The German Lawmaking Process: How Bills Become Laws

In Germany, the process of turning a bill into a law involves several stages of drafting, revision, and approval by various legislative bodies. The German Bundestag, the country's parliament, is responsible for debating and adopting laws, with the participation of the Bundesrat before it is signed into law by the Federal President.

The process begins with the introduction of a bill, which can be initiated by members of the German Bundestag, the Federal Government, or the Bundesrat. The Federal Government, composed of ministries responsible for various state and societal areas, usually takes the lead in drafting bills, often based on its political agenda presented at the start of each electoral term. However, the Bundesrat, which represents the federal states, and other entities like local authorities and interest groups, can also propose bills or request amendments to existing laws.

Once a bill is introduced, it undergoes scrutiny and debate in the Bundestag, with input from relevant committees and subcommittees. The bill is then voted on by the full chamber. If approved, it is referred to the other chamber, the Bundesrat, which can accept, reject, or amend it. If discrepancies exist between the two chambers' versions, a conference committee may be formed to reach a consensus.

After both chambers approve an identical version of the bill, it is sent to the Federal President for approval and signing into law. The Federal President examines the bill's constitutionality before signing and promulgating it in the Federal Law Gazette.

This process ensures that laws in Germany are carefully considered and reflect the interests of various stakeholders, ultimately shaping the rules that govern the country's society.

The Federal Government drafts the bill

The Federal Government drafts most new legislation in Germany. The Federal Government is structured to correspond with the most important areas of the state and society, with each ministry responsible for a major field. Each ministry is divided into directorates-general, directorates and divisions, with each division responsible for a specific field.

The Federal Government may be prompted to draft a bill by its own government programme, which is presented at the beginning of each electoral term and lists the government's main political projects for the next four years. The administration itself may also initiate the drafting of a bill, for example, if difficulties constantly arise in implementing a specific provision or if the costs involved are unexpectedly high.

The Länder, which are responsible for implementing federal laws, may also request amendments or submit a fully formulated draft law. This may occur if the cost of implementing a provision is unexpectedly high or if a provision is particularly burdensome for the finances of municipalities.

Associations of trade and industry and interest groups may also assert their members' need for amending legislation. Or it may be a petition submitted to the Petitions Committee that draws attention to the need for action.

In line with the basic relationship between the parliamentary majority and the government in a parliamentary system, the majority parliamentary groups in the Bundestag may also wish to amend a law and take a political decision to this effect. In such cases, the government or the relevant ministry is instructed to prepare a draft.

The heads of divisions in the ministries are specialists who are involved at all stages of the proceedings. They evaluate correspondence from citizens and organisations, follow the rulings handed down by the courts, and study specialist literature. They are in contact with colleagues responsible for the relevant area in Land ministries and local authorities and generally keep informed about developments in the field concerned. This means they have the specialist knowledge required to carry out the task of drawing up a draft bill.

The bill is introduced to the Bundestag

The Bundestag is the German parliament, and it is here that bills are debated and adopted. The Bundestag is Germany's most important democratic forum.

The bill must first be transmitted to the President of the German Bundestag, then registered and printed by the Administration. It is then distributed to all members of the Bundestag, the Bundesrat, and the federal ministries as a Bundestag printed paper. Once this is done, the bill is ready to be introduced into the public forum of the Bundestag.

The bill is then debated three times in the plenary of the Bundestag. These debates are known as readings. During the first reading, a debate is only held if this has been agreed upon in the Council of Elders or demanded by one of the parliamentary groups. The first reading's primary goal is to designate one or several committees that will consider the bill and prepare it for its second reading.

The detailed work on the bill takes place in the permanent committees, which are made up of members from all the parliamentary groups. The committee members familiarise themselves with the material and deliberate on it at their meetings. They can also invite representatives of interest groups and experts to public hearings. In parallel, the parliamentary groups form working groups to examine the issues and define their own positions.

The committee with overall responsibility for the bill then presents the plenary with a report on the course and results of its deliberations. This report forms the basis for the second reading in the plenary. Before this, all members receive the published recommendation for a decision in printed form, and the parliamentary groups coordinate their positions. Following the general debate, all the provisions set out in the bill may be considered individually. As a rule, however, the plenary moves directly to a vote on the bill as a whole.

Any member of the Bundestag may table motions for amendments, which are then dealt with immediately in the plenary. If amendments are adopted, the new version of the bill must be printed and distributed. However, this procedure may be abbreviated with the consent of two-thirds of the members present.

The bill is sent to a committee

Once a bill has been introduced, it is sent to a committee. Both the House and Senate have various committees composed of groups of Congress members who are particularly interested in different topics such as health or international affairs. When a bill is in the hands of the committee, it is carefully examined and its chances of passage by the entire Congress are determined. The committee may even choose to hold hearings to better understand the implications of the bill. Hearings allow the views of the executive branch, experts, other public officials, and supporters and opponents of the legislation to be put on record. If the committee does not act on a bill, the bill is considered to be "dead".

In Germany, the committees are made up of members from all the parliamentary groups. They familiarise themselves with the material and deliberate on it at their meetings. They are also able to invite representatives of interest groups and experts to public hearings. In parallel to the work done by the committees, the parliamentary groups form working groups, in which they examine the issues concerned and define their own positions.

It is not unusual for bridges to be built between the parliamentary groups in the committees. Most bills are revised to a greater or lesser extent as a result of collaboration between the governing and opposition parliamentary groups.

The committee may hold hearings

The German Bundestag, the country's parliament, is responsible for passing laws at the federal level. The legislative process begins with the introduction of a bill, which can be initiated by members of the Bundestag, the Federal Government, or the Bundesrat. The Bundesrat is a body that represents the federal states (Länder) and plays a crucial role in the legislative process.

Once a bill is introduced, it is referred to a committee for review and discussion. These committees are made up of members from all parliamentary groups, who carefully examine the bill and may invite experts and representatives of interest groups to public hearings. The committee's detailed work on the bill includes familiarizing themselves with the material, deliberating on it, and making revisions.

During the committee hearings, members will evaluate the potential impact of the bill and consider the perspectives of various stakeholders. They will also assess the bill's compatibility with existing legislation and the Basic Law, which is Germany's constitution. The committee hearings are a vital part of the legislative process, ensuring that the bill is thoroughly vetted and amended as needed before moving forward.

If the committee does not act on a bill or fails to reach an agreement, the bill is considered dead and will not proceed further in the legislative process. On the other hand, if the committee approves the bill, it will be reported to the floor of the Bundestag for further debate and a vote.

The bill is sent to a subcommittee

Once a bill is introduced, it is sent to a committee, which is then often referred to a subcommittee. Subcommittees are organised under committees and have further specialisation on a certain topic. The subcommittee may make changes to the bill and must vote to refer a bill back to the full committee.

The subcommittee is made up of specialists who are involved at all stages of the proceedings. They evaluate correspondence from citizens and organisations to the ministry, follow the rulings handed down by the courts and study specialist literature. They are in contact with colleagues responsible for the relevant area in Land ministries and local authorities and generally keep informed about developments in the field concerned. This means they have the specialist knowledge which enables them to carry out the task of making changes to the bill.

If the subcommittee votes in favour of the bill, it is reported to the full committee. This procedure is called "ordering a bill reported".

Frequently asked questions