence beyond their local areas. However, the movement gained momentum and, by the 1830s, thousands of groups similar to the American Temperance Society had formed across the United States. These groups used methods such as public abstinence pledges, meetings, and pamphlets to spread their message.

The 1840s saw the rise of the Washingtonian movement, a group of artisans in Baltimore who promoted complete abstinence and used their own experiences to help others recover from alcohol addiction. Unlike earlier reformers, they did not view intemperance as a moral failing but believed that drunkards could be healed through sympathy and support.

By the mid-1850s, the movement had grown even further, with the emergence of organisations like the Young Men's Christian Association (YMCA) and the early Woman's Christian Temperance Union (WCTU). The movement became increasingly political, advocating for legal prohibition rather than just calling for moderation.

Legislative Successes and Failures

The temperance movement gained traction during the First World War, with President Wilson restricting alcohol sales in many combatant countries to preserve grain for food production. This period also saw the rise of influential groups like the Anti-Saloon League, which played a crucial role in the passage of the Eighteenth Amendment in 1920, introducing national prohibition in the United States.

However, the temperance movement faced challenges and opposition, particularly in urban areas with significant European immigrant communities. The enforcement of alcohol bans proved difficult and expensive, and illegal alcohol production and consumption rose, leading to the growth of criminal activities.

Legacy and Decline

The temperance movement had a significant impact on alcohol consumption, with a decrease of up to 50% between 1830 and 1840. It also contributed to the development of alternatives to alcohol, such as temperance fountains and temperance societies.

However, the movement faced criticism for creating unhealthy drinking habits, encouraging criminal activities, and negatively impacting the economy. By the 1930s, the movement was in decline, and national prohibition was repealed in 1933 with the ratification of the Twenty-first Amendment.

Despite this setback, the temperance movement continued to exist and evolved to address contemporary issues. Today, prominent temperance organisations, such as Mothers Against Drunk Driving and Alcohol Justice, focus on disseminating research on alcohol's effects on health, society, and the family.

The Temperance Movement's influence on the 18th and 20th centuries

The Temperance Movement of the 18th and 19th centuries was a social movement that promoted temperance or complete abstinence from alcohol consumption. The movement was particularly prominent in English-speaking, Scandinavian, and majority Protestant countries.

18th Century

In the 18th century, alcohol was a vital part of life in the American colonies. Drinking was widely accepted and integrated into society, but drunkenness was not tolerated. Hard cider was the primary alcoholic drink of the time, and settlement along the frontier often included a legal requirement to plant mature apple trees. In the late 18th century, attitudes towards alcohol in Great Britain became increasingly negative, largely due to the need for sober labourers to operate heavy machinery developed in the Industrial Revolution.

During this time, temperance societies began to form in Great Britain and the United States. These societies were typically religious groups that sponsored lectures, marches, and published tracts warning about the destructive consequences of alcohol. Temperance societies began to promote the virtues of abstinence or "teetotalism", and by the 1830s and 1840s, many societies in the US began asking people to sign "pledges" promising to abstain from all intoxicating beverages.

19th Century

In the early 19th century, alcohol was still regarded as a necessary part of the American diet, but overindulgence and intoxication became problems that often led to the disintegration of the family. The temperance movement in the US began at a national level in the 1820s, popularized by evangelical reformers and the middle classes. The movement promoted temperance and emphasised the moral, economical, and medical effects of overindulgence.

The Woman's Christian Temperance Union (WCTU) was founded in Ohio in 1874 and became the largest women's religious organisation in the 19th century. The WCTU spread across the nation, with local chapters largely autonomous but linked to the state and national organisation. The WCTU's watchwords were "Agitate – Educate – Legislate".

The temperance movement's first successes were on the local and state level, but their aspirations were national. The Prohibition Party, founded in 1869, played an important role in the push for a constitutional amendment banning the manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors. The Anti-Saloon League, founded in 1893, took over as the primary prohibition lobby in America. Led by Wayne Wheeler, the ASL pioneered the use of "pressure politics", using media, publications, and behind-the-scenes influence to persuade politicians that the public demanded action.

