Understanding The Legislative Process: A Scholastic Simulation

Teaching students about the legislative process and how a bill becomes a law can be challenging. However, Scholastic's Easy Simulations: How a Bill Becomes a Law provides an engaging solution for educators. This resource offers a weeklong, interactive simulation that mirrors the real-world process of lawmaking. Students are encouraged to brainstorm school issues, form committees, draft and present bills, and ultimately vote on them, emulating the steps taken by Congress. This hands-on approach enhances their understanding of the legislative branch, parliamentary procedures, and the dynamics of governance. The simulation includes reproducible worksheets, primary sources, and clear directions, making it accessible for grades 4 through 8. By participating in this immersive activity, students not only gain valuable knowledge about the inner workings of government but also get a chance to propose and enact meaningful changes within their school community.

Students form committees, write, present, and revise bills

To begin, students are divided into committees, each tasked with brainstorming and drafting a bill. They collaborate as a group to address an issue or propose a new rule for their school, community, or state. This process involves discussing and debating ideas, considering different perspectives, and reaching a consensus within their committee.

Once a bill is drafted, each committee presents it to their classmates or the wider student body, who act as Congress. The presenting committee must clearly articulate the purpose and expected outcomes of their bill, seeking support and feedback from their audience. This presentation is an important step in the legislative process, as it brings transparency and allows for input from the wider community.

Following the presentation, the student body or classmates, acting as Congress, engage in a debate on the bill. This involves discussing the merits and potential impacts of the proposed legislation, raising concerns, and suggesting amendments. The committee presenting the bill must be prepared to answer questions, defend their ideas, and consider revisions based on the feedback received.

After the debate, the bill undergoes a revision process. The committee reviews the feedback and suggestions from the congressional debate and makes necessary amendments to their bill. This step ensures that the bill is refined, taking into account the input of various stakeholders, and increasing the likelihood of its passage.

By forming committees, writing, presenting, and revising bills, students not only gain a deeper understanding of the legislative process but also develop essential skills such as critical thinking, collaboration, and persuasive communication. They learn about the complexities of lawmaking and the importance of compromise and consensus-building.

Students vote on bills, following the steps Congress takes to enact a law

First, students work in groups (committees) to draft and propose a law. They then present their law to their classmates, who act as Congress. Each student takes on the role of a real congressperson from a state in the USA. They present their bill and debate bills from other committees.

Next, students vote on the bills in a congressional meeting. Before the vote, they will need to address the concerns of voters and concerned citizens, as well as the teacher, who acts as the President.

This activity can be extended to a student-centred project that takes up the final couple of weeks of school. The students do most of the work in class, and their grade is based on participation and completion.

Students learn about the legislative branch and lawmaking process

One such simulation involves students working in groups to draft and propose laws. They present their proposed laws to their classmates, who act as Congress. This activity allows students to experience the process of drafting, presenting, debating, and voting on a bill as it goes through the steps to become a law. It also helps them understand the role of a congressperson and the importance of addressing the concerns of voters and citizens.

In another simulation, students are assigned a state to represent in the House of Representatives and are given a bill to work on. They examine data about their district, messages from constituents, and media coverage to make informed decisions. This activity provides a comprehensive understanding of the functions and impact of the legislative branch.

The "How a Bill Becomes a Law" simulation by Mister Harms is also a popular choice for teachers. In this simulation, students participate in writing bills for their school, community, or state, learning the various stages of the lawmaking process. They get to experience committee discussions, floor debates, and the signing of the bill by the President. This simulation has led to real-life changes in some schools, with administrators adopting feasible student-proposed bills.

Through these scholastic simulations, students gain firsthand knowledge of the legislative branch and the lawmaking process. They develop a deeper understanding of how their government works and the importance of each step in turning a bill into a law.

Students participate in a hands-on experience, demystifying the inner workings of government

The simulation begins with students brainstorming real school issues and forming committees. They then write, present, and revise bills, following the same steps that Congress takes to enact a bill. Each student becomes a member of Congress, with a chance to contribute their ideas and participate in committee discussions. They will debate on the house/senate floor and some will even get to watch their bills signed by the President.

This activity is designed to be fun and memorable, with students taking on the roles of real congresspeople from different states. They will present their bills and debate with other committees, before voting in a mock congressional meeting. The simulation can be adapted to suit different timeframes and grade levels, with step-by-step directions provided to ensure a smooth and engaging experience for all participants.

Through this immersive experience, students will gain a comprehensive understanding of the legislative branch, exploring the intricacies of lawmaking, committee meetings, and parliamentary procedures. They will also have the opportunity to see their ideas come to life, with some schools implementing the most feasible student-proposed bills as actual school policies.

Students learn about the various stages within the lawmaking process

In one simulation, students are divided into subcommittees and given an issue to address based on a handout. Each group must come to a solution, and then the class is divided into the Senate and House of Representatives to write and pass a bill. This activity helps students understand committees, conference committees, bill writing, and the role of the President.

Another simulation sees students work in groups to create, propose, and pass laws. They observe first-hand the difficulty in creating "good" laws, justifying those laws, and garnering enough votes to pass them. This activity provides a practical and engaging addition to the classroom, making the learning process interactive and relevant.

In a week-long simulation, students form committees, write, present, and revise bills, and then vote on them, following the same steps as Congress. This activity includes step-by-step directions, reproducible student worksheets, primary sources, and rubrics.

Frequently asked questions