Islamic Law Punishments: Understanding The Harsh Consequences

Islamic law, or Sharia, is the ideal form of divine guidance that Muslims follow to live a righteous life. Sharia is derived from two main sources: the Quran, which is considered the direct word of God, and hadith—thousands of sayings and practices attributed to the Prophet Mohammed. Islamic law provides for both mandatory and discretionary sentences that are individualized, applied equally to all, and consistent with the law. Islamic law divides crime into three categories: Hudud, Qesas, and Ta'azir. Crimes against God, or Hudud, are considered the most serious offences under Sharia law and are punished by death, amputation, stoning, lashing, and crucifixion.

Punishments for crimes against God

Islamic law, or Sharia, divides crimes into three categories: Hudud, Qesas, and Ta'zir. Hudud are crimes "against God", and are considered the most serious offences under Sharia law. The punishments for these crimes are fixed in the Quran and the Hadiths (sayings and practices attributed to the Prophet Muhammad).

Hudud crimes include:

• Apostasy (leaving Islam to become an atheist or convert to another religion)
• Fasad (mischief in the land, moral corruption against Allah, social disturbance, and creating disorder within the Muslim state)
• Zina (consensual heterosexual or homosexual relations not allowed by Islam, specifically pre-marital or extramarital)
• Banditry (highway robbery)
• Adultery
• Blasphemy
• Witchcraft
• Murder
• Rape
• Publishing pornography
• Homosexuality
• Unfounded accusations of zina (unlawful sexual intercourse)
• Consuming intoxicants
• Some forms of theft

Punishments for Hudud crimes are harsh and often involve capital punishment or physical torture. These include:

• Execution
• Crucifixion
• Amputation of hands and/or feet
• Exile
• Stoning
• Lashing
• Beheading

In addition to these punishments, the Quran also mentions the principle of Qesas, or "an eye for an eye", which allows the victim or their nearest relative to exact revenge that is equal to the harm done to them. However, the state supervises all punishment to ensure that it is not harsher than intended, and torture is prohibited.

Punishments for crimes against man

Islamic law, or Sharia, divides crime into three categories: Hudud, Qesas, and Ta'zir.

Hudud are acts considered crimes against God and are punished by defined mandatory penalties. These include:

• Apostasy
• Fasad (moral corruption against Allah, social disturbance, and creating disorder within the Muslim state)
• Zina (consensual heterosexual or homosexual relations not allowed by Islam, specifically pre-marital or extramarital)
• Murder
• Rape
• Adultery
• Witchcraft
• Banditry
• Homosexuality
• Publishing pornography

Hudud crimes are considered the most serious offences under Sharia law and are punishable by death.

Qesas crimes are those for which the Quran and Sunnah specify a punishment, but the decision to inflict it rests with the victim's closest kin as the avenger of the physical harm done to the victim. This type of offence is regarded as a civil injury rather than a technical crime, as only the victim or their family has the right to prosecute and opt for compensation or blood money (diyah) instead of retaliation. Qesas allows for the death penalty in cases of intentional or unintentional murder.

Ta'zir crimes are those for which there are no specified penalties in the Quran or Sunnah, and the judge has discretion in sentencing. Ta'zir punishments may take into account factors such as the offender's character and the circumstances of the offence.

In addition to these three categories, Islamic law also provides for discretionary punishments that are individualized, applied equally to all, and consistent with the law. The law also provides for the protection of the rights of the offender, and compensation for any unjust injury caused by errors in the execution of punishment.

Homicide

Homicide, or murder, is considered a civil injury in Islamic law, and the victim's family has the right to prosecute and opt for compensation or blood money (diyah) instead of retaliation (qiṣāṣ). The state supervises all punishment, even when applied by the victim's kin, to ensure it is not harsher than intended.

Assault

Assault is also considered a civil injury, and the victim or their family has the right to choose between retaliation and compensation.