The temperance movement gained traction during World War I, with President Wilson issuing sharp restrictions on the sale of alcohol in many combatant countries. The movement became more political, with proponents of temperance, teetotalism, and prohibition becoming known as the "drys". The Eighteenth Amendment was passed by Congress in 1917, ratified in 1919, and went into effect in 1920, introducing prohibition in the US.

Influence

The temperance movement influenced society in several ways. It promoted alcohol education and demanded the passage of new laws against the sale of alcohol. It also encouraged the formation of alternatives to public bars, such as the Independent Order of Rechabites. The movement was further influenced by and tied to the women's suffrage movement, with prominent suffragists like Susan B. Anthony supporting prohibition. The movement also contributed to the formation of new Christian denominations, such as the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, which established criteria for healthy living, including temperance.

The Temperance Movement's focus on alcohol's negative impact on health

The Temperance Movement was a social movement that gained momentum in the 19th and early 20th centuries. It sought to curb or outlaw the consumption of alcoholic beverages, emphasising alcohol's negative impact on health, personalities, and family lives.

The movement was driven by a desire to improve individual and societal well-being through the elimination of the perceived negative effects of alcohol abuse. It was closely tied to the Second Great Awakening, a period of religious revivalism that emphasised individual moral reform and social betterment.

The Temperance Movement promoted alcohol education and demanded new laws against the sale of alcohol. It was particularly prominent in English-speaking, Scandinavian, and majority Protestant countries, eventually leading to national prohibitions in Canada, Norway, Finland, the United States, and India.

The movement's leaders, such as Benjamin Rush, a physician and signer of the Declaration of Independence, played a crucial role in shaping public opinion. Rush envisioned a disease-like syndrome caused by excessive drinking and cited abstinence as the only treatment. He also noticed the correlation between drunkenness and disease, death, suicide, and crime.

The Women's Christian Temperance Union (WCTU) was a key organisation in the Temperance Movement. It used grassroots activism and political lobbying to promote alcohol abstinence and women's suffrage.

The Temperance Movement's efforts culminated in the ratification of the 18th Amendment in the United States, which prohibited the production, importation, transportation, and sale of alcoholic beverages from 1920 to 1933.

The Temperance Movement's influence on women's rights

The Temperance Movement was a social movement that promoted abstinence from alcohol. It was particularly prominent in English-speaking, Scandinavian, and majority Protestant countries during the 19th and early 20th centuries. The movement was driven by the belief that alcohol negatively impacted people's health, personalities, and family lives.

The movement was closely associated with the women's suffrage movement, with many activists believing that the two issues were linked. Women were especially vulnerable to the negative impacts of alcohol abuse by men, as they had little economic and political power. The Woman's Christian Temperance Union (WCTU), founded in 1874, became the largest women's organisation in the US by the late 19th century. WCTU leaders like Frances Willard and Frances Ellen Watkins Harper argued that women needed to win the right to vote and enact alcohol prohibition to break the power of the "liquor traffic". WCTU members formed the grassroots of the suffrage movement for many years.

The temperance movement was also associated with the abolitionist movement, with temperance activists believing that alcohol was a "twin oppressor" of people alongside slavery.

The Temperance Movement's influence on the Prohibition Era

The Temperance Movement was a social movement that promoted abstinence from alcohol consumption. It was rooted in America's Protestant churches and first urged moderation before encouraging drinkers to help each other resist temptation and, ultimately, demanding that local, state, and national governments prohibit alcohol outright.

The movement was particularly prominent in the 1830s and 1840s, when it was intertwined with the abolitionist movement to rid the country of slavery. The Temperance Movement was also associated with the women's suffrage movement, with women protesting and organizing politically for the cause of temperance.

The Temperance Movement was responsible for the Eighteenth Amendment, which prohibited the manufacture, sale, and transportation of intoxicating liquors. The Eighteenth Amendment was ratified in 1919 and went into effect in 1920.

Frequently asked questions