Flint, Michigan: A Case Of Criminal Negligence

In 2014, Flint, Michigan, was governed by a state-imposed emergency manager who decided to switch the city's water source from Detroit to the Flint River. This was done to save money, but it ended up costing many residents their health and even their lives. The water from the Flint River was highly corrosive, and officials failed to treat it properly, leading to lead leaching out from aging pipes into thousands of homes. This resulted in dangerous levels of lead in the water, which is especially harmful to children and can cause reduced IQ, physical growth, and behavioural problems.

The crisis was a result of simultaneous failures of federal drinking water standards and Michigan's emergency manager law, which allowed state-appointed officials to make decisions about the city's water supply without democratic input. The Michigan Civil Rights Commission concluded that the poor governmental response to the crisis was a result of systemic racism, as Flint's population is predominantly Black and about one-third live below the poverty line.

The crisis led to several lawsuits, the resignation of officials, and criminal charges, including against former Governor Rick Snyder. However, most of the charges were dropped, and no individuals in power have faced criminal penalties. Residents of Flint continue to fight for clean, affordable water and accountability from companies and government officials.

The decision to switch Flint's water supply

In April 2014, Flint, Michigan, switched its drinking water supply from Detroit's system to the Flint River in a cost-saving move. This decision was made by Darnell Earley, the state-appointed emergency manager of Flint, who was tasked with cutting city costs.

The switch to the Flint River was intended to be a temporary measure until a new water pipeline from Lake Huron could be built. However, the river water was highly corrosive, and Flint officials failed to treat it properly. As a result, lead leached out from aging pipes into thousands of homes.

Almost immediately after the switch, residents started complaining about the water's foul taste, smell, and appearance. Despite these protests, officials maintained that the water was safe. It wasn't until March 2015 that a test of the drinking water in one Flint home uncovered lead concentrations more than 25 times higher than the level deemed actionable by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Subsequent testing found lead levels that far exceeded the EPA's criteria for classifying water as hazardous waste.

The inadequate treatment and testing of the water resulted in a series of major water quality and health issues for Flint residents. The contaminated water was found to be contributing to a doubling—and in some cases, tripling—of the incidence of elevated blood lead levels in the city's children, putting their health at risk.

The switch from Detroit water to the Flint River also coincided with an outbreak of Legionnaires' disease, a severe form of pneumonia, which killed 12 people and sickened at least 87 others between June 2014 and October 2015. The failure to maintain sufficient chlorine levels in the water supply was likely a contributing factor in this outbreak.

The crisis in Flint was a result of simultaneous failures of the federal Safe Drinking Water Act and Michigan's Local Financial Stability and Choice Act, which provided purely technical solutions without addressing the complex social and political issues involved. The emergency manager law, in particular, allowed state-appointed officials to make decisions about the city's water supplies and treatment protocols without input from local residents.

The road to recovery

In March 2015, Flint voted to switch back to the Detroit water supply, and this transition was completed in October 2015. However, the damage to Flint's water supply infrastructure had already been done, and officials advised against drinking Flint water even after the switch.

The crisis led to a series of lawsuits and criminal charges against state and local officials. In 2017, a major settlement was reached, requiring the city to replace its lead pipes with funding from the state and providing for comprehensive tap water testing, a faucet filter installation, and health programs for residents.

As of April 2024, nearly 10 years after the initial switch to the Flint River, the work of identifying and replacing lead service lines is still ongoing, and the city has failed to meet its court-ordered deadlines. The slow pace of progress has drawn criticism and led to multiple court battles.

A legacy of distrust

The Flint water crisis has left a lasting impact on the community, with many residents still distrustful of government assurances about water safety. The crisis also highlighted systemic inequality and environmental racism, as Flint's poor, largely African American population bore the brunt of the health risks and received inadequate protection from environmental and health hazards.

The crisis in Flint served as a wake-up call for the need to invest in and upgrade aging water infrastructure across the country and to address the marginalizing effects of infrastructure underinvestment and urban austerity measures. It also sparked a national conversation about the right to clean drinking water and the need for stronger government oversight and accountability.

Inadequate treatment of the Flint River water

The Flint water crisis was a public health crisis that occurred in the city of Flint, Michigan, in the 2010s. It involved the contamination of the city's drinking water supply with lead and possibly Legionella bacteria. The crisis began in April 2014 when, during a financial crisis, the state-appointed emergency manager, Darnell Earley, changed Flint's water source from the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department (sourced from Lake Huron and the Detroit River) to the Flint River. This decision was made to save the city about $5 million over two years.