Theft

Theft is one of the four offences for which the Quran specifies a punishment. The punishment for theft in Islamic law is the amputation of the hand. However, this punishment is not given for pilfering or stealing food or other edible items. Minors, the insane, and those who steal by force or deception are also exempt from this punishment.

Robbery

Robbery is considered a Hudud crime and is punishable by the amputation of the hand and foot.

Slander

Slander, specifically imputing unchastity to women, is punishable by eighty lashes.

Drunkenness

Drunkenness is punishable by eighty lashes.

Adultery

Adultery committed by married persons is punishable by death by stoning. For unmarried persons, the punishment is one hundred lashes and exile for one year.

It is important to note that Islamic law emphasizes the importance of evidence and intent when determining criminal liability. The standard of evidence required is strict, and acts committed in ignorance or without adequate knowledge are pardonable.

Corporal punishment

In the case of children, Islamic scholars generally advise against physical punishment, as it can have negative effects on their development and well-being. Instead, they recommend using love, affection, and patience in their upbringing. However, some Islamic texts do allow for physical punishment as a last resort, with conditions such as not hitting the face, limiting the number of strikes, and not causing damage to the skin or breaking bones.

In some Muslim-majority countries, corporal punishment is still practised for certain crimes. For example, flogging is still conducted in Indonesia, Iran, the Maldives, and Qatar, and amputation for theft has been carried out in Iran, Mauritania, Nigeria, Saudi Arabia, and Sudan. However, there is often local and international backlash against such sentences, and most Muslim-majority countries do not administer physical punishments.

Capital punishment

Hudud are acts prohibited by God and punished with defined mandatory penalties. These crimes are considered the most serious under Sharia law, and include banditry, adultery, and consensual heterosexual or homosexual relations not allowed by Islam. The punishment for these crimes is often death by stoning, which is controversial for being a cruel form of capital punishment. However, extensive evidentiary thresholds must be met for such punishments, and they are largely meant to serve as a deterrent.

Qesas crimes are those that have a specified punishment in the Quran and Sunnah, with the decision to inflict it resting with the victim's closest kin as the avenger of the physical harm done to the victim. This includes intentional or unintentional murder, where Sharia permits capital punishment. In the case of death, Sharia gives the murder victim's nearest relative or Wali (ولي) the right to take the life of the killer, if the court approves.

Ta'azir crimes are those for which there are no specified penalties in the Quran or Sunnah, and the judge is given discretion in sentencing. These include theft, blasphemy, and adultery, which are considered crimes against God.

Methods of execution in Islamic countries can include beheading, firing squad, hanging, and stoning. In some countries, public executions are carried out to heighten the element of deterrence. While Islam accepts capital punishment, forgiveness is preferable, and the court is fully able to impose more lenient sentences.

Rehabilitation and deterrence

Islamic law, or Sharia, divides crime into three categories: Hudud, Qesas, and Ta'azir. While punishment is intended to carry a punitive element, there is an emphasis on the rehabilitation of the offender in Islamic law.

Hudud crimes are acts prohibited by God and punished by defined mandatory penalties. These are considered the most serious offences under Sharia law, and include crimes against God, such as banditry, adultery, and apostasy. Punishments are prescribed in the Quran and range from public lashing to stoning and amputation.

Qesas crimes have a specified punishment in the Quran and Sunnah, with the decision to inflict it resting with the victim's closest kin as the avenger of the harm done to the victim. The state supervises all punishment to ensure it is not harsher than intended, and torture is prohibited.

Ta'azir crimes are those for which there are no specified penalties in the Quran or Sunnah, and the judge is given discretion in sentencing. This may take into account factors such as the offender's character and the circumstances of the offence.

Islamic law provides for both mandatory and discretionary sentences, and there is an emphasis on the rehabilitation of the offender. Punishments are intended to carry a punitive element that will deter recidivism and potential offenders. Rehabilitation and deterrence are key principles in Islamic law, with the aim of protecting the rights of the offender and ensuring that punishment is not harsher than intended.

Frequently asked questions