The Flint River water was highly corrosive, and Flint officials failed to treat it properly, which resulted in lead leaching from aging pipes into the water supply. This exposed around 100,000 residents to elevated lead levels, with children being particularly at risk from the long-term effects of lead poisoning. The inadequate treatment of the Flint River water also coincided with an outbreak of Legionnaires' disease, a severe form of pneumonia, which killed 12 people and affected at least 87 others between June 2014 and October 2015.

The inadequate treatment of the Flint River water resulted from several factors, including the failure to apply corrosion inhibitors and the omission of orthophosphate treatments, which are usually used to prevent pipe corrosion. The use of corrosive chemicals to decontaminate the river water further contributed to the problem by sending lead from the city's pipes into residents' faucets. Additionally, there was a lack of staffing and monitoring plans at the water treatment plant, and chlorination after filtration was not used until May 2014.

The consequences of the inadequate treatment of the Flint River water were severe and far-reaching. The elevated lead levels in the water supply had a profound impact on the health and well-being of Flint residents, particularly children, who are more vulnerable to the effects of lead poisoning. The crisis also had a significant impact on the level of trust within the community and the state and led to a decline in the city's population and economy.

In response to the crisis, there were resignations and criminal charges against government officials, and a settlement was reached to provide compensation to the victims. Efforts were also made to replace lead service pipes and improve water treatment processes. However, the crisis highlighted the need for stronger regulatory oversight and raised concerns about environmental racism, as Flint has a predominantly African American and economically disadvantaged community.

Lead leaching from aging pipes

The Flint water crisis was a public health crisis that occurred in Flint, Michigan, in the 2010s. It involved the contamination of the city's drinking water supply with lead and possibly Legionella bacteria. The crisis began in April 2014 when the city switched its water source from Lake Huron to the Flint River to save money during a financial crisis. This change in water source resulted in lead leaching from aging pipes into the water supply, exposing residents to elevated lead levels.

The lack of corrosion control in the pipes caused lead to leach into the water supply, affecting tens of thousands of residents. The corrosive water from the Flint River caused lead to be released from the aging pipes, which had a detrimental impact on the health of Flint's residents, particularly children.

The problem of lead leaching from aging pipes was exacerbated by the absence of corrosion inhibitors in the water. Officials failed to apply these inhibitors, which would have helped to prevent lead from leaching into the water supply. This oversight resulted in elevated lead levels in the water, putting residents at risk of lead poisoning.

The consequences of lead exposure are severe and can include reduced intellectual functioning, increased risk of attention deficit disorder, aggression, and long-term health issues such as kidney damage and cardiovascular problems. Children are especially vulnerable to the effects of lead, as it can impair their brain development and lead to behavioral and learning problems.

The crisis in Flint highlighted the need for proper water treatment and corrosion control to prevent lead leaching from aging pipes. It also brought attention to the broader issue of aging water infrastructure and the potential risks it poses to public health.

The Response to the Crisis

In response to the crisis, residents of Flint took action and advocated for their right to clean and safe water. Their efforts, along with the support of doctors, scientists, and journalists, brought attention to the severity of the situation.

Legal actions were also taken, with citizens and advocacy groups filing lawsuits against the city and state officials. These lawsuits sought to secure safe drinking water for Flint residents and address the issues of lead-contaminated water and inadequate infrastructure.

The Michigan Civil Rights Commission concluded that the poor governmental response to the crisis was a result of systemic racism, as Flint's population is predominantly Black and economically disadvantaged.

To address the immediate needs of residents, bottled water and water filters were distributed, and efforts were made to replace the aging pipes. However, the process of replacing the pipes took several years, and some residents still lacked access to safe drinking water even after the initial crisis had abated.

Long-Term Impacts and Lessons Learned

The Flint water crisis had lasting impacts on the community, with residents experiencing anxiety, depression, and other mental health issues due to the uncertainty and health risks associated with lead exposure. It also highlighted the need for stronger regulatory oversight and greater transparency and accountability from government officials.

The crisis served as a reminder that safe water is a human right and that aging water infrastructure can have severe consequences for public health. It led to calls for more stringent regulations and the replacement of lead pipes across the country.

The Flint water crisis also brought attention to the issue of environmental racism, as the predominantly Black and economically disadvantaged community of Flint bore the brunt of the crisis. It underscored the need for equitable access to safe drinking water and the importance of addressing systemic racism in policy-making and infrastructure development.

Ongoing Efforts for Improvement

Even years after the initial crisis, Flint continued to face challenges related to water quality and infrastructure. Efforts to replace lead pipes and improve water treatment processes were ongoing, but the trust of the residents had been damaged.

The crisis in Flint served as a catalyst for broader discussions and initiatives to improve water infrastructure and ensure safe drinking water for all communities. It highlighted the need for proactive measures, stringent regulations, and equitable solutions to protect public health and prevent similar crises from occurring in the future.

Legionnaires' disease outbreak

The Flint water crisis was a public health crisis that occurred in Flint, Michigan, between April 2014 and June 2016. During this period, the city's drinking water was contaminated with lead and possibly Legionella bacteria, exposing tens of thousands of residents to dangerous levels of lead and causing outbreaks of Legionnaires' disease, a severe form of pneumonia.

The crisis began when the city switched its water supply from Detroit's system to the Flint River in a cost-saving move. The river water was highly corrosive, and officials failed to treat it properly, leading to lead leaching out of aging pipes and into thousands of homes. Residents immediately noticed issues with the water's foul smell, taste, and appearance, but officials maintained that it was safe.

The inadequate treatment of the water also contributed to an outbreak of Legionnaires' disease, which killed at least 12 people and sickened at least 87 others. This outbreak was likely caused by the city's failure to maintain sufficient chlorine levels in its water mains, allowing Legionella bacteria to flourish.

The Michigan Civil Rights Commission concluded that the poor governmental response to the crisis was a result of systemic racism, as Flint's population is predominantly Black and about one-third live below the poverty line.

The crisis led to a series of legal actions and charges against state and local officials. However, despite some civil lawsuit successes, none of the individuals in power have faced criminal penalties for their actions.

Criminal charges and lawsuits

The Flint water crisis, which lasted from 2014 to 2016, led to several criminal charges and lawsuits. Here is a detailed overview:

Criminal Charges

In 2016, Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette announced an independent review to determine if any Michigan laws were violated during the Flint water crisis. This mission to criminally prosecute those responsible was continued by Attorney General Dana Nessel when she took office in 2019.

In 2021, nine people were charged by the attorney general's office, including former Governor Rick Snyder, Nick Lyon (director of Michigan's Department of Health and Human Services), and Dr Eden Wells (the state's chief medical executive).

However, in October 2023, the attorney general's office announced an end to the criminal prosecutions, citing legal setbacks. While Flint residents achieved success in some civil lawsuits, including a $626 million settlement in 2023, none of the individuals in power faced criminal penalties for their actions.

Lawsuits

In 2016, a coalition of citizens and groups, including Flint resident Melissa Mays, the local group Concerned Pastors for Social Action, the NRDC, and the ACLU of Michigan, sued the city and state officials to secure safe drinking water for Flint residents. They demanded the proper testing and treatment of water for lead and the replacement of all the city's lead pipes.

In March 2016, the coalition took further action, filing a motion to ensure that all residents, including children, the elderly, and those unable to reach the city's free water distribution centres, would have access to safe drinking water through bottled water delivery or a robust filter installation and maintenance programme.

In November 2016, a federal judge sided with Flint residents, ordering the government to provide every home with either a properly installed and maintained faucet filter or door-to-door delivery of bottled water.

A major settlement was reached in March 2017, requiring the city to replace thousands of lead pipes with funding from the state. It also guaranteed funding for comprehensive tap water testing, a faucet filter installation and education programme, free bottled water through the following summer, and continued health programmes to help residents deal with the residual effects of Flint's tainted water.

Despite these legal victories, the work of Flint residents and their advocates is not yet finished. Ensuring that the provisions of the 2017 settlement are met remains an ongoing task. Members of the lawsuit are still in court to ensure that the city properly manages its lead service line replacement programme.

In April 2024, it was reported that Flint still had thousands of homes requiring repairs for property damage caused by the lead pipe replacement programme, and the city had failed to meet its court-ordered deadlines to check the service line material at all eligible homes and replace the lead service lines.

Frequently asked questions